Open Mike 29/10/2026

64 comments on “Open Mike 29/10/2026”

Comment numbers have changed to permanent references. Older quoted numbers may no longer identify the same comment.

    1. 1.2

      And National is even closer to having no path to power. Actually, they are probably fucked on those figures once you account for TPM overhang with the extra overhang seat National created against themselves with their anti gang rant. Hopefully National's electorate vote collapses by a similar, or greater, amount and Mowbray's overhang wet dream turns into good day for Winston and David, and not so good for Simeon. Be interesting to see polling on the flippable Nat. electorates

      PS Took Mum out to vote at St Margret's in Frankton yesterday. Quite busy for a booth that now requires a planned effort to get to with the road works. And a happy positive vibe from the voters, and staff.

    2. 1.3

      I also think the attack ads that National have put up don't really work, it makes them look desperate, I saw that bizarre one on TV last night with the half shorn sheep & dogs, like WTF? & hearing Willis saying "the job is only half done" is so strangely self aware, like we know, you've only half wrecked the country we don't want you to completely wreck the place.

      1. 1.3.1

        … hearing Willis saying "the job is only half done" is so strangely self aware, like we know, you've only half wrecked the country we don't want you to completely wreck the place.

        yes My thoughts too when I saw that 'half-shorn sheep' campaign ad. And the CoC's enrolment suppression tactics for this “very, very tight” election have completely shorn more than a few Kiwis of their voting rights.

        https://www.salient.org.nz/post/controversial-amendments-not-recommended-by-anyone

        Enrolment for the 2026 General Election has now closed.
        Any applications to enrol or update your details will be processed after the election.
        https://vote.nz/enrolling/enrol-or-update/enrol-or-update-online

        The Electoral Amendment Act 2025 [Equal Justice Project, 9 April, 2026]
        Section 12 requires that there is a right to vote in New Zealand, which is held to a high threshold, protected, and considered important.
        …
        Democracy is about ensuring that people's voices are heard, and interpreting this principle in the best light should see the right to vote upheld and made as easy as possible for every New Zealander who wishes to exercise that right.

    3. 1.4

      Even if National lost 8 electorates, on this result they'd get 4-5 seat overhang on electorates. The presents a nightmare scenario for democracy of a weakened National party leading a government widely held to have been elected off the back of voter suppression, an electoral rort and therefore illegitimate, with a deeply unpopular, weak and ineffective PM shorn of all his senior list only MPs, at the beck and call of two extremist parties bent on culture wars and late stage neoliberal kleptocracy.

      Opportunity, assuming they make it, would be mad to go into coalition with the right under that scenario.

      1. 1.4.1

        If you read an article in this mornings rnz news, Wong hints at how difficult a coalition of the right would be.

        Not only would ACT have to be persuaded to adopt someone of TOPs bottom lines, but it would have to give up some of its own bottom lines to make room for them.

        Not in the article, but Wong's previously said about the differences with NZ1.

        Really difficult.

    4. 1.5

      Just to spell out the Reid Research numbers:

      Lab 30.6 Gre 14.5 TPM 1.9 =47.0 [Seats 60*]

      Nat 24.8 ACT 10.1 NZF 9.9 =44.8 [Seats 54]

      Opp 7.2 [Seats 9]

      *This assumes TPM/TTT get 5 seats with a 3 seat overhang.

      Opp still has the balance of power. I just heard on RNZ that Simeon Brown has called this poll "an outlier". Lets hope he is wrong. I don't want to pour cold water on it but the RNZ article says:

      "Both [pollsters] canvassed 1000 eligible voters, though Reid Research used online panels, while Verian split its interviews evenly between phone and online."

      To me nothing is better than ringing somebody up to ask who they are going to vote for. I wonder if any Standard readers have data showing the accuracy of Reid versus Verian?

        1. 1.5.2.1

          Weka…I have posted before (and so has Lprent) saying I don't think there will be a National overhang.

          I think the Nats will probably poll around 28 and so will qualify for 34 seats (28/98.5×120). If they lose 10 of the seats listed below to Labour, which is likely, there will be no overhang:

          Banks Peninsula, East Coast Bays, Hutt South, Maungakiekie, Mt Roskill, New Lynn, Wairarapa, West Coast/Tasman, Hamilton East, Hamilton West, Northland, Whanganui, New Plymouth, Otaki.

