
Open mike is your post.
For announcements, general discussion, whatever you choose.
The usual rules of good behaviour apply (see the Policy).
Step up to the mike …

Open mike is your post.
For announcements, general discussion, whatever you choose.
The usual rules of good behaviour apply (see the Policy).
Step up to the mike …
Comment numbers have changed to permanent references. Older quoted numbers may no longer identify the same comment.
Public Interest NZ is a channel on YT that is worth a look. Doesn't insult the intelligence and a good range of guests.
Ollie interviews Taylah Forward of World Inequality Lab.
So the wealthy now pay less than half of what the hoi polloi pay in tax 8% compared to 17%.
David Parker's push for IRD to survey the tax habits of the wealthy uncovered good data. Data that was anoymous and destroyed after use. The survey can't be repeated as the legislation that enabled it was repealed this term.
This is something else to pop in the first 100 days of a Green/Labour government, appeal(?) the legislation, then lean very heavily on IRD to use what powers they have to collect what is rightfully ours. No new taxes needed, just enforce the current ones.
The comments are interesting, using apartheid to describe our tax system as an example.
https://youtu.be/477daoU-xr8?si=ltgMPpxXVYfaw4Ce
[Link fixed]
Parker was so effective, getting the funding for IRD to muscle up.
This is of course the pet peeve of Damien Grant corporate undertaker: an empowered IRD.
Good to see the family trust strata of our world start to quake, and those snake outfits like Ammundsen Law who have been shielding the .005% start to work a whole bunch harder.
Excellent legacy from Parker.
The subject of capital flight comes up. The myth gets debunked.
If the wealthy are looking for a low tax refuge, they are already living in one. A well designed, well enforced tax system limits behavioural response.
Capital flight implies disuading investment. Investment is greatly impeded by crumbling infrastructure, dwindling workforce and neglible climate response.
There is also the contrast between capital flight that 'might' happen versus the brain drain and the worker exodus to Australia for higher wages and taxes.
+100
Young people heading off as "capital flight" in talent and entrepeneurship by their tens of thousands have been so bad for NZ, under National.
Capital flight because of wealth taxes appears to be a bogus monster and a trick of hocus bogus.
https://newsroom.co.nz/2026/10/30/middle-nz-wage-earners-now-paying-twice-the-tax-rate-of-the-most-affluent-kiwi-report/
I don’t know what those “interesting data” refer to and I can’t be bothered looking it up right now. The point is made.
It’s worth quoting from the transcript of your YT interview because there are a few strong arguments made against a purported capital flight.
Would a wealth tax affect ordinary New Zealanders?
If asset strippers, house scalpers, financial fininglars and speculators profit takers from existing assets, (Adam Smiths “rentiers”) sold up and left, we will all be better off. But, unfortunately,
they won't!
I don’t think that capital flight necessarily is the same as people emigrating [to a new better tax haven]. It would be preferable if we have a tax system that re-directs some of that capital [in NZ] to more productive use and that is more progressive in substance and not just in form (paraphrasing Tayla Forward).
And at the back of the rich and leaders, is the inviolability of them laying down their lives or health to help society in a very dramatic and horrific way. We lose our human capital sending our young men off to war, and those have been so regular. And fighting, hurting, killing, robbing, breaks the pattern of fair and civilised community with hardened or broken men afterwards. That is a sort of human capital
The rich and powerful now individually and as countries, invest in businesses that make money from selling weapons. Both during the war and after. [Yes Minister does a good skit on this – Jim wants to tell the PM about it, sure he would be shocked. Sir Humphrey tells him he would become a loser himself, as the PM doesn't want to know and would punish Jim for doing so.) This money system that gets manipulated against our long-term, general interests, may be why modern civilisation can't advance now on the planet. As the innovations and physics knowledge go up, there is less time given to scholarly and philosophical learning and embracing of a flourishing, healthy community.
It is not just the wealthy. Economies such as the USA, are entirely dependant on the "socialist redistribution" of keeping huge numbers of young people employed in their military, and military manufacturing. The real incentive behind their endless wars! It also keeps that latent rebellion focused outward, instead of asking questions about why the distribution of wealth is so unequal.
Ironic, when the USA claims to be the "home of capitalism”.
Similarly with Putin and Netanyahu.
The USA has done the Ayotollahs a favour. Uniting Iranians against the USA bombing their children, instead of removing the Government.
The Falklands was a total boon to Thatcher, keeping focus away from her economic and social failures, at home.
An appeal to jingoism has been the go to for "elites", to keep them in power, for most of human civilisation.
Watch the MAGA oits in the USA, with Iran, when they loose the midterms.
"Is it Eastasia or Westasia this week?"
Outstanding work from Damien O'Connor at the Oamaru all-candidate meeting yesterday. So principled and clear on housing and homelessness. The rest were moral eunuchs.
Also plenty of Labour and Green business supporters on the town.
Waitaki is going to be the electorate to watch on Saturday. Supposedly safe National seat with a light weight MP up against strong Labour and NZF candidates. Can't really see the Mowbray strategy playing out in that contest.
At minimum its connected together good leftie people who otherwise thought we were nearly alone. Which has been a joy.
If you want a reasonable 5 or 6 day challenge in your life, try Alps To Ocean cycleway (Mt Cook to Oamaru).
https://www.alps2ocean.com/trail-map
Spring is the optimum time for it as you get the wind is at your back, crowds haven't arrived, not too hot, sprinkle of snow.
Before you're 65 I suggest as there are 2 days of over 65kms.
Older people tend to use electric bikes. Anyone up to age 75 or so who is in good health will have no difficulty with this ride if they are on electric bikes. I would also say it is nicer in summer.
What I would say to you is that the Government is laser-focused on fixing the basics.
NACTional stands firm on Austerity (for thee), Corporates, Tax relief, and absolutely N0 (Net Zero) New Ideas.
If Kiwis want three more years of the same on the big issues: Cost-of-living, healthcase, unemployment – Party Vote NACTional.
https://www.opportunity.org.nz/clean_up_politics
Sharon Murdoch, in the Sunday Star Times, 1 November 2026
National has been fucking the basics and blundering the future.
Want a quick sure fire vote winner policy.
Allow people to stop payment from there end to the thieving app industry that makes it impossible to find the cancelation payment part of unsubscibing, twice I've been caught the second time I had spent 30 minutes double checking I'd sorted it but no $90 I can't afford to lose is going, bank cant/won't do anything.
Don't trust apps people they're set up by scum people in many cases
Also figure out a way to stop that infuriating surcharge rort when using pay wave
Simple solution from your end, deactivate payWave on the card. You can do that in your banking app. I've got two cards on my transaction account one with paywave, and one without that I use whenever I can as a simple eftpos card that doesn't cost the retailer a fee.
Do you know why there is a paywave charge on your debit card? It's because much of the world's cash transfer bank-to-bank is run through the major (US) credit card companies, who take a slice of every transfer around the world.
In NZ and Australia we set up eftpost direct bank-to-bank transfer systems in year dot, and until Paywave, owned by Visa, was introduced here, only credit card transactions carried the fee.
Most of the rest of the world relies on the US credit companies for these daily business transactions. As you can guess, this gives the US power over the world's money.
Europe is looking to link eftpost systems run by some of it countries, like Spain, to bypass US credit companies in an EU-wide bank-to-bank transfer system. Especially now that Trump passed a law so the US can co-opt any company based there to follow its orders.
Paywave is a rort and sends money straight to the US for doing diddly-squat. Eftpos is still a private company, but it's our Australasian company, and charges much less for bank-to-bank transfer.
Eftpos is effectively free for the merchant, it's part of the services in the monthly Merchant Fee, and my understanding is that it was part of the legislative trade off when cashless transactions were set up here. Paywave trades on providing convenience for the customer and the merchant is paying for the customer's convenience, then passing that cost on to the customer. Just some middleman standing in the way with their hand out. Easily avoided though.
The GST tax system works for the government the same. As we become dependent on one system the owners get their fingers into our lives and feed off us without our thinking and agreeing.
Didn't one of the cocs campaign last election on getting rid of surcharge?
The idea kinda fell to bits when it was realised that stopping merchants recouping card fees via a surcharge just put prices up as the card fee would be built into prices. The same price that cash and eftpos customers would pay. National's surcharge ban wouldn't have reduced the card fees merchants paid. Retailers Assn and cash advocates were strongly against it.
This is how Mamdani in NY made online subscriprions 'click to cancel.
Remember that NY City is a mini-state if 23 mi people.
He is the Mayor of a portion of the metropolis. Admittedly the biggest and most important part, with 9 million people including all of Manhattan.
Ta, thanks for correcting me. Still, almost twice our population here.
Labour is already onto this.
https://www.labour.org.nz/news/release-labour-s-plan-to-lower-bills-and-build-a-better-new-zealand/
It’s [in] Labour’s policy A Fair Go For Families although and although it doesn’t specifically mention Apps as such, I’d think that the policy covers that too.
Good on them , 99.999 sure they're getting my 2 ticks , but I never quiet know till the pens in my hand ,,
Labour will make much-needed changes to main benefit rates.
https://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/PO2610/S00207/cpag-welcomes-labours-benefit-indexation-policy.htm
I mulled whether this comment should be part of a rebuttal to Elliot Cossan’s Post but I think that Post is a bit of a lost cause right now and there’s way too much in it to rebut.
Labour’s policy on Disability may look a bit thin, but it’s not absent.
For this election, Labour has been focussing on reducing costs for [all] people and bringing down the cost of living. The other pillar is the focus on getting more people into jobs that pay better and create more jobs for New Zealanders, particularly for younger ones.
The search function on Labour’s Policy webpage is a dog.
there are some good things in there. But ffs, Labour are basically saying, still, if you are disabled and can't work, too bad, live in poverty.
Good peop0le of Canterbury you need to vote Labour or Greens. That is my shock reaction to the headline below. Do it now before things get worse. It is a crisis for you and for the country but you have been hit a number of times recently by emergencies and must get into change mode. You'll end up otherwise praising the authorities for the littlest emergency help like providing portaloos for those without sewerage systems after the earthquake.
https://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/GE2610/S00098/new-ecan-groundwater-report-confirms-canterburys-nitrate-emergency-is-worsening.htm
…ECan’s Annual Groundwater Quality Survey revealed that 70.1% of the wells tested had nitrate concentrations of greater than or equal to 1 mg/L (NO3-N). The risk of bowel cancer increases at 1 mg/L of nitrate in drinking water, and the risk of preterm birth increases at 5 mg/L ….…Higher nitrate levels remained overwhelmingly concentrated in areas dominated by intensive dairy farming.
The report was released today, just as news reported that Ministry of Education data showed drinking water at over 20 schools had nitrate levels of 5.6 mg/L or higher….
Hipkins seems rather adamant Barbara Edmonds (and not Chlöe Swarbrick) should be finance minister.
So is Hipkins right?
Who would you prefer (out of the two) to see in that position?
I asked Google and the definitive answer is “it depends”. I could’ve thought of that myself.
Found a poll (for what that is worth)
19% support for Chlöe.
32% said it would make no difference and 43% oppose
https://www.thepost.co.nz/politics/361106098/poll-voters-wary-swarbrick-holding-purse-strings
Thank you, my day is complete now!
I'd frame the question differently:
Q1 If a finance minister was the opposite of Nicola Willis, would you support or oppose them?
Q2 If that person turned out to be Chloe Swarbrick, would you change your mind?
'Coalition parties are scrapping over the election overhang strategy, rather than continuing their attacks against the left block' says RNZ today. I won't bother linking to the article, as I only wish to spread schadenfreude, pleasure at the pain of the rw.
Exactly the sort of behaviour to spook their support. Nothing like in-fighting on your wing to lose voter confidence at the polls.
Bitter arguments have broken out among the CoC parties. Key is begging Epsom blue-rinse voters to save his mate Goldsmith. Brasch paid to get his vote-split message (endorsed by both ACT AND NZF, ha!) in the papers. And ACT's Henry called the nats two-faced for dropping their marriage of convenience in Epsom.
Best thing the CoC voters could do is shrug their shoulders, walk away, and not bother to vote. Too complicated.
A great weirdness would be this in the first year after being elected. https://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/HL2610/S00079/to-salvage-the-un-we-need-to-think-outside-the-international-box.htm Oct.31/26
About the United Nations and how it is needed. written by Martin LeFevre – Meditations – Philosopher
To Salvage The UN, We Need To Think Outside The International Box
During the pandemic I initiated a series of dialogues with the rector and others through the United Nations University for Peace in Costa Rica. UPeace is the only UN-mandated University in the world, formed by the General Assembly in 1980.
The thematic question of our dialogues was: “Psychological Revolution and the Emergence of an Effective Global Polity?” Rector Francisco Rojas and I agreed on some basic premises. The first was that the foundation for a true global order has to be poured before the complete collapse of the post-World War II inter-national order.
We rejected the notion that “To save the United Nations from the irrelevance in which it now wallows will require the concerted backing of the few powers that govern the defunct security council.” … Remaining within the crumbling box of the UN and the defunct post-World War II international order because “where else can the hard conversations about war technology happen“ is a monumental failure of imagination.
The fact is that everyone on Earth now lives in a very disordered and increasingly dangerous global society. “Coexistence“ was always a fragile veneer; chaotic convergence is what we’re confronted with and must deal with as human beings. …The climate crisis and the precipitous loss of biodiversity lead the list of intensifying global crises that urgently require a psychological revolution that puts humanity as a whole over national interest. And if we wait until complete collapse from this foundation, it won’t be possible to build a true global order for the foreseeable future, if at all.
We also agreed that a tangible form has to be given to the “sovereignty of humanity” over the competing sovereignties of nearly 200 nation-states, especially since two of the “great powers” are dangerous shadows of their former selves….
[Incognito: This comment was moved to open-mike because it was off topic. Irrelevant copypasta.. Do better next time.]
That is weird too. Who and what defines what is weird these days? A rhetorical question.
I tagged it as irrelevant copypasta, which it clearly was, as it had nothing to do with the Post on which you commented and it lacked any meaningful commentary from you, so there’s nothing ‘weird’ about that. I reiterate the system-generated message (i.e., they were not my words): do better next time.
In England and Wales, only 19% of Green voters do not support the statement 'Zionism is racism'. The motion was passed at the recent Greens' AGM after a year of extensive workshopping with Green Party members.
Which would be fine, if people could reliably distinguish Zionism from Judaism, agree on what it actually means, and avoid treating any support for Israel as Zionism.
Without those distinctions, criticism of a political ideology can all too easily become a blanket judgement of people whose actual beliefs are considerably more complicated.
In my mind, this is a stupid and politically toxic solution to a problem that doesn't need solving in this way. It is perfectly possible to support the continued existence of the state of Israel while also deploring its many and ongoing war crimes.
Because if someone asks me whether what’s happening in Gaza constitutes genocide, my answer is yes, probably. But that doesn’t mean I believe Israel should cease to exist, or that everyone who supports its continued existence is a racist.
·
͏A while ago this bloke polished the Ai crystal ball.
It's all a bit grim.
Steve McMechan's post
As everyone knows daily lines charges in nz have gone and are still going out of control alone with peak power pricing per kWh, and in the same breath record billions of dollars profits by key players in the nz market.
I thought it would be interesting to ask ai to model things based on current real factual data and where we have been data wise over the past years until now and model it forward to give a glimpse as to what things may look like in nz year by year for the next 10 years and heck it’s not pretty at all.
[…]
Projected Trend (2027–2036): The Next 10 Years
These projections assume an ongoing 7% to 9% annual growth rate driven by Transpower/EDB capital expenditure resets, the total elimination of daily charge caps, and sustained gentailer wholesale margins.
2027:
The Low Fixed Charge regulation is fully removed on 1 April 2027. Retailers normalize high daily charges across all residential accounts. Daily Fixed Charges in high-cost zones push to $5.40 – $5.95 per day. Peak volumetric rates reach 63c – 67c per kWh.
2028:
Lines companies aggressively migrate grid cost recovery into fixed daily fees to offset rooftop solar revenue loss. Daily Fixed Charges rise to $5.80 – $6.45 per day. Peak volumetric rates hit 67c – 72c per kWh.
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1874568236014822/permalink/3764180817053545
I think there's a fundamental problem with this forecast. It assumes that increasing daily fixed charges automatically means consumers will pay more overall, but that's not necessarily the case.
I work for an electricity distribution business, and one of the interesting things we found when analysing the changes was that quite a few low fixed charge customers would actually end up paying less overall.
Part of the problem with the old regime was that it effectively conflated low electricity consumption with low income. But they're not the same thing.
In our network, a significant number of low-use ICPs were things like pumps and holiday homes. Meanwhile, a low-income family with several children might use considerably more electricity than a relatively wealthy household with a holiday home.
There's also a distinction between low consumption and low cost to serve. A connection that uses very little electricity can still require much of the same network infrastructure as one that uses a lot.
The old regime effectively shifted more cost recovery onto volumetric charges, which didn't necessarily distribute costs fairly or target those experiencing energy hardship.
None of this means electricity affordability isn't a genuine concern, or that some households won't be worse off. But simply projecting fixed daily charges upwards without accounting for changes in volumetric rates, consumption patterns or total annual bills is misleading.
It's also worth pointing out that the sector isn't operating in a regulatory vacuum. The Commerce Commission and Electricity Authority have made it clear that they'll be closely scrutinising lines charges, and the Minister has signalled a willingness to intervene if necessary. That's quite different from the assumption that lines companies can simply increase charges unchecked for the next decade.
If we're going to use AI to forecast electricity costs, we should at least model how the electricity market, regulatory framework and tariff structures actually work, rather than extrapolating a few headline numbers.