Open Mike 27/10/2026

81 comments on “Open Mike 27/10/2026”

Comment numbers have changed to permanent references. Older quoted numbers may no longer identify the same comment.

      1. 2.1.2

        The billboard ads were created by the Campaign Company, owned by Taxpayers' Union boss Jordan Williams.

        The poisonous TPU strikes back! It's Dirty Politics – Dirty Work – expensive work even – and Jordan Williams is well paid to do it.

        Why I laughed when I was sounded out for a seat on the Taxpayers’ Union board [Newsroom, 30 Sept 2026]
        Sunlight is the best disinfectant and that’s what Nicky Hager has exposed the Taxpayers’ Union to

        [comment]
        I bought Dirty Work yesterday and have got to page 60. It’s obvious that those who say “there’s nothing in it” have listened to the rubbish the Taxpayers Non-Union have told them what to think. Hager has pulled the curtains back and exposed just how this odorific outfit works. Next time a journalist just republishes a press release from the gaggle of organizations which all reside in the same office in Auckland they are handing their journalistic ethics to sleaze-bags. These guys don’t want NZ to be a decent society where everybody has a chance of flourishing. They want a dog-eat-dog society which behaves just like them; nasty and selfish.

        The nACTf Hollow Men & Women are a corporate lobbyist's wet dream – 'govt' by and for the sorted – trashing NZ for per$onal gain.

        I understand that Matt Burgess no longer works in CEO Luxon's office.

        The octopus that turned on National [Grant McLachlan, 1 Sept 2026]
        Money dictating policy
        Matt Burgess left the New Zealand Initiative to become Prime Minister Christopher Luxon’s chief policy adviser, then received a lobbying document from Fonterra and Z Energy seeking a law change to shield major emitters from Mike Smith’s climate litigation — a document he also received on his personal email and never disclosed under the Official Information Act. The Ombudsman found the Prime Minister’s own office had unreasonably breached the OIA. The Government changed the climate law anyway.

        Associate Health Minister Casey Costello followed the same pattern with tobacco. A leaked Philip Morris lobbying strategy named the Taxpayers’ Union and the New Zealand Initiative as positions the company could leverage to reach New Zealand First. Costello then cut the excise on heated tobacco products by 50 percent, and the Chief Ombudsman later found she had acted “unreasonable and contrary to law” in withholding related documents.

        Two ministries, two donor-aligned outcomes, two tentacles doing the reaching.

  1. 3

    "Precipitous decline" and "breath takingly incompetent" are two takes of the impact of the war in Iran. Appointees woefully out of their depth. Iran using it's super power in closing the Strait of Hormuz.

    Touches on the Ukraine war and how Putin will always just double down and how his life expectancy is lower now than before the war.

    Always interesting and informative, Sarah Paine in a 30 minute excerpt. Although I missed the drone part referenced in the title.

    https://youtu.be/HlDXGOJAzyM?si=qXW-pqm1cnwh0yJb

      1. 4.2.1

        Where have they been indeed….plus the ferries, water done well, cost of infrastructure projects cancelled and seymours ministry of mates to name but a few.

        Billions in wasteful behaviour and spending hardly gets a mention.

    1. 4.4

      Profit-driven private capital vulture culture – thanks Simeon. https://x.com/domesticanimal/status/2109014866338230589

      Publicly funded healthcare, social insurance and justice in Aotearoa New Zealand [NZ Medical Journal, 14 Aug 2026]
      This viewpoint article focusses on how resource constraints in New Zealand's public healthcare system have allowed the private health sector to grow and become the default provider of many non-urgent services and often also urgent or time-critical care, a process of "creeping privatisation". Increasingly, patients without the means to access care privately are significantly disadvantaged.
      …
      The New Zealand case shows how the private sector undermines and erodes the public sector, creating significant concerns for health equity, social solidarity and long-term sustainability.