                  1. 1.5.2.1.1.1.1.1.1

                    I've seen two people say there will be an overhang because Labour is polling to low. I guess that means in the electorate that Labour needs to win, it doesn't because their party vote support is so low.

  1. 2

    It's interesting that Stanford has reinforced Luxon's message of not working with OP. Firstly, because the nats internal polls show them below 5%, so not a threat (really?), and secondly because

    'Stanford said she did not know what Opportunity stood for, saying it had a set of principles and then shelved them.
    "I think they're a bunch of flakes. What do they stand for, and what will they fall for? I don't know. They keep chipping and chopping, and I don't know who runs them." '

    This is the likely new nats leader, whom Wong fan-girrld gushingly recently, possibly in a suck-up before coalition talks. Wong won't be impressed.

    https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics_election-2026/2203754/erica-stanford-calls-opportunity-a-bunch-of-flakes

    And just for mikesh, see, even Stanford hates OP.

    1. 2.1

      Luxon, Brown, Stanford, Peters and Seymour are so arrogant that they are doing a great job of pushing Opp towards Labour.

      I have always been skeptical that Opp would get to 5%, but with the latest Verian 6.3 and Reid 7.2 they look a cert to make it into parliament.

    2. 2.2

      Farrah is a pretty good pollster so I suspect what he supplies to the Nats in private will be of a higher quality than the public facing polls that are at least in part designed to give results that help drive news cycles and shape voting patterns.

      1. 2.2.1

        And publically Stanford is giving swinging nat voters another push back into its arms. We know from the last coup attempt she's a brass-faced liar, so her internal polling statement cannot be trusted.

      2. 2.2.2

        Yep – Farrar will certainly be giving the Nats a true picture of the results. He has no incentive to do otherwise – if the Nats think he's a crap pollster who gets things wrong, they'll find someone else.

        Whereas, no such incentive to tell the truth applies to the result he supplies to the TPU. The Farrar-TPU relationship is therefore unconstrained in its potential for corruption – though whether this actually happens is still a matter of debate that requires real evidence to decide.

        1. 2.2.2.1

          Given that the polls released by the TPU, largely have results in the middle of the pack of general poll results – it seems unlikely that any actual corruption is going on (unless you're speculating that all pollsters are corrupt in the same direction).

          No pollster is going to keep their market (which is, BTW, not election polls but all of the rest of the market segmentation surveys) – if they lie to their customers.

          TBH – as far as I've seen all of the polls for the last year haven't shifted materially in the right/left divide – it's all just within the margin of error stuff. Individual parties have had upwards trajectories (e.g. Greens) but this has come at the expense of drops in other aligned parties (e.g. Left/TPM) [Same is true for NZF and National]

          The only wild-card has been TOP. Emerging as a 'centre' party – but with a particular generational target market. Not new to NZ politics (NZF did it first, with the golden oldie vote), but potentially a disruptor for this election.

      1. 2.4.2

        To get all vulgar (or somewhat vulgar) Marxist for a moment, we can think of what she is doing in education as dedicated to various processes of reproduction. The re-engineering of the primary and secondary education systems aims to do the following:

        1.) Produce narrowly-educated people who nevertheless possess the characteristics that existing employers favour- basic numeracy, literacy, deference to authority and 'financial literacy'. This reproduces a capitalist class

        2.) Give the children of middle class parents (who are not quite rich enough to afford private schools) a natural advantage over other children, because their home environments are more conducive to the habits that allow children to do well in such a school system. They will get better grades, get into more professional tertiary education courses and earn higher incomes over a lifetime. This allows the middle class to reproduce itself.

        3.) Have a curriculum that eliminates ideas that are uncomfortable – such as the history of the Treaty, and of colonial capitalism and extraction more generally. It is a preference for what in the USA gets called "patriotic education". This allows the National Party to reproduce itself.

        Outside education and more broadly – God knows what she stands for. I imagine she's another willing empty vessel that has had her head filled by nonsense from right-wing think tanks.

        1. 2.4.2.2

          There are a heck of a lot of middle class and working class parents (regardless of their political allegiance) who want their kids to come out of the school system able to read, write and calculate. This is a strong platform for National.

  2. 3

    Cost of Living, Healthcare, Unemployment – https://www.ipsos.com/en-nz/34th-ipsos-nz-issues-monitor-sept-2026

    MoRONS, Mowrees, No New Taxes – or ideas.

    Road cone crackdown gathers pace [Chris Bishop, 1 July 2026]
    The Government is fixing the basics by taking another step to end New Zealand's overuse of road cones…

    https://www.opportunity.org.nz/clean_up_politics

    Green Party seeks to cap political donations, stop companies donating [careful now RNZ, 22 Sept 2026]
    The Green Party wants to cap political donations at $30,000, stop companies from donating and set up a public register for lobbyists to get "big money" out of politics.

    The Greens have written two members' bills, the Electoral (Donations) Amendment Bill and the Regulation of Lobbying Bill, seeking to limit the influence of money and lobbying in government.

    Money dictating policy [1 Sept 2026]
    Matt Burgess left the New Zealand Initiative to become Prime Minister Christopher Luxon’s chief policy adviser, then received a lobbying document from Fonterra and Z Energy seeking a law change to shield major emitters from Mike Smith’s climate litigation — a document he also received on his personal email and never disclosed under the Official Information Act. The Ombudsman found the Prime Minister’s own office had unreasonably breached the OIA. The Government changed the climate law anyway.

  3. 4

    Ok, I'm gonna confess.

    I'm a beekeeper and I bought a bunch of non hive stuff a few years back and amongst it was the alphabet and numerals in stencils. This is for painting yr rego number on yr boxes.

    I have used them to cut out of corflute the words 'NO NEW NURSES'. This new stencil was to be used to spray paint on ACTs hoardings under 'NO NEW TAXES'.

    I've chickened out of doing it.

    1. 4.3

      It was virtuous to consider it in the first place, and also virtuous to not follow through.

      I think that such dilemmas – that we can laugh about now – might get uncomfortably real and serious if the CoC is re-elected.

    2. 4.5

      Cheers aj, AB and tWig.

      Wasn't an easy decision. In my heart of hearts, voting isn't the answer (I've voted already), we are up against lobbyists, donors, back room deals, sycophancy for the US…

      Our best hope is adhering to neo liberal dogma – 30% of GDP spend, is still comfortable having working folk on welfare and happy to subsidize landlords through the AS.

      Direct action is what is needed but it in this climate it gets painted as vandalism.

    3. 4.6

      Every time someone from the left 'vandalizes' election billboards, it validates the choice from the right to do the same.

      Given the financial disparity… right election campaigns are almost always better funded… this is not a winning strategy for the left.

    4. 4.7

      Every time someone from the right 'vandalises' election billboards, it validates the choice from the left to do the same.

      Given the financial disparity… right election campaigns are almost always better funded… this is a winning strategy for the right.

        1. 4.7.1.1

          So vandalism is a losing strategy for the left……

          And a winning strategy for the right – this election I’ve reattached a Party Vote GREEN hoarding to the fence three times – so far.

          Those staples don't come cheap yanno, and the hoarding itself is looking a little worst for wear.

          If only the right restricted their vandalism to election hoardings, NZ would be the better for it, imho.

          1. 4.7.1.1.1

            And, since we're talking about election hoardings and the disparity of funding between political parties of the left and right, I should have mentioned Party Vote GREEN – For All of Us, or at the very least For the Many, Not the Few.


            Chris Slane, in the New Zealand Listener, 28 Sept 2026

  4. 6

    Benny has a sook.

    Benjamin Netanyahu – בנימין נתניהו

    @netanyahu

    Translated from Hebrew

    Likud: The elections in the State of Israel were stolen by Arab parties that support terrorism and the elimination of the Jewish state through serious criminal offenses of bribery, threats, violence, forgeries, and the use of prohibited software to mobilize voters

    […]

    We demand from the police and the Shin Bet a thorough investigation into the election theft by the Arab parties and the full prosecution of the criminals.

    https://xcancel.com/netanyahu/status/2115479434169868618

    1. 6.1

      My first grim thought was 'pogroms in Israel’, as Likud and far-right supporters take out their frustrations on Israeli Palestinians.

      1. 6.1.1

        Richard Silverstein isn't quite as pessimistic.

        What does this defeat portend for Netanyahu? After five terms and endless protests against his cynical policies, he may be at the end of the road. Though of course he is the political vampire who continually rises from the dead. So he can’t be fully counted out. Nevertheless, any other leader facing such a defeat would be removed from Party leadership. Netanyahu is no normal leader. But neither is he immortal. This may be the final curtain.

        Eisenkot’s Jewish coalition partners finished with a disappointing 48 seats. Considering the hatred which many Israelis feel toward the prime minister, it’s astonishing his parties did so poorly. This result has thrown him on the mercy of the Israeli-Palestinians. A place he does not want to be.

        Eisenkot failed to generate excitement because he is a terrible, marble-mouthed speaker. His message, such as it was, offered little more than the amorphous “change.” Israelis are generally very cynical about election politics. While they flock to candidates who really seem to offer change, or a new approach, they remain unmoved by the traditional Jewish parties. They’ve been burned repeatedly in the past in terms of their expectations. The Opposition leader failed to resonate because he played it safe. “Safe” in Israeli politics means the status quo, which is disastrous.

        https://www.richardsilverstein.com/2026/10/28/palestinian-parties-unprecedented-victory-makes-them-kingmakers/

        https://x.com/richards1052

      1. 8.1.3

        Both TonyV, that's word productivity – we must up our productivity we are told. What we can do then, just look out! We aren't drones by any means.

  5. 9

    Great work by Green MP Scott Willis at the election debate in Wanaka this week. He said, among other things:

    "On the topic of energy reliability and soaring power bills, Green MP Scott Willis drew some of the loudest applause of the night as he rejected proposals for imported liquefied natural gas (LNG) in favour of renewables.

    "We will take 200 million from the government subsidy for fossil fuels and put it into community energy … so we can have peer-to-peer electricity systems.”"

    The National Party candidate got a roasting on fast-track.

  6. 10

    Billionaires in California have spent US$612,000,000 on influencing legislation in California, half of it fighting a Wealth Tax.

    "The possibility of a tax on their assets has drawn more than US$293 million from at least 30 California billionaires, the majority of whom made their fortunes in tech ….."

  7. 11

    Congratulations on National on running the most efficient emergency department in Waitakere.
    If we ignore the fact that it scarcely treats any patients it is a wondrous model of the CoC’s New Zealand.
    We absolutely have saved the cost of the salary of any nurse that would have been appointed to the department. Wonderful management.

    And it saves on the cost of feeding patients by having none. In water, electricity and other costs it leads the countries emergency departments in savings.

    Huzzah for Simeon Brown, Chris Luxon, and all the dickheads with them.

    Guess the front fell off? That is exceptionally rare, except in these cases of government crony capitalism, failed ideology and mismanagement.

  8. 12

    Interesting from Gordon Campbell: https://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/HL2610/S00072/on-how-trump-peter-thiel-and-ice-may-gain-access-to-your-most-personal-bio-data.htm

    ,,,To date, the EU has been the most comprehensive source of information about the EBSP. Enhanced Border Security Partnership (EBSP) This initial EU discussion document by the EU Data Protection Supervisor raised a number of red flags that should be of similar concern here, too. For starters, he recommended the personal scop[e] of the framework agreement should be defined exhaustively and narrowly, and in line with EU laws on data sharing:…

    …Footnote: Bernard Keane’s valiant efforts to get information that sheds light on the EBSP process have not been entirely fruitless. Belatedly, he has obtained a much redacted DFAT document that usefully indicates the sweeping nature of the US demands. According to the document : :

    The EBSP requires partners to ensure that DHS can screen the biometric records of:

    • Travellers to the US who are Australian citizens or have a nexus with Australia;
    • Applicants for US benefits or protection; and
    • Individuals encountered in a border and immigration context in the US.

    As Keane comments: The phrase “nexus with Australia” is new and dramatically expands the people whose data would be targeted by the US, including anyone who has visited Australia, or has a visa to enter Australia, or has any other kind of connection to Australia, including holding an Australian passport (it’s estimated that up to 1 million people holding Australian passports live overseas). It also confirms that this will not be confined to biometric data linked to criminal records, but all available biometric data.

    There is no reason to think that the US will be any less aggressive in its demands for access to the personal data of New Zealanders, or of those who may have any kind of “nexus” with New Zealand.

    Footnote Two: In case you’re wondering what “biometric data” involves, there’s a simple explanation available here.

    [Biometric data]can include fingerprints, facial features, iris or retina patterns, DNA, voice, typing rhythm, walking style, or how you sign your name. Biometric logins have become popular in consumer tech because they make it faster and easier to access your devices.

    Because these traits are uniquely tied to an individual, biometric data is often used for security and authentication, like unlocking phones or passing through border control. It’s considered highly sensitive since misuse or breaches can have irreparable impact on your personal privacy…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *