RNZ-Reid poll happy dance

This is good. It’s one poll, trends are better, but what it gives left wing parties and volunteers a big confidence boost twenty days out from the start of voting, thirty-two days from election day proper.

The good news:

  • National have dropped to mid twenties
  • Labour and Green are looking strong on 45% combined
  • A centre left government could be formed with Opportunity, and Labour are the biggest polling party so Opportunity would talk with them first
  • That government would have two more Green MPs (depending)
  • A centre left government, and I can’t emphasise this enough, could form without Winston Peters.

A few complexities. It’s hard to tell how polling companies are calculating Te Pāti Māori seats.

Opportunity in this poll are on 5.5%. Their average over recent polls is higher (hence the value of the trend, not individual polls). But if they dropped below 5%, my back of the AI envelope calculation is there would be an overhang, with Left bloc on 62 and Right bloc on 60. I’d really like to see some proper calculations done, with different scenarios around Opportunity, Te Pāti Māori, and overhangs, and will update the post if I see any.

It’s not a done deal by any means, so let’s keep up the good work. I personally believe that how we all talk about the election at home, with family and friends, at work and play, and online, affects how people think and thus vote. Including getting people to vote at all, and swing voters. Kindness and encouragement go a long way, as does highlighting Labour, Green and Te Pāti Māori policy and positions that affect people’s every day lives. Let’s keep talking up the left.

In the meantime, enjoy!

43 comments on “RNZ-Reid poll happy dance”

    1. 1.1

      I'm expecting the 1 News poll to either not show the same trend, or to show it only weakly. Because my sense is that it has never been a particularly Labour-friendly poll. And I'd note in passing, that most of 1 News's internal commentary on their poll has always been to hyperventilate about tiny movements within the margin of error as though they constitute some revelation exclusive to 1 News – one of the many ways in which commercial 'values' can corrupt the national tv broadcaster. In any case, if I'm right it will provide a counterpoint to the RNZ-Reid poll that will allow Luxon to bluster his way through in his usual impersonation of a confident person.

      1. 1.1.1

        Headlines like "up 3, down 2" are meaningless without context. Usually a poll is published months after the last one (by the same outfit), so it's the movement over a long period. But the last TVNZ poll was just last week, so major shifts are unlikely.

        I confidently expect to be shouting at the TV when the headline tonight is "Greens down!" because they're on "only" 14 or 15%. The real headline should be "Greens support firms up, not soft, looking solid".

        Ditto Lab/Nat. They won't surge or slump ("down 1% shock!"), they're just consistently, unprecedentedly low. Which is the real story.

        1. 1.1.1.1

          I'm not sure it is the real story. As a long time GP voter, it seems fine to me whatever Labour are on so long at the combined L/G is enough to form govt (with or without support).

          Do we have this idea that the main parties should be above a certain %? Why is that?

  1. 3

    Luxon's personal numbers are dismal (Hipkins' numbers are mediocre).

    The fun now is in the bickering on the Right. It will get very nasty, as they argue about tactics and tetchy thin-skinned Luxon doubles and triples down (his only response setting).

    1. 3.1

      Fingers crossed in the debate, Hipkins can stay above the drowning man desperation of Mr Thumb.

      And please, no scripted swear words, inauthenticity is more damaging than wearing a white pillow case holding a burning cross.

      1. 3.1.1

        I'm a touch apprehensive about that debate. What if Luxo is allowed to get away with endlessly chanting something like SmirKey's "show me the money" mantra?

        1. 3.1.1.1

          "Show me the money" is a concern, but how much more money does the CoC want to claw back from everyday Kiwis?
          The adult minimum wage (+2%, +1.5% & +1.9% in '24, '25 & '26 respectively) has decreased in real terms over the last 3 years sad

          Budget 2025: Coalition claws back savings from pay equity, KiwiSaver, Best Start [careful now RNZ, 22 May 2025]

          ACT outlines policy to freeze adult minimum wage for three years [1News, 15 Sept 2026]

          Guy Body, in the New Zealand Herald

  2. 4

    Faced with less than 27% support and spiralling, Simple Simeon finally acknowledges "This is going to be a close-call election…"

    As a visual metaphor of this morning's poll, on the face of other recent polls, I supply this clip of the Natz bombers cruising their way to giving the country another trouncing when, out of the sun, come the left's finely-honed fighter wing, taking Hauptmann Luxon and Unterleutenant Brown completely by surprise…

    "Go get em, Hipkins"!!

  3. 5

    A few complexities. It’s hard to tell how polling companies are calculating Te Pāti Māori seats.

    Usually the reporting will have a line about it somewhere in the report or article and it is often clear from the projections around the make-up of Parliament. Also, once the polling company provides results to whoever commissioned the poll, the commissioner and others can then analyse the results. In this particular case, it is covered in the article:

    The basic seat projection assumes Te Pāti Māori would win at least one electorate, but that no party creates an overhang by winning more electorates than it would otherwise be allocated according to its party vote.

