Why NZ First and Opportunity will not be part of the same Goverment

On Sunday’s Q&A there was this fascinating interview with new Opportunity MP Kayla Kingdon-Bebb.

Here is the interview. It is well worth a watch.

Kingdon-Bebb is clearly articulate, intelligent, principled, and knows her stuff.

She has an impressive background, previously a private secretary for Maggie Barry and Eugenie Sage and she was previously Director of Policy at DOC. Since leaving the Public Service she was CEO of WWF-New Zealand.

My strong response was to wonder why she did not join the Green Party? Her particular concerns, the environment, particular ocen health and climate change and treaty issues are well within the Green Kaupapa.

My strong impression is that there is no way that Opportunity and NZ First can be part of the same governming arrangement.

Christopher Luxon must be praying and hoping and wishing that the right majority survives the counting of specials.

Because otherwise there is no path to Government for him unless somehow Opprtunity can be bought off. And if they are it will be the beginning of the end for them as a party.

Opportunity’s five bottom lines are relevant, and also “any governing partner must agree to [them] for our support.”

Slightly loose language but certainly if they go into coalition with other parties the bottom lines have to be met. If not they could pledge confidence and supply but this would go awfully close to breaching their bottom lines. A lawyer may be able to draw a distinction between the two. I am not sure that Opportunity supporters would be able to do this.

Dealing with the interview with Kingdon-Bebb there were four standout parts to the interview.

She was a co author of the He Puapua report, a report that the right demonised to whip up racist support.

When asked if she stood by the recommendations in the report she said this:

[A] lot of the sort of screeching about co-governance is being done by people who haven’t actually read the report. It’s overarching recommendation, and it prepared a suite of options for government to consider about how to become more compliant with the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. The suite of options was intentionally very broad. It’s only overarching recommendation, really, is that the government should engage all New Zealanders in an open-ended and inclusive conversation about what declaration compliance might look like. So I think it’s been, frankly, quite badly misrepresented by some politicians for political purposes, and I think it’s really disappointing because the integrity of the work is actually very good.”

When asked why she thought He Puapua became a flashpoint she said:

[O]ver the last 15 years particularly, I think we’ve seen actors in society and some politicians seek to use politics of race and division for political ends, and I think that is really disappointing.

She then discussed Opportunity’s proposed bottom trawling ban.

The conversation went like this:

Tame – You called the Hauraki Gulf ring-netting decision the result of sleazy backdoor lobbying. WWF … ran a campaign inviting kiwis to give fisheries Minister Shane Jones the finger. Could you support a government with him as fisheries minister?

Kingdon-Bebb – I think that would be very challenging, but Opportunity has not ruled it out.

Tame – Right. And how about your personal relationship with him? Do you think you could work together?

Kingdon-Bebb – Yes, so I’ve actually met Shane Jones a number of times, including in my former life as a senior official, but subsequently as the CE of WWF. In a small group of people, Mr. Jones has a good policy brain. He can be reasonable. He, as you probably know, often has a bit of a different persona in a large crowd or in the media.

The third standout part of the interview was what she thought of Michael Laws, who had made some outrageous comments about her.

She said this:

I find Michael Laws to be pretty seedy and creepy. I’m not wrapped at the idea of, and in fact, I’ll make it my business not to be in a room alone with him. Despite sending me an apology, which read something to the effect of, “I’m sorry I offended you,” which in my mind is not actually an apology, it’s fairly clear to me that the man is relatively unrepentant. And I’m not personally offended by the comments he made. I am appalled that New Zealand First is allowing a senior candidate to make misogynist, debasing comments, which in effect are lowering the tone politically and in a climate where we’ve seen increasing violence and harm against women in politics, to allow that to stand. And so I sincerely hope that Mr. Peters, as their leader, deals to that.

Finally she was asked why she stood for Parliament and said this:

[T]he thing that really pushed me over the edge to stand for Opportunity was watching the systematic dismantling of New Zealand’s climate architecture in the last term, which, as you know, had been painstakingly negotiated between the Greens and National and Labour to buy consensus. I really believe that for New Zealand to make progress on some of the most wicked challenges facing us, be it climate change or child poverty or infrastructure deficit, we do need to rebuild the political centre and forge consensus. And that is what motivated me to stand for Opportunity, because that’s what we’re about. So I would love to see some progress, obviously on ocean conservation, on restoring New Zealand’s climate credibility.

Having watched this the chances of some sort of governing arrangement involving NZ First and Opportunity I would think are nil.

They are both seeking to to occupy the same part of the political spectrum, the centre, but with diametrically different approaches. Opportunity is trying to be reasonable and evidence based and establish a science based consensus. NZ First wants to run culture wars and spark dissent and division.

This is a battle for survival. They both know it. One mistake by either leadership group could spell the end of their party as a viable entity.

Do not rule out what previously appeared to be impossible, NZ First negotiating with Labour a coalition agreement that excludes Opportunity.

This could get very interesting.

26 comments on “Why NZ First and Opportunity will not be part of the same Goverment”

  1. 1

    Kayla is also in solid command up close.

    Would be at least as good as Sage as a Minister of Conservation or Fisheries.

    Hopefully some clarity in 10 days.

    1. 1.1

      “…as good as Sage…”

      Do you mean “as good as Sage was prior to her entering Parliament”?

      Eugenie Sage is vastly more experienced in those roles.

        1. 1.1.1.1

          I was really impressed by the interview. For a newbie to hone in on the stuff that matters so quickly was refreshing.

          But I think she should be in the Greens …

    1. 2.1

      Given this is Winston’s last rodeo, will he chuck Laws under the bus to make it all work? From memory he said he’ll deal with Laws after the election? but so far as I know, punishment not yet handed down. He could deliver a head on a platter to Opp.

    2. 2.2

      “would NZ1st be willing to provide a C&S agreement”?

      I don’t think so. This is Winston’s last rodeo (agree with you AJ). He wants to be PM for a while and to have a sovereign investment fund. But Opportunity cannot be part of the mix.

  2. 3

    NZ First are collectively bullies and would consider “demoting” OP to the non-Government cross-benches as an acceptable slap-down and belittlement, whether it was or was not, in fact.

  3. 4

    Why do you think a mistake by NZF leadership team would spell doom for them Mickey ?

    Winnie appears bulletproof and has the culture war claxon on standby to call to his flock with.
    ​
    Can’t see that going west anytime soon tbh having successfully recruited extra fringe players since 2023 to keep Shane company.

    1. 4.1

      It is getting four dimensional chess on it but NZF and Opportunity will want to be king makers and their opposition not be kingmakers.

      If either of them are sidelined or either of them back the wrong government they are toast.

      I am not sure that Opportunity have the backroom analyists telling them this but it is fascinating the way it is developing.

      It is like Borg verses Klingon for all you treckies out there.

  4. 5

    Here is a simple argument as to why they likely will support the right in some way if the Parliament is otherwise hung, which may well be the case after specials.
    ​
    The reason is that the alternative would be a new election. An immediate new election would be under the current rules. Hence would be even more vulnerable to strategic voting because voters understand that now. And, it won’t be as if the right will have forced the election. The blame will most likely be attributed to Opportunity for not doing a deal at least for confidence and supply.
    ​
    Not only would a new election likely heavily favour the right due to the strength of their overhang position. It may well also result in Opportunity missing the 5% threshold this time around. So, if Opportunity is going to obstinant, they may well make their own position a lot worse, along with the position of the left.

    1. 5.1

      ​And, it won’t be as if the right will have forced the election.

      A new election because the nACTF CoC couldn’t win a second term the first time around, even with an unprecented six overhang seats, might give more voters pause to wonder why. Imho, CEO Lux is hollow in word and deed – some Kiwis don’t care; maybe OP MPs do?

      WATCH: Nineteen times Christopher Luxon has ruled out the Opportunity Party [Stuff, 19 Oct 2026]

      Was it really only nineteen times? Ten more days until the nACTF caretaker ‘govt’ (by and for the sorted) starts to woo OP in earnest.

      Sharon Murdoch, in the Sunday Star Times, 25 October 2026​

  5. 6

    Good post. Looking forward to learning more about the other incoming OP MPs.

    Possible the greatest thing OP can do is replace NZF as the centrist party. Right now they are dragging the Overton Window back from Trumpian populism. This is a very good thing. Standing in the centre and saying reasonable instead of reactionary things.

  6. 7

    One of the main criticisms I’ve seen on Twitter from political commentators is the OP are inexperienced and will get eaten alive by ACT, NZF and National. We will see but so far they look like they are boxing clever.

    1. 7.1

      I agree. Their bottom lines are really well designed and Kingdom-Bebb’s interview suggests that it is really well thought through.

      They could back down and be castigated. If they do this they will fail.

      But I think they are trying to emulate the Teal movement in Australia which looks like it could be quite resilient.

      And I suspect they will not back down.

      Going to a new election on their bottom lines will be transformative. And I suspect they would do quite well although I am not so sure about the left.

  7. 8

    By leadership team, I assume you mean the behind the scenes, largely unknown funders or owners of the party.

    Like Luxon, Wong isn’t in charge of their respective party’s.

    If the money folk want in with National they will be in.

    1. 8.1

      Agree gsays.
      When crunch time comes it will be the money folk behind Opp. who will call the shots.

      My bet is: they will sit on the cross benches (or a derivation of it) and promise not to bring down any government be it left or right. There might be a proviso to that, but have no idea what it might be.

  8. 9

    I also thought it was an impressive interview. But, how typical of OPP MPs is Kingdom-Bebb? And does OPP’s ‘neither left nor right centrism’ consist merely of containing a bunch of people with different viewpoints? And if so, how will that hold together under negotiating pressure?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *