There was an interesting interview yesterday on Q&A.
The topic was MMP and the interviewees were Lara Greaves, who I respect, and Nick Smith who generally I do not.
They were talking about MMP.
The aftermath of the recent election is that there is a lot of concern at how the election was conducted.
At one level I find this debate frustrating.
There were a number of aspects that affected the result including:
- Reducing the time for enrollments. This drove down turnout and benefitted the right.
- Allowing Luxon to choose the election date. This drove down turnout and benefitted the right.
- Large donations by rich people to the parties of the right. The quid pro quo has not been fully ascertained but donors receiving fast track approvals are a feature.
- Large amount spends by third parties to affect the result. Think Taxpayer’s Union, Voices for Freedom and Harry Mowbray were clearly happy to splash cash around to keep the left out.
- The Overhang.
When you think about it the net effect is that the right have one extra seat over the left. With cups of tea in Epsom and Ohariu the level of benefit for the right is no more than it has been in the past.
But there has been a focus on the overhang. And there has been this attempt by the right to suggest that the left complaining about the rort of the electoral system means we are going to go all January 6 on it.
Holy false equivalence.
Focussing on the overhang alone and not addressing donation issues or enrollment issues is missing the point.
The Q&A interview was really interesting. Because part way through Nick Smith said something that I found myself fully agreeing with.
He said this:
I think one of our flaws is that there are lots of good things about our electoral culture in New Zealand. I think the Electoral Commission did an outstanding job of running our election. There’s been a big debate about the 5% threshold. That has been the most contentious issue. The argument has been that it’s been too high. You cannot get a new party into Parliament. Opportunity has shown that that 5% threshold can be achieved. The bit that I think is a weakness is that I do get a sick feeling in my stomach when I see the government of the day trying to manipulate the rules, rewrite the rules for the next election to their advantage.
And whether it was the debate that’s been quite contentious in my time in Parliament, do prisoners get to vote or not, or the question of whether those sorts of issues. I would love it if our Parliament had the maturity to effectively require a 75% or entrench all of the Electoral Act, because these tweaks that are done on a partisan basis actually undermine the integrity of New Zealand’s electoral system.
Here is the video if you want to have a look at it.
One example he offered, the prisoner voter issue, has been debated continuously over the past 15 years. National disenfranchises some prisoners, there is a ruling that the policy is in breach of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act, Labour reverses it then the cycle starts again.
The effect on the democratic system is minimal. It has been estimated that only 2,000 votes are affected.
This is a miniscule number of votes compared to the total passed in Aotearoa New Zealand. And not all eligible prisoners would vote. And if they did the Legalise Cannabis Party may benefit but otherwise votes would be scattered around.
As Andrew Geddis said “the amount of parliamentary time and political energy spent on this particular issue in an era of collapsing everything is just a little bit silly”.
Smith’s request that significant changes should only be made on a bipartisan basis is something that we should aspire to. But I think he is dreaming if he thinks this will be agreed to by this current Government.
https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics/2625484/luxon-says-wait-for-votes-could-have-taken-5-weeks-without-enrolment-changes
No chance of commonsense whole luxon openly lies about everything, the head of the electoral explicitly stated that late enrolment does NOT slow down the the return date.
The length of the wait is the same this time as last time (2023), i.e., 20 days. So, Luxon’s claim is not true and turns out to be false.
What I’d say to you is I think you’re all thick as shit, so I’m gonna say what I like
Luxon doesn’t care or give a shit; cry me a river.
👍 Liar Luxon’s is at it again, but even if counting had taken “four or five weeks“, what of it – ‘dropkicks’ had rights too.
Just imagine what it would have been like “waiting weeks for the final outcome.”
Yes lux-one told another porkie on RNZ, he said it could take 5 weeks to count the votes if people enrolled on the day and he has repeated his mantra over and over again but that is contrary to what the electoral comissioner said. It is sad our acting PM continues to get away with lying.
This is desirable but not a foundational principle for the design of electoral systems. That foundational principle should be something like: to maximise the democratic participation of every eligible citizen and for each citizen to have equal influence over the composition and policy choices of elected governments.*
Much of the bipartisanship talk is a way of shying away from having the courage to openly state such a principle – it dials back expectations and obscures the self interest that is at work. Thus we saw Nick Smith’s panegyric on the value of direct local representation which he used as a roundabout excuse for the overhang – it was just voters expressing their support for fantastic local candidates, apparently. He expressed a dislike of governments changing things to their advantage – a neat bit of bogus both-sidesism that also skillfully avoided referring to any underlying principles.
Because it’s clear, that the previous Labour government’s permitting of election day enrolments is consistent with the principle I outlined, and the Coalition goverment’s two-week restriction was inconsistent with that principle. Principled behaviour versus unprincipled behaviour are therefore reduced to a problem of a lack of bipartisanship. Kiwi pragmatism is frustrating at times – it is too often a gutless avoidance of big and necessary ideas. Nick Smith went even further down in my estimation – and he monopolised the time as well, so that Greaves had to sit listening to his endless reminiscences and banalities.
*There is of course, or there should be, way more to democratic participation than just voting and elections, but that’s the focus here
I saw the interview as well. Here is a link to it because it is well worth the watch.
I guess it is a debatable whether governments make these changes to benefit themselves. And, it hasn’t been limited to the right over recent years. For example, it could also be argued that Labour changing enrollment to the date of the election was beneficial to them. As, higher turnouts traditionally favour the left.
I think whether it actually had any effect in this case is moot at the moment, because the enrollment figures were within the band of around 92-94.7% we have seen over recent elections (93.7% last time I checked). And the greatest effect is due to around 25% of the people who actually were enrolled not voting. And, I think claiming voter suppression is over-egging the situation. It isn’t like we had people with machine guns stopping people from enrolling or such. People still had months to do it, and the change was well advertised.
But, I agree with Nick Smith. I think any changes to the electoral system should require 75% support in parliament, or a binding referendum, just to stop these suspicions from arising in the first place.
There is quite an interesting analysis on kiwiblog that points out that there may well have not been a right wing overhang if it wasn’t for the Maori seats. Not suggesting we should do away with those or such. Just that this may be the Ying and Yang of politics in NZ.
Not sure I agree that the disparity in finance really makes that much difference. One of the characteristics of kiwis, is that we often outperform groups with a lot more financial resources. Look at a number of our sports teams that excel for instance against opposition that have far bigger financial resources. I think there is great benefit in having limited resources in that it forces people to think how to most effectively use what they have.
What we saw in the election was a lot of wasted and even counter-productive expenditure on the right. Even a lot of the advertising in favour of the overhang was extremely confusing IMO and a waste of money. Sure, it might have encouraged some tactical voting at the electorate level. But, the party vote for National was pretty much what polls had been predicting well before the overhang campaign.
In contrast, we saw that TMP was able to achieve a much stronger result due to tactical voting compared to their relative size and budget. And, that also benefited the likes of Labour and the Greens who picked up the party votes that would have otherwise gone to TPM.
But, I don’t think there is much evidence to show the change made any difference. When the law to allow election day enrollment was allowed for the 2020 election the enrollment data shows 94.1% enrollment for that election. Last time I looked, the enrollment data for the current election was provisionally at 93.7%. So, even the provisional results are just a smidgen below the 2020 year.
What that says to me is that changing a deadline makes bugger all difference. People just adjust their lives to the new deadline. A bit like people who want to buy a Lotto ticket. If they really want to buy one do you think changing the cut-off from 6 pm on a Saturday night to 5 pm will really make any difference to those people? And, people who miss the cut-off were probably never going to buy a Lotto ticket anyway.
How many people will forget to buy a Lotto ticket if the deadline is 13 days beforehand instead of 6 pm on Saturday night?
That would be tricky to organise because there is only a matter of days between Lotto draws. In percentage terms, compared against time available, it is probably about right though.
So typical of you, you didn’t even make an attempt to answer the question.
Don’t you see the point of prolonging the time gap/delay and the effect that might have on human action or rather, inaction?
On the other hand though, I have seen the left argue that this was voter suppression. In which case, I would expect to see strong evidence that voter suppression was actually happening. But, I haven’t seen that is the case. I have consistently argued for the deadline effect. That people alter the behaviour to meet deadlines. And, I think the evidence largely bears that out.
I guess the evidence is mixed so far as to whether there was any effect at all. The most likely group affected by the change I think is the 18-24 year age group.
According to the Electoral Commission the rates for enrollment for young people in this group were 78.02% in 2020, 76.7% in 2023, and 74.20% in 2026. So, yes, the enrollment rate has dropped in 2026. But, it was dropping anyway even when voting was allowed on the day.
Another point here is that the enrollment rates in the 18-24 year old age group six months out from the 2020 and 2023 elections were higher than for the 2026 election as well.
Only 54% of people in that age group were enrolled six months out in 2026. Compared to 59.8% in 2020 and 61.8% in 2023. So, it seems to me that this year we started from a much lower base of enrollment.
So, that probably didn’t help the enrollment rate at the election.
https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics/2552971/net-migration-up-but-so-is-number-of-young-kiwis-leaving
Young people in NZ are not having a great time.
So, that probably didn’t help the enrolment rate at the election.
Sigh
You avoid answering questions and like moving goalposts.
Voter suppression (excl. the issue of prisoners for now) caused lower enrolment, especially among younger people, and record-low turnout. In addition, it probably caused a steep increase in disallowed votes, and preliminary estimates are quite bad, but the stats aren’t available yet.
https://newsroom.co.nz/2026/08/03/tens-of-thousands-could-be-turned-away-from-voting-but-no-one-is-counting-them/
Your deadline effect is somewhat related to the immediacy bias that I mentioned previously (https://thestandard.nz/day-1-of-voter-suppression-why-is-national-preventing-people-from-enrolling-to-vote/#comment-2076876). Thanks to the huge efforts of many, incl. the Electoral Commission, enrolment was only slightly down compared to previous elections. And the 13-day gap is likely to have contributed to the record-low turnout.
So, things were going down and instead of stemming the downward trend, the rule changes may have made it worse.
But you’re not bothered!?
I actually agree with Suzie Vincent below.
I don’t see any reason why people can’t automatically be enrolled as happens overseas. That would mean we wouldn’t even be having this discussion.
I doubt it would solve the bigger problem of voter turnout though. We can argue a percentage point or so in voter enrollment. But, that misses the elephant in the room which is why quarter of the enrolled population didn’t bother to vote at all.
Excellent! I can think of many things that are more satisfying than having this discussion.
Automatic enrolment was provided in the legislation that reduced the time for enrolment. The Electoral Commission said that it would expect this would have an effect in the 2029 election, but not the 2026 election.
And, yes, I agree disallowed votes could be an issue. I think at the time they were also estimating 700000 special votes when it its actually going to be 400000. So, not sure if the estimate for disallowed votes was tied to the higher expected special votes figure. Time will tell on that I guess.
Jusr read the Attorney-General’s NZ Bill of Rights Act report on these electoral changes. You might learn something. Like we have a right to vote and the enrolment changes acted against that right. Analyzed in the report. Along with estimates of how many would be directly and indirectly disinfranchised.
Making it as easy as possible for anyone to vote is the democratic way. Restricitng the enrolment period, radically chnaging the enrolment provisions that had applied since 1996 is just a deliberate exercise in making it harder to vote.
If a party does something that is in the public interest and also good for them I do not have a problem with it.
It is when they do something that is not in the public interest because it was good for them.
It is in the public interest for our democracy to function properly and for as many people as possible to vote.
It is not in the public interest to artifically stop some of them from voting just because it helps your party.
This excuse about administrative benefits is nothing more than a poor excuse.
There are different ways of thinking about public interest though. If allowing enrollment on the day means long queues due to people leaving it to the day, then that isn’t good either. People might not bother to vote if they think they will have to wait. So, it cuts both ways. I am quite in favour of having a cut off prior to election day. Whether that is the day before, or a week or two before doesn’t really bother me.
That’s just pure weasel.
The job is to enable people to vote. So if there are queues on the day, Electoral managers should go put some more staff and ballot papers out.
Obviously people don’t get the time off work to vote here, so they have to fit it in between work and Polling place being open, which is often Saturday afternoons.
I sure hope you don’t get sick and have to rely on someone helping you to the polls, on the day.
Your reasoning makes no sense at all.
Enrolment this time closed 13 days before Election Day yet voter turnout may become the second-lowest on record despite your alleged ‘no queues and/or much shorter queues’. Go figure!
The atmosphere at election stations is generally quite good and positive even when people have to wait a bit. At least that was my experience in earlier elections.
You’re not bothered – you sound like a certain PM.
Remember I did say in my first comment that any changes to our voting system should require a 75% majority or binding referrendum in order avoid any suspicion that the system is being rigged. So, we are arguing a point that is largely irrelevant to the discussion. I agree that we need to increase the protection of our electoral system whether enrollment statistics have been affected or not.
I’d love to know what you think is ‘the point’, if it’s not imaginary “long queues”, given that you’ve been trying hard to steer the discussion away (from irrelevance!?) and towards your own talking points (that presumably are [more] relevant).
Enrolment, turnout, and disallowed votes are all part of the mounting evidence for deliberate voter suppression.
I am discussing two points:
Historical: Did the change to the enrollment date affect enrollment? The figures suggest not much affect if any there in terms of enrolled voters. Your strongest argument is the amount of disallowed votes. That will be a concern if it is as high as has been estimated. But that is yet to be seen.
Looking forward: I think there are some fundamental changes required to how we run elections, and protections to ensure that governments don’t game changes to suit themselves.
Debates around the historical stuff is largely academic and will be clarified soon enough. It is already clear things need to change going forward.
Okay, it’s largely academic and we haven’t got all the data yet, so there’s no point wasting our time discussing this here on TS, which begs the question why you started this thread @ 4 (https://thestandard.nz/i-agree-with-nick-smith/#comment-2079637) in the first place!?
The argument is having multiple components; they’re not separate arguments.
In 2023, there were 15,555 disallowed Special Votes, of which 10,566 were because they were not enrolled anywhere. The total number of Special Votes cats was 594,804.
https://www.electionresults.govt.nz/electionresults_2023/statistics/sdv-disallowed.html
If you think that about 400,000 Special Votes this time on top of an already-low turnout is a positive sign and perfectly acceptable, then I can see why you’re not bothered by the rule changes.
I think the invalid votes is definitely worth discussing. Not so much the enrollment figures, in my opinion anyway.
My understanding is that votes can be partially allowed. (elector votes in the wrong electorate: Party vote counts, electorate vote doesn’t).
If this is large, it could be a factor in some of the electorates where the margin is small.
In 2023, 42,410 Special Votes were allowed for Party only.
I am a bit sceptical that the number of invalid votes will be as high as predicted. I think these predictions were made prior to the election.
The vote count seems quite low. So, some votes may already have weeded out due to issues being identified during voting. Also, the number of special votes is much lower than expected as discussed. So, if the expected invalid votes was pro-rated on that, then the actual invalid votes might be lower.
Anyway, we will find out in under two weeks.
Maybe you also believe that this is the same all over the world? Other countries arguably like ours do their level best to make voting easier. NZ is an absolute outlier here, bucking the trend completely
Enrolment is automatic across Europe. And substantially so in Australia (compulsory voting). The system enrols you pretty much automatically when e.g. you get a drivers licence or some such. About 98% are enrolled and those that aren’t are mainly 18 year olds who haven’t got a record in the government’s systems yet.
In the UK, which lagged significantly, (enrolment cut off 12 days before election I think), this meant voters lost the chance to vote. This was seen as scandalous so major action has been taken to make enrolment automatic.
In NZ we have only about 93.5% enrolled. Only about 74% of people 18-24 are enrolled. Only about 86% of Maori are enrolled. These are appalling figs. Given this situation, a good government would be pulling out every stop to make enrollment easier and get everyone on the roll, regardless of whether you think it’s a good idea or not.
Ird number would do it , even if ypu auto enrolled onto the party vote but had to make sure your address was upto date to electorate vote
IRD doesn’t always hold citizenship or residence information for individual taxpayers, but MBIE (residence status and travel records) and DIA (citizenship status) between them hold the required information for eligibility to enrol, at least for party voting. Add address where known at time of registration, or pull from IRD otherwise, and that gets most people to electorate enrolment as well.
What say there are long queues at the voting place because people are enrolling the voting? Really? We have had 10 elections where people can enrol and vote, including 2 where enrol and vote could happen on election day. And where are these queues? The quality of your trolling is declining.
Nick Smith made a persuasive case against the Electoral Integrity Act (= party-hopping law) when he was an MP. It’s still the law, simply because neither National nor Labour want(ed) to lose Winston’s support over something that was a lot cheaper in dollars than NZF’s other demands.
“Focussing on the overhang alone and not addressing donation issues or enrollment issues is missing the point.”
Spot on, MS.
YES the enrolment issue was a scandal. The amount of funding – and specifically, critically, to the unregulated third parties is also a rort. BUT another primary factor is the lack of control over what appears in the publicity and promotion, in the press, social media and on hoardings.
At least seven outlandish ‘disinformation’ ads were taken down following upheld complaints to the Ad Stds Authority under “Principle 2: Truthful Presentation – – Ads must not mislead or be likely to mislead, deceive or confuse consumers, abuse their trust or exploit their lack of knowledge. This includes by implication, inaccuracy, ambiguity, exaggeration, unrealistic claim, omission, false representation or otherwise.”
How long did each remain up before being taken down? Long enough to land firmly in minds, and get in the national press. And I am quite sure that those responsible know this full well. The sheer volume of attack-with-impunity was like a tsunami.
So we get generalised memes developing: “ Labour Party cannot manage the economy” becomes an ‘of course’. We know this is bullshit – chapter and verse are so easy to find. But the counter-logic is simply not seen, and this is far more likely to have effect in NZ.
AUT, plus Univ Otago+VUW, studied ‘News Avoidance’ in NZ a couple of years ago.
“60% of survey participants reported they sometimes, often, or almost always avoid the news. This is higher than any other national figure reported in other studies, with Greece and Bulgaria the next highest at 57%.”
It’s like candy from a baby. And what does the gloating sound like, I wonder?
‘We got away with it’ is a shameful indictment on electoral fairness. And right now, nothing to stop it happening again and again.
Remedies?
Nick failed to mention the large amount of $$$$ donated in this election and the influence and ufair advantage it can have. Act bombarded us with adds theirs adds had no bounds its was like a form of brain washing.
covid is pa – Precisely. And given the way that algorithms work on e.g. Facebook (which know that humans love outrage and will follow it down each amplified step, to their ultimate destruction).
My understanding is that social media advertising is relatively cheap, both to create and disseminate; and has a much greater cut through with younger (potential) voters than ‘traditional’ news and live venues. I don’t know anyone who watched the live debates, or went to a ‘meet the candidate’ event.
Perhaps Labour needs to target more resources in that direction.
Gah! Can’t believe I’m saying this – I loathe political ads – and actively avoid them. Why am I suggesting more!
Everything we learned from a deep dive into digital advertising at the 2026 election | The Spinoff
Looks like Labour did put more resource into digital advertising including social media advertising.
The overhang plan was excellent and worked really well, that Luxon (and Key) opposed shows why Luxon has to go.
Also ‘wah’
Ya haven’t won yet bud
Don’t worry, you’ll get your chance. In at least three years time.