Chris Hipkins Is Right

Remember all that hopey-changey stuff?

I can still remember where I was when I heard Obama’s Democratic nomination speech in 2008. Take 5 minutes of your day and bathe in heady political optimism:

In 2017 Ardern led a fresh, optimistic, feminine politics and later formed an entire career promoting this new way of doing things. I was proud to be at that campaign launch.

But that was a long 9 years ago.

In 2023 when Chris Hipkins became Prime Minister, he jettisoned otherwise difficult, too late, and politically expensive policies: the TVNZ-RNZ media merger, the biofuels mandate to help suppress fuel price increases, the social insurance scheme that was to be a massive expansion of ACC, any talk of tax reform, the hate speech legislation, lowering the voting age, the entire Three Waters programme, alcohol pricing and advertising reform, the clean car discount, into what many called a pre-election policy bonfire. It didn’t stem the support collapse that Ardern’s leadership had precipitated.

Hipkins also jettisoned all of the aspirational language that Labour and social democrats the world over have come to expect.

By 2026, what is still visible from the Ardern-Hipkins government is smaller items: a significantly upgraded and expanded public housing portfolio, new state subsidies like Winter Fuel Allowance and School Lunches, Matariki as a public holiday, an integrated but starving health system, and some other items of that scale. 

It’s not nothing but it’s not transformational or hopey-changey. 

There is still a strong cohort of support for large-scale state intervention that presumes the same scale of agency and inspiration of President Obama or Prime Minister Ardern, and we can see it in the rise of the Green Party over four months in 2026.

It is the right of all voters to be unrealistic.

But it leads nowhere if you are trying to get a second or third term, which is where gradual change turns into measurable shifts to the whole of New Zealand. Kiwisaver started very small and now manages $140 billion of our savings. NZSuper started small and will by the end of 2027 manage $100 billion.

From the little things, big things grow.

There is no longer any chance of large scale change in New Zealand no matter what party you vote for. When the fuel-driven inflation pressure on the economy is so strong and will be for years to come, and the scale of public sector austerity is so strong that there is far less capacity to achieve public change for years to come, and there is little private sector will to invest in the economy and hire people by business, then hope, change, transformation, aspiration, expansion, growing wings, or rhetorical capes are not going to happen. It would be great if it were possible, but it ain’t. 

Workers believe things are consistently worse. 

NZ business has not surged in investment to fill the void of the retreating state and there is now a growing reality gap between their mood and their investment delivery.

Treasury economic growth forecasts have been consistently inaccurate and optimistic.

The IMF hasn’t been able to do any sensible forecast about economic growth or shrinkage across developed economies over the past three years either. So it’s not just us getting forced into small-c conservative imagination.

In 2026 compared to 2017 we are a smaller, weaker country on multiple measures and the entire public sector doesn’t have the ability to change it. That’s not fun but it’s real. In 2017-2020 the government threw tens of billions at the public service and hired left right and centre and got hundreds and hundreds of workstreams going. 

Fate wasn’t fair to the results.

Hipkins’ small-bore approach to social democrat politics follows closely to Australia’s Labor government. The result is that the right are eating each other for breakfast. 

Chris Hipkins is not Jacinda Ardern. His small bore policies may not even reward Labour in 2026 vote share. 

But 2026 is the right time for the Chris Hipkins school of politics.

38 comments on “Chris Hipkins Is Right”

Comment numbers have changed to permanent references. Older quoted numbers may no longer identify the same comment.

  1. 1

    I agree we need to follow what Labor has done in Australia. Look at what all the small changes have meant for Australians. Cheaper houses (apart from NSW), good paying jobs, cheaper power bills, reasonable food cost compared to here, lower inflation, solid interest rates, and an education system channeling young people into jobs which are good paying and have a future – all the while not burdening a generation with debt.

    This has taken the ground work done by the state governments over at least 6 to 9 years, followed by a labor led federal government taking another 5 years.

    There is no quick fix for NZ, we drank the cool aid of neo-liberalism and the price is pain.

  2. 2

    Hipkins is following the same ridiculous and economically illiterate fiscal responsibility rules as this coalition government. So we can just expect more of the same.

    1. 2.1

      Exactly right – which is why we need a strong Green presence in government – to drag Labour, screaming and protesting, towards progressive policies which help all NZers (except perhaps the top 4% – let them pay their fair share of tax!)

        1. 2.1.1.1

          If Labour holds its own electorate seats and picks up a few marginal Natz ones, and the Greens receive an increased share of the party vote, surely that's the most desired outcome?

          With TPM there with 4, 5 or 6 electorate seats, we'll be able to get rid of the CoC, or have I not got my head round the MMP voting strategy?

    2. 2.2

      Bernard Hickey has nailed it.

      With concerns about how Labour can increase necessary investment in health, education, housing, services and infrastructure while keeping the same fiscal strait jacket, as the Coalition of Cockups. Especially with their very timid bow to the right wing framing on spending and taxes. Leaving Greens with a dilemma if Labour stymies any real changes. Hipkins replacing Peters as, "the handbrake"?

      A "do little" Labour risks not really achieving anything concrete if they do get in.

      Ending up a one term Government themselves.

      Hopkins is not right! His "bonfire of policies" didn't work last election. Not surprised that Labour is barely polling above National, despite Willis, Stanford, and the bunch of ideological loonies they are in power with, fucking up everything they touch.

      Our only hope is the Green vote getting closer to the "main parties".

      1. 2.2.1

        Precisely!

        A Green vote of over 20% and a Labour vote of say 25% would give the Greens plus TPM enormous leverage to force LINO to actually do meaningful things to improve the lives of ordinary people (Luxon's hard-working taxpayers who he actually doesn't give a f*** about).

      2. 2.2.2
        1. 2.2.2.1

          I think that Opportunity, assuming they find themselves kingmaker, and then part of a left coalition, should refuse to support Labour's CGT proposal, and join with the the other two parties in insisting on a wealth tax; or perhaps a CGT coupled with a wealth tax. A wealth tax, it seems to me, would be the one "circuit breaker" that NZAO needs.

          1. 2.2.2.1.1

            Except, as a party set up by self-made millionaires, OP tax policy was specifically designed to foil the introduction of a wealth tax by hook or by crook.

            Hence the regressive land tax (fine if most of your egregious wealth is in shares), and in a dodgy ubi that can be set conveniently to poverty level.

            We have seen nothing of OP’s ‘negative bottom lines’. I bet my bottom dollar OP would block the introduction of a Wealth tax as part of their agreement.

            1. 2.2.2.1.1.1

              Except, as a party set up by self-made millionaires, OP tax policy was specifically designed to foil the introduction of a wealth tax by hook or by crook.

              A CGT is a far more effective tool for the purpose of avoiding, "by hook or by crook", a wealth tax, and is favoured by the banking sector because, when a property is sold, any mortgage has been paid off and the bank no longer has a financial interest in it, so it doesn't influence interest rates, as land taxes might.

              However, a land tax is unlikely to be agreed to buy the other parties in any case.

              1. 2.2.2.1.1.1.1

                PS: A wealth tax is also regressive in the sense that everyone who has to pay it is paying at the same proportional rate. That used to be the case with the land tax that we had until the early nineties, which applied only to land above a certain value threshold. It is the exemption factor that makes a wealth tax attractive, rather than the question of whether or not it is regressive. Regressiveness, however, doesn't apply so much to TOP's land tax since it would be accompanied by a UBI.

                1. 2.2.2.1.1.1.1.2

                  It is very easy to set up a progressive wealth tax. Say tax wealth >10 million at 2.5%, increasing to 5% for wealth > 25 million, for example.

              2. 2.2.2.1.1.1.2

                OP strategy was to flood the zone of national debate on tax with their novelty idea, to kill discussion and support for a Wealth tax before the election. Nice try with your CGT deflection there; however it just neatly reinforces my point.

                1. 2.2.2.1.1.1.2.1

                  Nice try with your CGT deflection there; however it just neatly reinforces my point.

                  My criticism of CGT would reinforce support for a wealth tax rather than deflect from from that support, so I do not see how it reinforces your point. There may not be sufficient discussion around wealth taxes as it happens, but I doubt whether that's because of Opportunity "flooding the zone of tax discussion". It is more likely that there is not sufficient discussion around wealth taxes because Hipkins has ruled it out and voters don't believe the Greens will get sufficient support to push it through.

              3. 2.2.2.1.1.1.3

                Read this link put up by subliminal at TS today: perfectly carries on the conversation.

                https://thestandard.nz/open-mike-10-10-2026/#comment-2075053

                ‘but are they levying their hopes and dreams on a silver bullet tax proposal that conveniently redirects the issue of growing inequality to the land rich top 10% of society (fine) but doesn’t target corporate interests or the truly wealthy. Could this .
                be why Opportunity has attracted interest from high-net-worth donors? ‘ says Luke Maker.

                I’d argue it’s the other way round: OP is a political strategy vehicle designed by the super-rich to muddy the waters from the start.

                1. 2.2.2.1.1.1.3.1

                  I had already Luke Maker's substack before making my latest comment. He makes the valid point that land taxes would not be sufficient to support a UBI, and I agree. The problem with wealth taxes, though, is that people seem to think that it will get rid of extreme inequality. It won't, and that's not its purpose: its purpose is to extract more tax from the wealthy than it provided for in a simple income tax table – people are concerned, validly, the the 9% tax rate enjoyed by the wealthy simply cannot be countenanced. More tax is needed to run a worthwhile social democracy than the poor can afford to pay, so the extra tax has to come from the wealthy. I support wealth taxes partly for that reason, and partly because I believe a capital gains tax would be largely ineffectual.

  3. 3

    Walking a fine line here with the plea not to criticize Labour and yet been provoked by this post.

    I agree Hipkins is right. Right as in center right when he got the chance to show some leadership he baulked for fear of the backlash of three Waters and Mowrees, meaningful tax reform and now lately happy to keep the landlord handout going and free trade with India as examples.

    Being fatally optimistic I'm hoping this is just a Trojan horse appearance to get into power and then start to roll back the worst excesses of neo liberalism.

    Let's be honest it is the failure of this cruel experiment that is causing the decline in the major parties in liberal democracies all around the globe.

    1. 3.1

      Walking a fine line here with the plea not to criticize Labour …

      Nope, the plea was to talk up the Left and not bag them, but critique is/was fine.

      FWIW, I think a few die-hard Lefties are confused re. Labour and its strategy.

  4. 4

    It is the right of all voters to be unrealistic.

    Yes, it is a truism, but often those who are 'unrealistic' about a change of direction nevertheless lay the groundwork for the change becoming inevitable at a later date. An example was the anti-nuclear legislation.. Once upon a time anyone who dared to openly declare their anti-nuclear stance was charged with being a Communist. Now it is a 'fait accompli'.

    The Greens carry that beacon for us and all hail to them for doing so.

    Labour on the other hand has to present itself in a more constrained manner so as not to frighten the horses. "Three Waters" was a good example and I'm looking forward to reading Hager's book on the subject.

    They both play an important role in getting a left leaning government elected, so how about we dial down on the criticism of one against the other?

    1. 4.1

      Sure, we all have the right to be unrealistic (at times). However, I don’t think we have the right to demand this of others or, worse, that they accept our unrealism as ‘the truth’.

      I think that Labour does have a realistic strategy to lead the next government and map a different course. Where that will lead is in the stars.

  5. 5

    Gsays . .

    • now lately happy to keep the landlord handout going

    I think the logic was poorly explained.

    Landlords wanted interest dedectabilty, as anyone in business can.

    At the same time they didn't want (or have) a capital gains tax on profit from a sale, which normal businesses have to pay.

    So they wanted, and got, the best of both worlds.

    In lieu of not paying capital gains on profit after asset sale, labour said ok, your not a business with regard interest deductibles.

    Brings them into line with private home owners who can't deduct mortgage interest paid on a home loan.

    The capital gains tax labour are putting up captures these landlords as businesses now, hence it's appropriate to let them keep their interest payments as tax deductible payments.

    I think that's it, anyway.

    1. 5.1

      Cheers aj for the explainer, obviously not easy to do that in a soundbite.

      I'm still of the opinion that landlording is definitely not a progressive pursuit. I'm aware plenty of self identifying 'lefties' do it and some even claim to be 'good' landlords.

      I'm also aware that, because of the way the rules are, this is the only game in town for passive income/ retirement/ legacy for children/insert reasoning. But it is still helping to lock folks out of home ownership and contributes to accommodation insecurity.

      I also begrudge the cost of the Accommodation Supplement. Another hand out to the landlord class.

      1. 5.1.1

        Yes that certainly doesn't fit into a TV sort of sound bite. (If I'm right, I'm no expert)

        I agree 100% with your three points. But unfortunately we have a rentier economy – the rules favour them. You may find this interesting:

        The Rentier Black Hole

        Why domestic and foreign capital flows into British housing and does not come back out.

        1. 5.1.1.1

          Very interesting that Pedro Sánchez in Spain just called a snap election for Nov 29 betting on this issue. There have been big demonstrations around housing affordability in the past few weeks, flaring up after the eviction of a disabled 87 yo from her family apartment (she died yesterday).

          He wants to shore up his minority government, under pressure from the right and far-right, by riding strong public sentiment stirred up over housing security.

          'Sanchez framed the election as a choice over Spain's future direction, saying voters must decide whether the country joins what he called a "far-right wave" or continues on a path of "openness, social justice and environmental responsibility." '

          Sánchez has stopped Spain being used by Trump as a staging post for the Iran war.

          https://www.dw.com/en/spanish-prime-minister-pedro-sanchez-calls-snap-election/a-79542826

          1. 5.1.1.1.1

            Sanchez is one of very few European leaders who are a credit to their country, many brave decisions, but will have made himself a target. All power to his arm.

        2. 5.1.1.2

          Great link thanks. It's great to have the problem laid out on 'their' language

          I seem to recall one of his YT clips explaining the situation here in Aotearoa.

          I have a work colleague that thinks Treasury acted fraudulently when they gave financial advice on state asset sales. He has the spreadsheets, data and the analytical mind to see the bigger picture. Communicating the issue is where it gets tough.

          His fervour and the need to hold three or four concepts in mind at once makes it difficult to convey.

          In a nutshell, Treasury failed to account for the loss of earnings/profit leaving the economy.

          In a related vein, The Taxpayers Union (I know, bear with me), in 2025 issued a statement that Core Crown Debt was not an accurate way to view the state of affairs in regards GDP.

          Government borrowings was going to be a more precise indicator.
          https://www.taxpayers.org.nz/debt_clock_update_2025

          Phew! I know there is more to it than I've described but I have a gorgeous day here in the 'Tu and a house to prepare for painting.

          1. 5.1.1.2.1

            Get that paint on.

            That's quite interesting. Newsroom do a 30 min YT weekly at the moment, in the most recent Tim Murphy said he considered treasury information manipulated to favour the current govt and he doesn't trust them.

            My paraphrasing.

            1. 5.1.1.2.1.1

              … but I don't particularly hold the fact that the Treasury in these instances is particularly neutral. They come from a environment for the past three years working for and with this government and yes, it's providing supposedly independent advice, but there's an awareness uh of what might or might not fly. It's like consultancies who deliver you the answer you want. So I I don't know that the Treasury saying something. For example, the [snorts] Treasury's uh big number that they've quoted of 11 billion for pay equity. I know that Barb Ribbons and Labour don't accept it because they haven't seen the workings. And so, you know, I don't know the public should just accept it either uh until that's made available.

              Unedited transcript from YT video starting 18:33 (Raw Politics: At the risk of being cancelled…).

              FYI, Barb Ribbons = Barbara Edmonds laugh

                  1. 5.1.1.2.1.1.1.1.1

                    Thanks – something to watch (out) for in future then? Correctly correcting "Barb Ribbons" might make a good test.

                    Can it analyze YouTube videos?
                    Yes. The API accepts both uploaded video files and YouTube URLs, and the same agentic processing applies to both. Google also says the technology will power YouTube’s own Ask YouTube feature on the watch page in the coming months.

                    https://coursiv.io/blog/gemini-agentic-video

      2. 5.1.2

        I also begrudge the cost of the Accommodation Supplement. Another hand out to the landlord class.

        It also, I would think, help to keep rents at the level they are at; and at lower levels ownership of rental properties would be uprofitible, and there would therefor be fewer landlords, and more savings available for other investments.

  6. 6

    Gareth Morgan has now had a go at criticising the tax policies of the various parties, including Opportunity.

    https://newsroom.co.nz/2026/10/10/gareth-morgan-opportunitys-tax-plan-joins-labour-greens-as-regressive-for-nz/

    He blames our poor productivity on faulty tax initiatives in the past and extols his own policy, of taxing imputed rent, as the right one. I think he is probably right, but we have act on the situation as it applies today. One would have to ask whether we can salvage anything now by applying the policies which, he alleges, should have been followed a long time ago.

Comments are closed.