  2. 5

    I've been pondering the negotiations between Labour and Opp should the election outcome give Opp the balance of power. To me it is easy.

    Labour should offer Opp a Land Tax similar to the one in the Opp manifesto saying that this will be used to fund the hugely underfunded public health system.

    The Greens and TPM will be happy to support this. It will be a major coup for Opp that they would be happy to accept, and Labour can justify it by quoting the report that came out today that shows that 80% of the increase in public health funding ($2.4 billion of $3 billion) has been given to private health providers over the last three years. Effectively public money is subsidising the profits of private companies while the public system crumbles.

    The beauty of this is that National cannot offer a Land Tax because neither they nor ACT support it.

    1. 5.1

      LVT is a regressive asset tax to move property out of ownership by the poor while ignoring other assets the rich control. No, dumb idea for leftist governments.

      1. 5.1.2

        100%

        Very frustrating to see this from the left because the Greens have a much better suite of policies that protect low income people and that OP can probably get on board with.

        1. 5.1.2.1

          Agree Weka that there are other capital tax options that could be traded. But I suggested the LT because it is supported by Opp. For instance in the survey referenced by Chairman below, a Wealth Tax is popular with the public.

          To offer something in negotiations that Opp have not previously supported might muddy the water.

          1. 5.1.2.1.1

            Wong has said they are no wedded to their own ideas, but will work with other parties to get the best policy.

            you are still ignoring the impact on low income people. Seriously, why are you doing this?

            1. 5.1.2.1.1.1

              I'm talking about wealth redistribution measures such as a wealth or land tax that taxes the top 5% so that this money can be used for, among other things, a better public health service to serve the less well off people.

              Not sure what your problem is with this.

              1. 5.1.2.1.1.1.1

                OP LVT would apply on the land that everyone's homes are on.

                It's not a wealth tax, it's a land tax. It wouldn't tax the top 5% (see the Greens policy for welath tax). It would tax all land with some exceptions. Read OP's policy.

                Landlords, would pass on the tax via rents.

                My problem is you promoting a LVT instead of an actual wealth tax that taxes actual super wealthy people.

                Read AB's comment as well, about the removal of intergenerational wealth recycling. People who bought cheap back in the day when many more people could afford to buy a home can leave their home to their kids atm. Tax the capital gains, and inheritance, but at least leave something, the only thing those kids might have in order to get ahead in life. LVT would remove that.

      2. 5.1.3

        Unless the land tax is accompanied by a "citizens' income", I think the Opportunity Party should not make such an offer. It is not in their interests that the two items should be separated.

      3. 5.1.4

        to move property out of ownership by the poor

        Just the opposite I'd have thought. If it serves to bring down property values, the poor will more often get to own property.

        1. 5.1.4.1

          Only if the poor are not also beneficiaries or superannuitants. They certainly won't be able to afford any land tax from the benefit or super.

      1. 5.2.1

        People think it's fine because no one has explained all the implications to them properly. All they see is "old people hoard land". They don't see, "No, the rich hoard assets."

    2. 5.3

      LAND TAXES HARM LOW INCOME PEOPLE.

      shouting because too many people on the left are ignoring this. The only way OP's LVT half way works is if you pair it with a UBI, which mitigates some of the cost for low and low/med income households. Otherwise it would be an unmitigated disaster for home owners and renters alike.

      There are better ways to fund health etc.

      1. 5.3.1

        If Labour agreed to bring back Land Tax, I really doubt that it would apply to family homes in which case it seems like the effect on poor people would be minimal to none.

          1. 5.3.1.1.1

            I agree with Craig here, Weka.

            Who are all these poor people owning assets (apart from their family family home which is exempt) that are going to suffer?

            1. 5.3.1.1.1.1

              I already said in the comment you replied to.

              If you are talking about a LVT that excludes the family home, you need to say so. OP's policy includes the family home.

