Daily review 16/11/2026

10 comments on “Daily review 16/11/2026”

  1. 1

    Here’s a really interesting energy market reform which could be used to sotp rewarding fossil fuel-derived generation from gorss energy wasters like hypescaled data centres:

    The Albanese government is closing in on a deal with the Coalition to pass new laws to force gas producers to set aside exports for domestic users after the Greens demanded Labor ensure data centres did not get access to cheaper energy produced by the scheme.

    The scheme is designed to reserve up to 20 per cent of Australia’s gas production for households and heavy industry, based on a forecast of expected demand for the fossil fuel recalculated every 12 months known as the domestic supply obligation.

    So here’s that kind of policy turned into a local context.

    The new LNG storage in New Plyouth will be used primarily for electricity generation. Since it’s a purley policy-directed project, the government should direct that its energy porduction never be used for AI hyperscale datacentres energy generation. That would force hyperscaled datacentres to rely on new renewable energy projects to be viable. It would also stop the distortion of the energy market that such massive energy users force upon us mere household consumers.

    <

    p style=””>Market be damned. It’s good hard politics from the Federal level Greens in Australia.

    1. 1.1

      But in a New Zealand context, wouldn’t imported LNG alwaysbe more expensive than our renewables by a considerable margin. The Makarewa thing initally proposed diesel generators on site, rather than buying peaking power on the spot market, which got redesigned to batteries + generators.

      Otherwise a good piece of performative politics which would have votes in it. Any argument against it would just illudicate how dumb the LNG for backup power idea is. And that argument is getting worse. Today there was a piece on Business Desk starting,

      New Zealand’s growing fleet of wind, solar and geothermal power stations has sharply reduced thermal generation and appears to be helping hydro generators conserve water, showing how the evolving electricity system could improve security of supply.

      It has long been a mantra in the electricity sector that building more renewable

      The rest is behind paywall, if anyone can help with the rest TIA

    2. 1.2

      “That would force hyperscaled datacentres to rely on new renewable energy projects to be viable.”

      Ad-the new renewable energy you talk about is needed to power NZ’s economy EXCLUDNG data centres. Data centres cannot be allowed to steal this power for their massive power needs (that incidentally create very few jobs). The opportunity cost to the economy would be huge.

      It is simple-data centres must be required to provide and pay for all of the power they need as part of their resource consent conditions.

  2. 2

    Richard Harmon has determined on something important only to the National Party. The electorate MP is the National Party caucus.

    And somehow they are the embodiment of Edmund Burke, but burdened by the caucus leader, the Right Honourable (brain cells are dying) Christopher Luxon.

    He can remember who Derek and Marilyn were in the 1981-1984 government.

    His lauding of the type, is either to stress their role in preserving the number of party MP’s when the PM is not popular, or to raise the profile of the electorate MP as proposals for a return to FPP are re-launched by Harry “I have money for those who work for our cause” Mowbray.

    He writes this

    But while those candidates did well (James Meager in Rangitata got 61.87% of the electorate vote), the party did not fare so well. In that electorate, National’s party vote share was down by 8.5%, though on average across those selected electorates it was down by 3.7%.

    What all this suggests is not that voters were deliberately splitting their votes to engineer an overhang but rather that they liked the local MP who they knew, but they didn’t like the generic brand, “National.”

    That is a highly questionable claim.

    More votes for the MP and less party votes for the party was the outcome sought via the vote-splitting strategy.

    In the specific case the MP’s majority benefitted from his first incumbency result. And In 2023 he was contesting against a Labour Party minister in Jo Luxton – she won more votes than the party, whereas her replacement did otherwise.

    And the 8% fall in party list vote to National all went off to ACT & NZF.

    8% was the decline in the National Party vote from 2023.

    None of it suggests what he claims – not only AI can hallucinate it seems.

    https://www.thepost.co.nz/politics/361117394/vanessa-weenink-should-never-have-been-national-mp​

    1. 2.1

      Yup, highly dubious claim.

      In Rangitata, ACT’s party vote went up by +4.64% to 14.73% but its candidate only got 2.65% of the electorate vote (no candidate in 2023).

      Similarly, NZF’s party vote went up by +4.41% to 11.85% but its candidate went backwards by −0.54% to 4.86%.

      This is a textbook example of the encouraged tactical voting, i.e., give candidate vote to National candidate and party vote to ACT or NZF.

      Incumbency and local candidate quality (of the National candidate) may have added to it.

      1. 2.1.1

        Agree 100% Incog. Vote splitting worked well for the Right but thay are in full denial mode. This is because they want to do it again at the next election.

        Labour and Green parties need to have a vote-splitting pact for the next election seat by seat.

        1. 2.1.1.1

          All this vote splitting business doesn’t bode well at all for cross- or bi-partisan politics any time soon in NZ. I thought that is what the electorate would like to see more of and was one of the selling points of TOP 🤔

    2. 2.2

      Distraction by analysis. There was discussion / observation that National’s party vote was insufficent to match their potential electorate vote, and especially their incumbent electorate MPs form very early in the campaign. Rebuilding National’s party vote into the mid 30% range wasn’t really a viable option so an overhang strategy evolved in the electorate, Mowbray and Brash were following rater than leading this. Only problem with this strategy was that it hung National’s front bench.

      We’re going to see all sorts of denial, distraction, and flat out dead catting for a while as National rationalises the collapse in their support. Killing off most of your front bench is going to do wonders for party unity and there’ll be a tipping point from whence it’ll be all on, if it isn’t already.

      1. 2.2.1

        I think that Mowbray and Brash lean more towards ACT than National and that they didn’t mind inflicting a bit of harm to National’s front bench (and simultaneously sending a message to future National list candidates that they’re there to make up the numbers on paper).

        National’s national support was weaning and clearly the party suffered from yet another blood nose after being wagged by the two tails for three years – ACT and NZF are having National for lunch.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *