Calculated cruelty

National continues in its attempt to dominate media by announcing outlandish policies. Today it was going for a twofor.

It has announced as policies random drug testing for beneficiaries and benefit cuts for those unfortunate enough to be on the jobseeker benefit for two years or more.

From Radio New Zealand:

National is promising to introduce random drug testing for those on the jobseeker benefit to ensure they’re “ready for work”.

A policy document released by the party said New Zealanders were regularly required to pass drug tests to get or keep a job and it was “not too much to ask” that people getting Jobseeker Support take “reasonable steps to remain work-ready”.

The announcement is part of a five-point plan that wants to “remain focused on employment”, and is “fair and affordable for taxpayers.”

National’s Social Development and Employment spokesperson Louise Upston made the announcement in Paraparaumu on Thursday morning.

Upston said it would start with 10,000 tests in the first year and expand over time.

National expects the policy to cost around $1.5 million per annum and be funded from MSD baselines. The savings are expected to be just over $580 million from 2027/28 to 2030/31.

“Under our policy, a first failed test will be recorded and a second failed test will trigger a clinical alcohol and drug assessment.

“Where someone then fails to meet their obligations, the normal sanctions regime will apply, which could include reductions to their benefit.”

Upston claims that the policy wasn’t about “punishing someone because they haven’t found a job” but was to make sure people receiving Jobseeker Support met “reasonable” expectations to be ready for work.

But her statement is conflicted by the second part of the policy which will clearly punish those who have not been able to find a job within two years.

Under the policy single Jobseeker recipients without children will lose $48 per week, couples without children would lose $82 per week and Jobseeker recipients with dependent children around $24 less per week.

The announcements are calculated cruelty. And they underscore how bad National has been at creating jobs.

Christopher Luxon had set his government a target of no more than 140,000 kiwis on jobseeker but had missed this terribly with the September figure being 218,000.

The drug testing is red meat to its supporters. Beating up on beneficiaries always goes down well with its base.

The justification is that treasury is predicting 220,000 new jobs over the next four years. But things are dire now. Given that Luxon is so far off his target there is no guarantee that the Treasury prediction will be any more accurate.

All that the change will do is make chronically unemployed people poorer and more desperate. Already anyone who loses a job over the age of 60 is finding it really hard to get a job. This will just build in extra misery.

30 comments on “Calculated cruelty”

  1. 1

    "National continues in its attempt to dominate media by announcing outlandish policies."

    And it's working just as planned, the media won't shut up about it.

  2. 2

    If there was random drug testing at ACT Party gatherings the results might be interesting.

    I'm surely not the only one who has heard whispers about white substances being snorted in the back rooms behind the clean image.

      1. 2.1.1

        You think, Belladonna, that people attending Green Party meetings have partaken of "white substances"?

        That's just stupid.

              1. 2.1.1.1.1.1.1

                Waste of screen space to carry on pointed barbs Bella. When you can make an good argument you are great but otherwise like nursery rhyme behaviour – When good…when bad horrid. Go for small humorous and ironic to have a go will you? I want better sneers.

                1. 2.1.1.1.1.1.1.2

                  Some people do seem to get a kick out of finding fault and telling others off. We can choose not to descend to their level.

                  NZ has a history of politicians relentlessly modelling cruel behaviour – that's well past its BB date, imho.

                  Benefit sanctions: Government building 'a legacy of cruelty', critics say [careful now RNZ, 19 Feb 2024]

                  Comfortably Numb [Nick Rockel, 9 Oct 2026]
                  National resorts to bashing beneficiaries.

                  It was predictable and a sad indictment of a government that lacks any vision for NZ. Instead of releasing its fiscal plan or a new policy to help those struggling, National has resorted to beneficiary-bashing to appeal to potential voters.

                  "Predictable"? Whatcha talkin bout, Nick?

                  Dr Jonathan Coleman, Health Minister for the last 3 years of the Key/English govt, says drug-testing beneficaries won't work.

                  https://www.rnz.co.nz/national/programmes/middayreport/audio/2019055687/former-national-govt-health-minister-against-random-drug-tests

                  Imho, it's already working as intended.


                  Body, 2026 – https://bsky.app/profile/bodycartoon.bsky.social <> Slane, 2013 – https://natlib.govt.nz/records/32240537

            1. 2.1.1.1.1.2

              B seldom passes up an opportunity to bag the political left, and yes – that does get a bit stale here.
              Anyhoo, Luxy's 'drug testing' is a distraction, like his MMP referendum and multiple 'urgent' caucus meetings smiley

              https://thestandard.nz/coalitions-problem-bullshit-doesnt-conceal-poor-performance/

              “Not everything that is faced can be changed. But nothing can be changed until it is faced.” – James Baldwin

              Sliding in the polls, have a crack at beneficiaries: National's drug test policy follows a well-worn pattern [The Spinoff, 8 October 2026]
              None of that will trouble National because the policy is not meant to get anyone into work. Social development minister Louise Upston says this "isn't about punishing someone because they haven't found a job". Of course it is. The cruelty is the point. It stokes a popular prejudice that unemployment is a personal failing, and it lets the government off the hook for its failed economic management.

                1. 2.1.1.1.1.2.1.1

                  Sliding in the polls, have a crack at beneficiaries: National's drug test policy follows a well-worn pattern [The Spinoff, 8 October 2026]

                  If the drug testing is a distraction – then why follow up on it?

                  Possibly because I'm easily distracted – one of my many cruel failings.
                  Well well, will you look at that / Nat – I've bolded "drug testing" and "distraction" for the readers.
                  A "well-worn pattern" indeed – worn out even – but some still appear to get a kick out of it.


                  Chris Slane, 2013 – https://natlib.govt.nz/records/32240537

                  Depicts Prime Minister John Key as puppet master operating a Punch and Judy show for the public. Punch is played by Social Development Minister Paula Bennet who is bashing a solo mother with children with a bat labelled 'benefit cuts'. The audience is calling for Punch to "Bash the Benie". Refers to major social welfare reforms bought in by Bennett which are expected to cut thousands of people off benefits and penalise solo parents. Reforms include reducing all existing benefits to three new categories, drug testing, clearing outstanding warrants for arrest, requiring all sickness, mental health patient and solo parent beneficiaries to look for work (see Otago Daily Times 15 July 2013). This cartoon suggests that Key is the behind the scenes architect of the reforms, and that the reforms are a entertainment and distraction for the public.

  3. 3

    Oh how they gonna pick who randomly get tested, open and honest racial profiling? Or throw a few whiteys in for looks??

    Epsom unemployed or mostly otara??

  4. 4

    Well CoC don't wish to be blamed for the number on benefts do they?

    Must be those lazy bludgers taking drugs and getting your taxes are to blame!!

    I agree with Winston to my surprise!! It is bordering on fascist.

    I thought of you Kay. Such cruel blame games.

    Distraction from the awful debate by Luxon..

  5. 5

    Tried and true right wing pre election dog whistling.

    Shows their assessment of the moral compass of potential National voters.

    Bash Māori is a bit ho hum, as they have already done that.

    Those on welfare, are next!

  6. 6

    The drug testing of people on Jobseeker benefit is nothing but cynical headline grabbing and reinforcing negative stereotypes.

    Any New Zealander who’s feeling the pain of the cost-of-living crisis could ask the question if such drug testing will make a difference.

    High unemployment tells us nothing about the character of the unemployed. It tells us there are not enough jobs. When the Great Depression left as many as three in 10 New Zealand workers without a job, it was not because they had all lost the will to work. The economic system had collapsed.

    […]

    … the government has made a bad situation worse.

    […]

    It is cynical politics and it follows a well-worn pattern. National has a crack at beneficiaries whenever it needs red meat for a conference or wants a bump in the polls near election time.

    https://thespinoff.co.nz/politics/08-10-2026/sliding-in-the-polls-have-a-crack-at-beneficiaries-nationals-drug-test-policy-follows-a-well-worn-pattern [Neale Jones]

    Yes, but those tests will catch at least some drug users, Right?

    The tests will find next to nothing. We know because jobseekers have had to pass a drug test for any job that requires one since 2013. In the year to June 2018, 47,115 were referred to those jobs. Just 170 failed, and that figure included people who did not turn up. That is 0.36% of referrals, probably lower than you'd find in most workplaces on any given day.

    It’s definitely much lower than the overall positivity rate of 3.3% of ‘random’ roadside first screening tests for drugs of drivers across the country during the first six months it was in place.

    https://thespinoff.co.nz/society/02-09-2026/six-months-of-roadside-drug-testing-in-new-zealand-by-the-numbers

    So, an ineffectual policy, as sold by Louise Upston, and she’s been caught false advertising again.

    1. 6.1

      "So, an ineffectual policy, as sold by Louise Upston, and she’s been caught false advertising again."

      She don't care.

  7. 7

    This is how it works:

    • Step 1: National gets elected
    • Step 2: Lots of currently employed people think to themselves, "Yay National have been elected, they are super-generous with welfare. I'm going to chuck in my job and have a cruisy time on the benefit!"
    • Step 3: Unemployment goes up
    • Step 4: National says: "You people are being lazy, we're going to cut your benefits and test you for drugs."
    • Step 5: Those people who chucked in their jobs say: "Damn that sucks, because there are stuff all jobs around at the moment. Oh well, I'll just have to wait till National get elected again because they are super generous with welfare and then I can have a cruisy time again."

    It's all perfectly logical – just like National's welfare policy.

  8. 8

    But there's more, mad irresponsible policy which makes it irresistible to Natfactache.

    Here is some Gordon Campbell being quietly devastatingly thoughtful about cutting our foreign aid (which mostly goes to the Pacific, our friendly neighbours. My colouring addition.)

    https://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/HL2610/S00021/on-the-centre-right-laying-traps-for-winston-peters.htm

    …The political infighting aside, the plan to reduce foreign aid in order to help Pharmac buy more new drugs is the kind of thing you’d expect from a banana republic. In a truly first world country, these things would not be an either/or. We need to fund both, adequately.

    The notion that foreign aid is a wasteful handout to foreigners is false. As the MFAT website says, almost 60% of our $1.2 billion annual foreign aid budget goes to our Pacific neighbours, and reflects “our shared community interest in the prosperity and stability of the region….” …

    Proposing to loot the foreign aid biscuit tin without much prior warning or without any consideration of how this might impact on our aid partners – or on the international reputation of New Zealand as a reliable partner in development – is reckless, and irresponsible of National and ACT. Peters has called it “dangerous” and “desperate.” On this occasion, he’s right….

Comments are closed.