Let me begin by suggesting that the Single Transferable Vote (STV) option in the 1992 referendum was preferable. In the 1993 referendum, First Past the Post (FPP) was preferable. Mixed Member Proportional (MMP) won 54% to 46%, a clear win but not a weighty endorsement.
MMP is an unfortunate system for many reasons but particularly because it seeks to obscure class conflict. In this it is no friend of working people.
We can all agree that the fight for political democracy – that is, adult suffrage – was, and is, a hard road. Winning the vote is a continuing struggle, particularly in a world evermore patrolled by a new global feudal-style aristocracy.
The confidence that we have in liberal democracy in New Zealand is harder to find in large parts of the globe. Liberal democracy is not protected by a ratchet system, whereby gains in democratic voice become a new stable platform for further gains. Polities can fall back into despotism despite previous democratic gains. Current trends in Brazil are interesting.
This means that the protection of democratic voice is important. However, that is only part of the story. In the Nineteenth Century, the debate about political democracy – with suffrage its heart – was complemented by the “other” democratic matter – industrial democracy. This addressed worker voice in the ownership and control of production.
In general, if concessions were made (and won) in terms of political power, they were less frequent and harder fought in the realm of ownership and control of capital and profits. Collective bargaining was generally the closest working people came to ownership and control, and any student of Industrial Relations, or, for that matter NZ’s Employment Contracts Act, will understand how fierce is the opposition to worker voice and control.
The baffling aspect of the struggle for industrial democracy has been the Left’s progressive disengagement with the idea. The ideology of private property so effectively promulgated since the Eighteenth Century is powerful. Today, Industrial Relations, ownership and control, creation and distribution of wealth are all approached by the Left as one would a choleric Inland Taipan.
With this timidity comes a distancing of the Labour tradition from working people as its core constituency, a downgrading in the voice of unions and the growth of a latter-day pluralism, given oxygen by Post-Modernism, in which Labour’s newly found broad church marginalises its traditional base. The role of marketing strategy in party and electoral activities promotes that marginalisation.
And there are reams of scholarship, in Economics, History and Sociology especially, to anchor this inchoate pluralism. Much of contemporary economic orthodoxy exists on the basis of Capital’s attack on the centuries-old Labour Value model, mounted from the early Nineteenth Century, and consolidated in the 1870s marginalist framework.
The often-unspoken target of this scholarship has been class analysis. Labour value analysis prioritises the quality and quantity of labour embodied in production, in the process explaining how capitalist exploitation occurs, and establishing the basis for class conflict and exploitation under Capitalism.
Contemporary economic orthodoxy remains rooted in a Nineteenth Century move to obscure that exploitation by emphasising the individual and their choices. There is no structured exploitation under Capitalism, merely the outcome of myriad individual choices expressed in prices. There is no space for effective economic democracy, for ownership and control is an important expression of individual freedom, in this case to own, control and dispose of assets.
So well established has become this mode of analysis and organisation, radical alternatives have found it hard to prosper. Even in the Labour tradition, its historical commitment to abolishing economic exploitation has been diluted.
So we come to MMP. MMP is political system designed to obscure class differences (that is, differences based on exploitation in Capitalism) and, instead promote the narrow view of political life as a choice between myriad parties grounded in the status quo. MMP is clever, for its essential pluralism, its essential centrism, promote “safe” contending views, yet obscure the contradictions within Capitalism with a fig-leaf of contending pluralist interests. Its essential pluralism obscures and rejects class analysis.
For the Left, to play in the MMP pool carries many dangers. It is a system for and of a narrow view of political democracy. It plays to a 1960s pluralism of contending elites. It traps the Left in debates and institutions in which class perspectives are framed as illegitimate, conflictual, archaic. It doesn’t address the lacuna in industrial democracy. Above all, it traps the Left in a political order in which its historical and historic role – that is, to transform Capitalism in the interest of working people – is at best irrelevant, at worst a danger to that circumscribed democracy.
One curious aspect of New Zealand finally arriving at something like a true MMP outcome, thirty or so years after its implementation, is the changed circumstances since the early 1990s. MMP in New Zealand appears to be coming of age in an era of polarisation and conflict globally and, perhaps, locally. The conditions for the maturation of MMP in New Zealand are not promising. This contrasts strongly with, for example, Denmark in which a comparable system has been in place since 1920 and has developed deep roots in the obfuscation of class conflict.
So, is that it for this election?
We all vote. If National get more votes than Labour, OP make a deal with Luxon and the coalition-plus-OP govern for the next 3 years?
Is that IT???
Pathetic.
Are you suggesting that FPP is a more preferable system to the Left than MMP?
That seems, in the NZ context, entirely counterfactual.
FPP – in the latter half of the twentieth century – locked in the government alternating between the two centrist parties.
It was only under MMP that we started to see the development of various Left parties (Alliance, Greens)
This entire premise is based on the assumption or contention that people vote based on their "class".
I don't find any evidence that this is the case in NZ in the 21st century. Just what party do you think that the 'workers' vote for? Its certainly not Labour (or they'd be romping into government at every election).
Alot of turkeys vote for Christmas in nz, white dummy males,
As a white male, that's a bit sexist – there are plenty of left voting males who aren't dummies, and plenty of dummies who vote right who aren't white and male. Fixing one glass ceiling by replacing it with another doesn't make the world a better place, IMHO.
There endeth the lesson…
My real comment is that I think that what we are seeing as a worrying drop in support for the two main parties is MMP bedding down to the point that election outcomes will be a mix of any party combinations. In a couple of elections, for example, the greens may be the highest polling party and look to who it can work with. Or, gasp, NZ1 may be the highest polling party but find it impossible to make a coalition so ACT then forms a government.
We will need to see if that causes mmp to fail.
Those of us with longer memories know that mmp got voted in because voters wanted anything that stopped the wealthy funding both left and right and therefore controlling whatever was the outcome. Plenty of people wanted STV but mmp was offered instead because the wealthy were running scared and thought that offering an inferior alternative might get FPP back. Luckily, it didn't.
I'm am pretty much the national average nz male , white 55, so I'm allowed to be rude about my own ,
Mmp was probably my first truly politically aware vote.
Any wage earner under the $150 000 bracket is a fool to vote right, , hope running them all down make me a equal opportunity arshole!!!
It was a reaction to the disastrous changes both Labour 84 and National 90 inflicted on us. We voted the first, effectively ACT, Government out, only to get National doubling down on it.
Whichever one got in we had the same Neo-Liberal result. People who were not even born then, have no idea of the job losses and homelessness that were inflicted on people. Those "lucky boomers" eh? I know many that never recovered. The policy settings which have caused our decline, havn't been reversed. Lately the Coalition of Cockups has doubled down on them, and our young skilled people are "voting with their feet". Only a very few of the apprentices, I trained in the last four decades, are still here.
It is obvious that we need further curtailment of politicians power. Constutional change, not changes solely to voting systems. "If voting changed anything they would get rid of it"!
Swiss style direct democracy is an example of system change. Ireland has used citizens assemblies. Wales is criminalising deliberate lying by politicians. For just a few examples.
Fair points. Whether the space or willingness for changes in our political system are available is a big question in a world in crisis. Labour should be leading the change in analysis and politics. It’s why Labour came into existence – to champion working people in the face of exploitation and misery.
There's an MMP election campaign on. Thousands are not yet enrolled. Only days to go.
Abstract pondering about which of the various flawed voting systems is preferable? Not exactly a priority right now.
+100
MMP was designed for Germany to moderate the extremes. That it would result in multiple parties so no one party could hijack the democratic system, as the Nazis had done on gaining a majority in 1933.
Maybe that is a potential problem with FPP, that if a major portray becomes extreme, they can capture the government. As perhaps is now the case in the US. Except unlike Nazi Germany, we can be pretty sure elections will continue in the US, which limits the opportunity of extremists.
Of course NZ is nothing like Germany of 1933. There is no real prospects of extremist parties actually capturing the government.
Maybe the moderation that Nigel perceives (and decries) is less about the electoral system and more about the political character of New Zealand.
Of course NZ is nothing like Germany in 1930s. Hmmmm. What were the mental themes being pushed yhere, what were people being enticed, exhorted about and why? Traces of it here? Could be. Needs thinking not absolute statements.
Too late!
Extremist parties captured our Government in 1984 and 90. Unfortunately no one has been able to reverse the damage.
And for the last three years. Dismantling a functioning country. The collapse of the water and health systems, are just the first of many.
Neither FPP or MMP has succeeded in keeping them out. We voted against Rogernomics only to get Ruthanasia. Now we have No Boats, aided by the Cookers and the proto Fascists, trying to outdo both those unfortunate experiments.
Our instincts to limit the power of Governments to make major fuckups like these, which caused us to vote for MMP, were correct .
It is obvious that the powers of a few politicians in Wellington, in our system of rotating Dictatorship, need further curtailment.
Of course the two "major parties" are happy with their "turns" and have no desire to allow democracy. Hell. The 80% of us who think the rich should pay taxes, may exert our Democratic power.
It shows how much the Overton window has shifted, that the current bunch of idealogical maniacs is considered in any way, moderate!
Maybe people should read up on Industrial Democracy.
[Please fix the error in your e-mail, thanks – Incognito]
Mod note
I remember having a conversation about STV with Bruce Beetham, ex MP for Rangititkei at an election meeting in 1993 (I think) and he explained how and why he favoured STV, which I had not really thought about before.
He had some clear and quite good arguments, but by then it had really come down to MMP (and the paper bags over the list MPs faces) or the old boys" of FPP and the useless old fuddy duddies in safe seats accountable to nobody.