Open Mike 18/11/2026

15 comments on “Open Mike 18/11/2026”

  1. 1

    Wayne Brown joined a tour of China with a group of NZ businesspeople. The take-away? “Democracy’s had its day. It’s time for something else”.

    Something more like the amalgamation of Auckland’s councils, that was forced on most of them without their wanting it, perhaps? Wayne Brown, Mayor until one of his relatives is appointed as his replacement, perhaps?

    Nationally, Chairman Luxon, dictator for life. perhaps?

    In a Seymour/Swarbrick joint-agreement kind of way, I think I can find common ground with Wayne Brown. Not that I think Democracy’s not the best thing for the bottom 90%, just that it was done away with during Rogernomics and Ruthenasia times and at least someone’s finally admitted that.

    IMHO, since the 1980s, we’ve had a plutocracy. We first need to admit that to ourselves and then decide whether we want to keep it, or replace it with something that everyone can share.

    https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics/2650034/not-working-well-wayne-brown-calls-for-mmp-rethink-after-china-visit

    1. 1.1

      We do operate a sort-of democracy and our institutions fit themselves into the democracy framework and our laws support the system, but where is the embedded awareness programme that keeps us all alert to the mechanics of and reasons for, the democracy we enjoy and hope to maintain?

      Do we just fly this thing blind?

      Like wallpaper, democracy disappears from awareness if it’s just … wallpaper.

    2. 1.2

      Not surprising that Brownie gets it wrong. A better conclusion would start by observing that China’s economy is currently broadly successful because of two main things:

      • markets have fierce competition ruthlessly imposed on them by the State to drive the innovation that markets can produce. The Chinese have learned from the failure of the USSR. And they have also watched unregulated markets degenerate into feudal theft in the West.
      • Although the Chinese state allows individuals to become very wealthy, they do not allow wealth to be converted into political power. Political power stays within the CCP. Again, they’ve learnt from mistakes in the west.

      So rather than Brownie’s conclusion a more subtle question is needed. In a democratic polity, how can markets be allowed to operate in those sectors of the economy where they are effective and desirable, but still remain disciplined by shared sense of social purpose?

      1. 1.2.1

        Don’t forget population size.

        In a country like ours there are many sectors where local companies are competing against global companies where serving new Zealand can be achieved from within the production overrun.

        Then comes the difference between corporate borrowing rates, which rarely favour local businesses.

        That’s where Roger Douglas’s “level playing field” left me cold, even when I was too young to fully understand it.

      2. 1.2.3

        In addition, China is very good at long term planning. Some cock-ups do result, and the planning is imposed centrally, but it can have some big successes.

        By contrast NZ is very poor at long term planning.

        Also, China is aiming for long term self sufficiency and food security.

  2. 2

    The failure of liberal democracy over the past twenty plus years was always going to lead to questions to it’s legitimacy and relevance, much in the same way the discrediting of the ruling elites post WW1 and the collpase of capitalism in 1929 combined to see the rise of proposed modern alternatives in futuristic fascism and utopian communism.

    As long as theneoliberal capitalist settlement is buttressed by centrist technocrats and authoritarian liberal elites the political system that underpins it the “west” will be subject to existential questions.

    1. 3.1

      Let’s start by looking at our national debt in comparison to other countries. This chart is from parliament’s own website (https://www3.parliament.nz/mi/pb/library-research-papers/research-papers/library-research-brief-crown-and-household-debt/) If we imagined our debt levels to be much lower, we find ourselves in the company of poorer-performing countries. Off to the right of the chart, we see countries, many of whom we envy, with greater percentage debt than we have.

      IMHO, it isn’t about how much debt we carry, it’s about what we do with the debt we have taken on. Luxon liked to compare the public sector to a business or home. Most people have a mortgage. If people had the same kind of ongoing security that the government has (it isn’t likely to be retrenched, it will always be there), it would be sensible to max out the mortgage, buy a valuable property and own a property that has a value in today’s dollars, while paying off the debt in yesterday’s dollars. Look at Paul McCartney – he bought lots of properties in the Beatles era, long since paid for and worth an awful lot today.

      So, when people like Luxon the bogeyman tells us we have a lot of debt, we need to respond by saying – the level of debt is ok, what’s NOT ok is using it for things like tax breaks for landlords. Mr Luxon, show us how you will use the debt as an investment for the country’s future, not to pay off your patrons. IMHO, asking those kind of questions during the last 3 years would have shifted the game. Instead, the opposition played along with Luxon/Willis when they scared the country with the size of our debt and we followed them down the rabbit hole of their choosing.

      I’m having trouble inserting the graphic. If it doesn’t show, click on the link and scroll down to the international comparison.

    2. 3.2

      Thanks for the link aj.

      This article should be a compulsory read at every ballot box.

      It means that Nicola Willis was misinformed, ignorant , ideologically captured lying.

      The last is the least surprising.

      Unfortunately the other party in the centre sings from the same songsheet. Swarbrick as Finance Minister isn’t a tory nightmare, it’s a pressing necessity.

      1. 3.2.1

        Thinker and says, yes.

        The right have embedded the ‘household budget’ comparison very very deep into the concious of a lot of minds. Short simple answers, on endless repeat, are very hard to dislodge. Chloe is doing her best to articulate a change, and articles like this plus the Gary Stephenson’s, Richard Murphy’s of this world are making some glacial progress in the same space.

  3. 4

    ‘Low-performing’ NZ drops in climate change rankings for third year in a row [Newsroom, 16 Nov 2026]
    New Zealand’s climate policy performance is ahead only of Slovakia, the US, Iran and Russia, a new global ranking finds

    “For third year in a row“?!! I like not this news – bring me some other news.

    World goes over climate cliff [The Ecologist, 17 Nov 2026]
    ​But Climate Analytics policy analyst and lead author of the report Sarah Heck warned that collectively governments are “simply not moving fast enough to adopt the policies that would enable us to escape from the emerging overshoot trap”.

    “Not moving fast enough“? But Luxon said “it’s a case of slower to go faster“, and nothing goes slower for longer on CC than National.

    “Worse, several are taking their foot off the accelerator and slowing their climate action – or in cases such as the USA, Canada and New Zealand – rolling it back at a staggering level,” she added.

    Two degrees Celcius is the new threshold.

    Global warming extends boreal fire seasons into uncharted territory [Nature, 17 Nov 2026]
    Keeping warming below 2 C could significantly limit the geographic extent and consequences of unprecedented boreal fire seasons.​

    A new age of climate extremes’: Earth accumulating heat at accelerating rate [The Guardian, 9 Nov 2026]
    The imbalance between incoming energy from the sun and energy leaving Earth reached its highest level since monitoring began, the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) said in its State of the Global Climate update.

    That imbalance and the accumulation of heat will supercharge extreme weather events such as heatwaves, droughts and tropical cyclones.

    1. 4.1

      But Luxon said “it’s a case of slower to go faster”.

      Even for Luxon this is foolish. Somebody should publish a book of Luxonisms; it would be a tome.

      1. 4.1.1

        Why does Luxon speak in the 3rd person: “What I say to you is…”

        He’s frightened to be direct and have nothing between himself and the audience. He’s constructed a puppet to stand in the middle, so he can refer all negative response to it, thus avoid feeling the direct, raw incoming opinion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *