Three things make me optimistic for New Zealand’s economy.
Now that we know that any future New Zealand government through to 2028 will be a marginal enterprise beset by slow, difficult and hard fought compromise with little available public funding – be they left of right – it is in reality up to business and workers and households to improve the New Zealand economy.
Firstly our transition away from real estate is a trend that has not seen us behave like we were coming off heroin.
As is occurring in Australia and China, real estate has rapidly decreased as a reliable way to make any profit sufficient to permanently improve your lot in life. With that comes massive collapses like Du Val Group, the rapid collapse of the masterplanned neighbourhoods of Kainga Ora, and the reconcentration of development capital out of Auckland, or Tauranga or Hamilton, into Canterbury and Queenstown.
There’s lots of causes to this; some public sector directions, some international banking trends, some local.
Multiple economists and commentators have been saying for over a decade that this decline in activity and decline in reliance on real estate is exactly what needed to happen to New Zealand.
Unlike Australia and China, New Zealand does not have and hasn’t had a strong ecosystem of innovation commercialisation with strong state support. But as we will see, it’s happening anyway.
This shift is now deep-set.
Secondly, the growth of innovation-led large scale business.
If I had told you 10 years ago that our property market had just fallen by 20%, but that the economy was hanging in there, you wouldn’t have believed me. And, had nothing changed in our economy, you would have been right. In 1972 80% of our exports were commodities, but now they are only 55% of the total. Rocket Lab, Halter, Xero, Gallagher, and many other tech-based companies are now leaders in their field even if a lot of their ownership and operations is now international. Only took us 50 years but it is happening.
The rapid growth in cleaner energy has over the last decade accelerated to the point where New Zealand’s electricity grid is now 90% renewable. That, together with our cool climate, enables not only big investment in digital infrastructure such as Infratil, but also high value agribusiness and export-led health technology such as Fisher&Paykel Healthcare who are now a dominant global player in sleep and respiratory technology.
We know now where the value-added exports won’t come from: our dairy industry. Fonterra has deliberately determined to choose medium-value fast moving consumer good ingredient supply as its driver rather than retaining and building its own brands which are now all sold. Fonterra and Synlait remain under growth stress despite Fonterra cashing in anything of real future value. Total dairy cows in New Zealand are down from 6.7 million a decade ago to 4.7 million.
However it is also important to stress that dairy remains our largest export category by a country mile. There is no sign that dairy is following real estate as an unreliable economic partner. Same goes for New Zealand’s booming tourism markets from Australia, United States and China: the world loves us both for short term skiing and adventure, and for once-in-a-lifetime long haul destination visits.
Further, business that support agricultural exports are growing in scale and ambition from fruit robotics to inland ports. It’s a good sign where two massive inland port investments are within 50kms of each other and quite undaunted.
Our dual existing export bases are pumping.
The third part is the growth in business growth capital.
Growing a local business venture need not be reliant on the terrifying pairing of raising a mortgage on the entrepeneurs’ own house using one of the local 5 banks. For those needing growth capital we are as a whole economy doing the hard thing of weaning ourselves off the necessity of real estate.
Ten years ago, no KiwiSaver manager was funding local start up companies and the dominant local venture capital investor, Icehouse Ventures had $70m of Assets under Management. Now they have $1.5 billion, and from a wide range of investors, including KiwiSaver funds. Kiwisaver now has over $155 billion under management and growing fast, and even with all the hardship withdrawals the average savings is $40,000. Many Kiwisaver accounts are already getting to the point where their returns are superior to anything you used to be able to get from trading houses. NZSuperFund is now very close to $100 billion under management and is also investing strongly into venture capital for local businesses.
Some NZSuperFund investment case studies include: Awanui pathology services, Kaingaroa Tipu forests, Datacom, and NZGourmet the specialist fruit and vegetable grower.
And yes, both of those massive funds are from savings policies brought to you 20 years ago from the Labour Party.
For those who have expected that some time in the future there really will be a recovery back to real estate, that’s as gone as the DSIR or the Callaghan Institute. The City Rail Link and Plan Change 120 won’t save Auckland real estate.
For those that expected that a new reborn risk-hungry state would in time form a new version of the Growth and Innovation Framework/Knowledge Wave, well, nope, other long term policies proved more effective. There are indeed still good efforts such as the New Zealand Institute for Advanced Technology, and whatever good will come out of the newly merged Crown Research Institutes. One is entitled to live in hope.
For those that are expecting a new form of the state that is as directive as 1946 or 1970s whose results still dominate the entire river systems of the Clutha and Waitaki or 2020, the people have spoken and such scale of direction is neither the will of the 2026 electorate nor, even if it were, within the capacity of the state for the foreseeable future.
But that makes rational optimism about our economy in the medium term all the more remarkable.
We will rebuild this economy without them.
No comments yet.
Add a comment