              1. 5.3.1.1.1.1.1

                Taking that further, OP's rationale is that we 'as a nation' are over-invested in property. And that therefore, 'we as a nation' must suffer an LVT being applied. We're all sinners on the property ladder, and we all must pay the price, even if we're accidental passive investors, is their message. (Take your eye off the rich).

                1. 5.3.1.1.1.1.1.1

                  yep. And investment culture (which needs fixing because of the sinners) trumps community and whanau, which are downstream of the economy and investment instead of at the centre.

            1. 5.3.1.1.2.1

              if you think landlords won't try and increase rents if their costs go up by thousands of dollars per year, I have a bridge to sell you.

              Yes, obviously, if supply outstrips demand by a big enough margin rents will fall. But landlords still have to find the cash from somewhere every year, so they will try and get it from tenants.

              1. 5.3.1.1.2.1.1

                That hasn't been the case.

                Rent rises lost their relationship with landlord costs, years ago.

                Of course the accommadation supplements, and other subsidies for landlords, have allowed them to raise rents regardless of their actual costs..

        1. 5.3.1.2

          Yes. The Labour Party seem too dumb to understand that no tax will have any ameliorative effect on our dysfunctional housing market unless they are prepared to extend that tax to "family homes".

          1. 5.3.1.2.1

            And you’re too dumb to understand the way politics works in NZ and even less so the election strategy of the Labour Party. You favour a Party that puts the least popular tax (LVT) on the table and then quickly sweeps it under the rug and your favoured Party may not even make it into Parliament let alone into Government. You’re too dumb to understand that taxing assets is not all about the money and how Government pays for things.

      2. 5.3.2

        I think that the outcome (and I suspect also the purpose) of a land value tax as formulated by OPP will be to concentrate home ownership into fewer and fewer hands. In retirement, incomes drop dramatically for people without additional wealth over and above their house. Sustaining home ownership during this time is already difficult for many people because it costs so much (rates, insurance, repairs and maintenance) . LVT will be an extra impost for people whose state pensions have also been replaced by an even less adequate 'Citizen's Income'.

        Houses will be sold and more large-scale corporate landlords will appear – as will and more life-long renters who won't have the sorts of protections that life-long renters in other (mostly European) countries currently have. It will in the long run 'proletarianise' the lower reaches of the middle class by removing the intergenerational recycling of housing wealth (capital) among non-wealthy citizens.

        1. 5.3.2.1

          Nothing we didn't know and discuss here already. But no one political has even addressed this on the national stage. Grey Power should have been all over it.

        2. 5.3.2.3

          I think that the outcome (and I suspect also the purpose) of a land value tax as formulated by OPP will be to concentrate home ownership into fewer and fewer hands.

          Before making a statement like that you should be prepared to provide evidence, or at the very least some logical reason why that might be the case. You have provided neither.

          A land tax would be accompanied by a citizen’s income. We won’t get one without the other.

          1. 5.3.2.3.1

            A land tax would be accompanied by a citizen’s income. We won’t get one without the other.

            Well, then that’s the dumbest way of addressing our dysfunctional housing market and thus amounts to business as usual because we won’t get either and thus, we will get neither.

          2. 5.3.2.3.2

            In the case of retired people on low incomes (i.e. superannuation with minimal savings), will the citizens income merely replace one low income with another low income – essentially having an income-neutral effect? If that's the case, LVT absolutely is an extra impost that will result in some low-income people having to sell their houses because of it.

            It seems quite rational to think that's a likely outcome. And the same applies to believing that many of these houses will end up in the portfolios of mega-landlords whose scale of operation means that land taxes are a manageable cost across a large portfolio – especially where extra costs such as land taxes can be transferred onto tenants.

            1. 5.3.2.3.2.1

              Still have to pay the LVT on top of your UBI-equivalent pension or state benefit, and current rates/insurance costs. If you don't have the money, the state 'reverse mortgages' you.

              Found this out from the OP ‘calculator’ page.

              Plus LVT will be ‘tax-deductible’ for landlords.

    3. 5.4

      According to one recent poll, the Green's wealth tax had a healthy 64% support.

      https://www.greens.org.nz/tax_system_for_all

      Also on the survey list was a wealth tax – an approach the Greens support – defined as “a 2.5% tax on an individual’s net assets above $10 million with an exemption for family homes”.

      A healthy majority, 64%, supported the introduction of such a tax, with 26% against the idea and 10% answering don’t know.

      https://thespinoff.co.nz/politics/24-09-2026/how-new-zealanders-really-feel-about-tax-exclusive-poll-results

      1. 5.4.1

        A wealth tax minus the family home is far better than a universal LVT that captures the family home and then has the Govt giving back per a UBI to those who have been impoverished by the LVT.

        A tax, it used to be called a land tax, could come in at times when there is a change in the way the land is held. So on sale/transfer including per a will when say 2.5% could be claimed over say $10m. The figure and the % could be flexible.

        But there is a cost to this and those and the gains would need to be carefully investigated as well as the ease that it could be circumvented. Also we need to be sure that such extra $$$ is truly needed as there is long standing tax philosophy that no more than is needed should be taxed. Also would keeping the tax rates and bands up to date achieve more than extra taxes such as a wealth tax?

        ETA Oh dear I’m off-side with Hon Hipkins with my thoughts about raising the % in the tax bands….I’ll clearly have to do better!

    4. 5.5

      Unless the land tax is accompanied by a "citizens' income", I think the Opportunity Party should not make such an offer. It is not in their interests that the two items should be separated.

  3. 6

    Rumours that Trump proposes Orban, backed by Russia and China, for UN Secretary Genetal. Another known candidate is from the UAE, and is criticised for coming from a regime arming genocide in Sudan.

    Those who denounce the UN’s value and claim it's toothless sure seem keen on getting one of their own at the top. The last few General Secretaries clearly had too much "suicidal empathy" for those suffering in the world. Perhaps the UN is more powerful than it is made to look.

    1. 6.1

      The UAE is funding warfare in africa and lawfare in the UK via its ownership of manchester city.

      Premier League estimated to have spent around 200mill pounds so far going toe to toe with them which every other club pays for.

  4. 8

    I really hate OP now, because instead of me voting Greens for their excellent platform to rejuvenate a left government (and I've always voted Labour), OP force me to vote strategically for Hipkins' anaemic offering. And I don't even trust OP's claim they will 'go with' the highest-polling party. Like a tarted-up party girl. We can write off anything Luxon claims the nats will do as lies.

    I really, REALLY hate OP.

    1. 8.1

      it's grim as. I'm in the same position except I'm a lifetime Green voter. I'm not voting until election day and will be looking at any polls between now and then. Which is a shitty way to have to vote.

      I think it's unlikely OP would reneg on talking first with the highest polling party (or seats whatever), but not impossible, and Peters set the bar for this kind of centrist bollocks. I also consider the position OP have on this to be powermongering that is beneath them and I haven't seen a good explanation from them on this.

      I've also not seen anyone really talking about the fact that the left bloc could have more seats then the right, but National have more seats the Labour and thus OP give National the government (or vice versa).

      It's a very centrist, FFP-esque mentality.

      1. 8.1.2

        I’ll have to vote tactically as well, with both my ticks, but if that’s what it takes to get rid of this sorry excuse of a Government, so be it.

      2. 8.1.3

        Exactly. By going with party, not wing, they can derail a left win. This came to me the other night. And today after writing my comment, I thought, this feels like the old FFP days.

      1. 8.3.1

        Gee, mikesh, fair critique is not bias. You, for example, have failed at almost every level to address any of the issues that I've pointed out, except for giving a mild character reference for that Jessica woman.