    For anyone wanting to do their own seat projections, the Electoral Commission has a handy calculator online: https://elections.nz/stats-and-research/mmp-seat-allocation-calculator

      1. 5.1.1

        AFAIK, the only polling company which has polled Maori electorates, specifically, is Curia (on behalf of Whakaata Maori)

      2. 5.1.2

        Excellent point.

        After digging around a bit, I'm not sure why TPM are assumed to lose seats (they currently have 4) – they won a by-election in Tāmaki Makaurau ahead of Labour not that long ago, so 4-5 seems more likely. Published results of Whakaata Māori polling (conducted by Curia) have them ahead in Te Tai Hauāuru and Hauraki-Waikato, while Labour are ahead in Te Tai Tonga.

        WHAKAATA MĀORI – CURIA POLL: TE TAI HAUĀURU | Media Release | Whakaata Māori

        Maipi-Clarke leads Hauraki-Waikato as party vote remains neck and neck – Te Ao Māori News

        WHAKAATA MĀORI – CURIA POLL: TE TAI TONGA | Media Release | Whakaata Māori

        I would guess Labour retains Ikaroa-Rāwhiti, picks up Te Tai Tonga (as above), and not sure about Te Tai Tokerau – it might be retained by the independent, throwing everyone's analysis out, or TPM to maximise the overhang (Kelvin Davis lost the seat in 2023, no guarantees Willow-Jean Prime will win this time despite being the best-known name). I can't really see TPM not retaining Waiariki either.

  4. 6

    Going to be very close. But things are looking good for TOP to be in parliament supporting a Labour led government.

    1. 6.1

      The other story is that left-leaning voters should stop fretting about Opportunity, because if they do get 4.9% the combined opposition are ahead of the coalition, after wasted votes. (Of course that is very changeable, but the claim that TOP have to be there to change the government isn't true. Take them out and it's a coin toss, really).

          1. 6.1.1.1.1

            Even if National are ahead of Labour – all TOP have said is that they will negotiate 'first' with the largest party. They have not said (and I do not expect them ever to say) that they will not also negotiate with the next largest party.

            If TOP are in a kingmaker position, then it stops being a 'coin toss' and starts being a negotiation.

            1. 6.1.1.1.1.1

              But National has already ruled out going with TOP laugh Yeah, Right.

              More seriously, I think National could form a coalition with TOP, but not a coalition of National, ACT, NZ1 and TOP.

              1. 6.1.1.1.1.1.1

                More seriously, I think National could form a coalition with TOP, but not a coalition of National, ACT, NZ1 and TOP.

                yes And, on current polling trends, a deflating National would need the support of all three. Perhaps Winston First and Atlas ACT will curb their racist and anti-environment tendencies once the election results are in and negotiations begin, but Kiwis could be in for a long post-election wait, Goldsmith's rationale notwithstanding.

                https://thestandard.nz/this-trick-of-national-could-win-them-the-2026-election/

                Controversial Amendments Not Recommended by Anyone [Salient, 7 Sept 2026]
                This year, the Electoral Commission expects that 55,000 such votes will be disallowed on the basis of un-enrolment, with an additional 72,000 disallowed because a voter has moved and not changed their enrolment details by the date of
                25 October. The total is more than seven times the number of disallowed votes from the last election.

                The government's rationale for the change was to improve the “timeliness, efficiency, integrity, and resilience of elections and their operations,” yet the commission has maintained that the changes will make no difference to the release timeline of election results.
                …
                The Ministry of Justice regulatory impact statement (RIS) prepared for the amendment act predicted that “an earlier enrolment deadline may merely shift enrolment demand in the run up to the election rather than reduce it,” and that for this reason the “option is not preferred.”

                In 2025 Chief Electoral Officer Karl Le Quesne said that if the changes weren’t made the commission would have had to “resource up in a much bigger scale than otherwise,” but was clear that the amendment was “not a change that we recommended.”

                The same year Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith told RNZ that allowing late enrolments placed “too much strain on the system,” and that “the 20-day timeframe will likely already be challenging to achieve at the next election.” Goldsmith also said that people had a year to get organised, and that he had “every confidence New Zealander’s can manage.”

                Public law professor Andrew Geddis expressed concerns that large-scale changes to voting practices make it difficult for voters to change their behaviour quickly enough, consequentially leaving them unable to participate in the democratic process due to changes made in administrative law.

                “If those numbers are quite considerable and if we have a quite close election, then we do have this question as to whether the legitimacy of the election has been affected by people who wanted to take part being told that the law no longer allows them to do so,” he told Newsroom.

          2. 6.1.1.1.2

            If National creates an overhang and thereby pushes ahead of Labour, then what would TOP do? [HT to Jonathan Milne’s Newsroom Pro/Breakdown e-mail newsletter]

            1. 6.1.1.1.2.1

              Okay, this answers my question:

              "Our first principle is to negotiate first with the party that gets the largest number of votes at the election. I think that's a tradition that enables stable politics, and so that's the approach we would take." [Qiulae Wong]

              https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics/618657/opportunity-party-leader-qiulae-wong-on-the-party-s-surprise-surge-in-a-new-poll

              So, it’s the number of votes rather than seats that’s the deciding factor.

              [HT to commenter Desmond Darby https://newsroom.co.nz/2026/10/07/blinder-or-blowout-newsrooms-leader-debate-takeaways/#comment-697433 ]

                1. 6.1.1.1.2.1.1.1

                  It’s a verbatim quote and says “negotiate”. I don’t doubt Wong may have used “talk” on other occasions (do you have a link?), but I think that is/means one and the same thing, in this context, unless one distinguishes between formal and informal stages of negotiating the next Government. Anyways, it’s a different question to the one I posed and have now answered.

              1. 6.1.1.1.2.1.2

                It doesn't make sense anyway. Scenario:

                Bloc A: 59

                Bloc B: 51

                TOP: 10. (For simple maths, we'll ignore overhang).

                But within Bloc B Lab/Nat have a few more votes than Nat/Lab in the other Bloc.

                Good luck sticking with the "largest party" line. It wouldn't wash.

                1. 6.1.1.1.2.1.2.1

                  what?

                  If the left bloc have the most votes but Lab has less than National, OP would negotiate first with Nat.

                  that seems unfair to me, but I think it makes sense from a centrist position because it's old school stability.

                2. 6.1.1.1.2.1.2.2

                  I’m usually one who overthinks and thus overcomplicates things but this one is clear & obvious to me.

                  Bloc ≠ Party

                  Most votes ≠ most seats

                  Negotiations to form a Government tend to be one-on-one talks between Parties (e.g., the coalition negotiations were two 2-way talks between National & NZ First and National & ACT, producing 2 separate Coalition Agreements).

                  So, it does make sense, to me.

                  1. 6.1.1.1.2.1.2.2.1

                    Sure, they could try, and they could argue for logic and reason.

                    But this is politics. Not an academic seminar. The pressure on TOP would be huge. And probably the pressure from within their own party, bearing in mind they would have (in this case) 10 new MPs, who are not like NZF, not a "leader decides and dictates" party.

                    Obviously the scenario I've given is extreme, and very unlikely, but it demonstrates the weakness of the TOP line. It won't hold up in the real world of media glare. Especially if National are in Bloc A and the full force of their cheer squad is applied.

                    I'd suggest it's better to prepare for commitments being "flexible" than to be shocked when we discover post-election that they are – as they usually are.

                    Luxon’s commitment (no to TOP) certainly will be flexible. In fact, it will vanish.

        1. 6.1.1.2

          Obviously. But not my point.

          "The opposition need Opportunity" is not true. So it's not necessary to try to get them over 5% for tactical reasons only. Which is not the same as voting for their policies.

          We can guess at who Opportunity would go with (influenced by our own preferences, probably). FWIW I'd expect them to be there, and favouring Labour/Greens.

          1. 6.1.1.2.1

            Right now, the Opposition do need TOP. Because, without them it's a coin toss.

            You can continue to campaign to not need TOP (because Labour/Greens/TPM have an outright majority without them) – but that is not the current situation.

  5. 7

    I have never before seen an NZ minor party time its polling run as well as this.

    Not even United's "worm turn" was as steep or fast as the Green and Opportunities jump.

    Things can still shift with a month to go, but this is a very powerful trend.

  6. 8

    Given that Labour wants to run its fiscal policy within budget limits which essential adopt Nicky No Boats settings why would the Greens want to form a coalition with Labour?

    1. 8.1

      Because forming a coalition with
      National would be like tying yourself to an anchor and throwing it overboard?

    2. 8.2

      Because they have to form a coalition with someone who has around 30% of the vote – if they want to be in government – and Labour are the least bad choice!

      Really, forming a government under MMP is the art of the possible – no one ever gets everything they want.

  7. 9

    TVNZ Verrian poll does not show the same trend – as expected. In fact, no changes of any note at all really: Nat 29 (up 1), Lab 28 (no change) – nothing like the 4%+ lead for Lab over Nat in the RNZ-Reid. It's a lifeline for the Lux (sadly). OPP now with kingmaker role, so expect the parties on the right to step up scaremongering over OPP to drive them under 5%. The Nats want 4.5% of wasted vote going to OPP with most of that having come from the soft (semi-deluded?) left – then the Nats can cakewalk it unless something else changes.

    1. 9.1

      OPP now with kingmaker role, so expect the parties on the right to step up scaremongering over OPP to drive them under 5%.

      yes nACT and Winston First will be gunning for TOP, but they'd better not get too dirty. If TOP can keep it's head above 5% (wouldn't be a worry if any govt had implemented the 4% threshold recommendation of the 2012 MMP review), then nACT1 on ~48% 'plays' LabGreenOP on 51%, and, as indicated in weka's post, TOP's five bottom lines are more compatible with LabGreen than with nACT1.

Comments are closed.