        I hate OP because they have narrowed my voting choice. By being new, it is impossible to make a good call on their decisions if elected. Even if they do not get into Parliament, they have reduced this election solely to the centre, and a neo-lib centre at that.

      1. 8.4.1

        OP have literally said they will form government with the party with the most seats. That's either National or Labour. If we want to change the government, then Labour has to get the highest number of seats. It's not paranoia it's maths.

        1. 8.4.1.1

          No certainty that OP will keep their word.

          Just that we know Luxon will talk to OP, or the money behind National, will replace him with someone that will.

      2. 8.4.2

        mikesh you should be dancing with Belladonna at the Secret Politicians Ball (shades of Beatles). You two both seem paranoid. The rest of us are just obsessed with getting a Party/ies which will address the nation's needs in a clever, knowing, practical and straightforward manner.

        1. 8.4.2.1

          Are you implying that I support TOP? I'm not sure which element of my commentary would have led you to that conclusion.

          Or is there some other area that you perceive me as being paranoid?

      1. 8.5.1

        I think they said recently that it may take a while for this to happen ( sorry can't find the link) If that is true they maybe able to work with both as long as they agree to "look into it" as they like to say

    2. 8.6

      I'll be making the same calculation – though I'm less conflicted over it. Swarbrick seems to talk more sense on economic matters than any other leader*, but I'd like to force Wong into talking to Hipkins first. I don't see it as a sort of helpless 'lesser evilism', but more as a proactive 'greater goodism' . Because if it works, we get a Government that includes both the 'very significantly less evil' party and the 'not really evil at all' party. MMP makes it easier.

      *which is why the Nat campaign rhetoric is so obsessed by her

      1. 8.6.1

        may main problem is I want more Green MPs in government and this is the first election where that's been a real possibility. But otherwise agree, and thank for your reframe as well.

  5. 9

    Im particularly interested in some things in NZAO such as firefighters who are a great bunch and probably sorely tried by the vacuous, callous neolib managers over them. However Martyn at TDB has been looking at River van der Velden's flood of FENZ with demands out of the old-fashioned song playbook about cutting out the fat from gummint, (such a good old nitty ditty). Excerpt: https://thedailyblog.co.nz/brooke-van-velden-fenz-distraction-campaign-wins/

    …On the 15th of September a scathing review into FENZ found 30 new fire trucks bought over the last decade weren’t in service due to incompetence and grotesque mismanagement.

    Two days after that report, Minister Brooke Van Velden suddenly loses confidence in the CEO not because they buggered up 30 firetrucks while the fleet grows older and breaks down, but because of some boring thing regarding administration.

    Brooke Van Velden has ignored the Union telling her every single month since she came to power that the fire trucks were breaking down.

    A damning report proves everything the Union told her over the last 3 years was true yet the straw that broke Brookes back was ‘FENZs administration of its levy scheme’???

    Could it be that the Minister has found the most boring technical thing to focus on because as Minister, she required FENZ to make $60m in savings?…

    1. 9.1

      lprent – my name and email don't come up – is this permanent? If needed for scam safety I don't mind but will you advise. And second I can't get Bold to work from the choice panel. Thanks for keeping all bright and tight though.

        1. 9.1.1.1

          The old auto fill behaviour in Name and Email fields has disappeared, so I've got to type these in every comment, but these fields don't seem to grab your cursor like they did. Was the auto fill removed to fix the cursor grab?

          Also the Replies tab doesn't work for me, even though I'm using the same browser window I've commented on.

          Safari 27.0.1 on MacOS 27.0.1

            1. 9.1.1.1.1.1

              Confirming that the same issue is happening for me. Both for desktop and mobile. Windows and Firefox desktop. Android Google Chrome mobile.

        2. 9.1.1.3

          I have to put name and email in box before I can comment. I can present first letter to bring up drop-down and highlight the info but every time now which I didn't have to before. And I can't bold words in my comments though Italics is OK.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *