Open Mike 06/10/2026

42 comments on “Open Mike 06/10/2026”

    1. 2.1

      "What this poll suggests is that the relatively negative campaign being run by both parties about who is lying, who is taxing, and who is being irresponsible with taxpayers' money is not resonating with as many voters as they might like."

      https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics_election-2026/1749722/rnz-reid-research-poll-nightmare-on-national-street-while-greens-soar

      More than one opinion issuer has said the negative campaigning is off putting. I would love to see more leadership, positivity and optimism from Hipkins/Labour.

      Whenever there is criticism from Willis, dismiss it with a simple sentence then press on with the vision for Aotearoa and how we will get there. Something like 'Well she has shown how out of her depth she is in managing the economy, what Labour will do is X,Y,Z." Media time is woefully short to bicker about what Nicky No Boats reckons.

      Be mindful of the observation about teaching a pig to dance, you both get dirty but only the pig enjoys it. National don't have anything else, they have no track record to boast about. Stop buying into their quibbles and paint a rosy Red picture.

      It seems like a long time ago when Ardern's message to her pollies during campaign season was to not comment on National's woes and to be kind.

      https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics_election-2026/1749722/rnz-reid-research-poll-nightmare-on-national-street-while-greens-soar

      1. 2.1.1

        I think it's "wrestle" – if you wrestle …

        Trouble is, some pigs come looking to wrestle, even when you're not in a wrestling mood.

        That's when you need to make sure you're well greased-up!

      2. 2.1.2

        I don't think the lesson here is that negative campaigning doesn't work. It plainly can. And it would be rather strange if Labour didn't at least gesture vaguely at the current government's record as part of its argument for change.

        But whether negative campaigning works depends heavily on the conditions on the ground.

        The attack has to be:

        1. believable;
        2. delivered by a messenger voters trust, or at least regard as credible on the issue;
        3. about something voters actually care about; and
        4. consistent with the conditions voters are experiencing on the ground.

        That's where I think National has a problem.

        "Labour wrecked the economy" was a much easier argument to make in 2023, when Labour had been governing for six years. It's rather harder in 2026, after National has itself been governing for three.

        Likewise, attacking Labour over taxes works if voters already think Labour is going to tax them into oblivion. But attacking National over the economy works if people have just lost their jobs or are struggling to pay the bills. Attacking them over public services works if people are sitting in an emergency department for twelve hours or can't get their kid seen by a specialist.

        The negativity isn't inherently the problem. The problem is when political parties mistake saying something negative loudly and repeatedly for giving voters a persuasive reason to believe it.

        And I do agree about Labour needing a positive proposition alongside that. "Look at their record" answers why the government should be thrown out. It doesn't answer the equally important question: "Why should we put you in?"

        1. 2.1.2.1

          Yes. In a sense campaigning is always 'negative', but it is less likely to be successful if it is outside the four constraints you describe.

      3. 2.1.3

        Frankly that's a ridiculous quote from a typically poor column by Jo Moir.

        The "both sides" cop-out won't wash. It's literally her job to report facts and call out lies. Which she rarely does.

        When Luxon/Willis/Brown lie, Hipkins should say so.

        And Moir's comment about "hindsight" is laughable. Nobody needed hindsight to see how bad Luxon is and how stupid National were to keep him.

      4. 2.1.4

        Doesn't suggest anything of the sort about a "negative campaign" upon National's vote fall.

        Luxon is collapsing and taking down the entire Nationalivote, because his leadership and actions are being effectively exposed.

        The only other time in NZ history we've seen a government fall after one term was 1974, and that was won on a fundamentally negative National campaign.

        The job this time is to kill the government.

        1. 2.1.4.1

          We've had two one term govts actually labour in 1957-1960 after the brutal black budget led by Walter Nash.

          It's about time for a one term national govt, we've had two one term labour govts!

          But yeah Luxons losing this election on his own with constant own goals and just being so unlikable, also the nastiness is just so unkiwi, I honestly wonder how this election would be shaping out if labour had a leader who was any good rather than just "not Luxon"

    2. 2.3

      can luxon take them below 20%

      To give the man some credit, he's certainly capable of achieving that result! I'm backing him!

      1. 2.3.3

        Perhaps he can "chunk it down" in a series of 1% point decrements? Although he richly deserves such a result and the whole Luxon-Willis economic project needs to be permanently discredited, this is probably too much to hope for.

    3. 2.4

      It’s more likely that National will go under 20% in the polls than that Nicola Willis will get core Crown spending down under 30% of GDP, particularly given that she’s got no credible plan to grow GDP beyond more dairy exports. In any case, she’s likely to be out of Parliament on current polling.

  1. 3

    The reason Labour is polling poorly is that the constant blaming and belittling by National Party MPs and their media hacks, has shaped public perception, as it was designed to do.

    The reason National is polling so badly is that they're utter shite 🙂

    1. 3.1

      Speaking of "utter shite", last night I watched the first episode of a UK docudrama – 'Dirty Business' (2026).
      Elements in common with 'Mr Bates vs the Post Office' (2024), and 'Breathtaking' (2024)' – cover-ups and (thankfully) whistleblowing.

      Let's pray "Local Water Done Well" keeps a lid on the consequences of ecological overshoot – Queenstown residents hope so.

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_pollution_in_New_Zealand
      https://maps.greenpeace.org/maps/aotearoa/know-your-nitrate/


      Chris Slane, in the New Zealand Listener, 26 August 2016 – https://natlib.govt.nz/records/45847149

      1. 3.1.1

        Any idea why Veolia is not being prosecuted for the outage? Were they never responsible for maintenance feedback, only running, of the plant?

        They do a lot of ducking and diving in the report identifying who did and said what. "We told Wellington Water there was an issue" (which was so muted that WW couldn't recall it). "We didn't put more staff on during repairs because WW never told us to".

        Being paid a bucketload on money to run such plants because that's your international business surely requires more effort that writing a few milquetoast emails every now and then and scooping up the profits.

        https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/regions_wellington/1224096/moa-point-disaster-caused-by-systemic-leadership-failures-damning-report-finds

        1. 3.1.1.1

          Any idea why Veolia is not being prosecuted for the outage?

          A(t)las no, but thanks for that RNZ article link.

          The creation of Tiaki Wai, which owns the assets and has its own funding, has opened the door to a transparent and cooperative approach to overcome the broader systemic issues. [- Operator Veolia]

          Maybe Veolia's previous 'approach' included a cock-up on the transparency front – echos of corporate culpability in 'Dirty Business'.

          Dirty Business true story: 'This is something that affects all of us… we should all be a lot angrier' [23 Feb 2026]
          "If you're looking for an overnight change, there isn't one," said Peter matter-of-factly. "But the one change that we all believe in, the groups that we mix with, is to remove the profit motive.

          "In the end, the danger is that they're no longer doing a service, giving us clean water, cleaning our sewage and returning it safely to the environment. They're just about making money. You've got these hedge funds [like the Australia-based Macquarie Group, which led the consortium that owned Thames Water from 2006 to 2017] and others loaning the water companies money and earning interest from it, so that the loaned money can go to the shareholders and not to invest in the infrastructure."
          …
          "The Post Office thing was a terrible scandal. People went to prison, people took their own lives, people's health was damaged. But the amount of money was not on the scale of this," cautioned Peter. "80 billion pounds has been transferred to shareholders. They [the water companies] are 70 odd billion in debt."

        2. 3.1.1.2

          Not to negate anything you have said.

          Does Wellington Council have the 'resources' ($) to hold Veolia to account?

          It's just another totally shit aspect to neo-liberalism, a council with a deliberately diminished capacity to sort its own water affairs, ends up privatizing profits and socializing costs through a tender process.

        3. 3.1.1.3

          Having international knowledge means that Veolia can make bigger messes than the local yokels in Wellington could imagine, and then point the finger at our ignorance and lack of perspica-city, which we don't even know the meaning of. They picked-a-city which thought it was something to do with perspiration, and invited the knowing ones to dance on our graves if they so chose.

  2. 5

    I think it’s long overdue to increase transparency and trust because these are vital in and for the functioning of government of New Zealand. I applaud Labour’s plans to tackle lobbying and breaches of/under the Official Information Act (OIA). Frankly, I can’t wait and I hope it won’t be watered down or walked back when Labour leads the next Government, but I trust them heaps more than Coalition Mark II. I don’t know what policies, if any, the Greens, TPM, and TOP have on the OIA; TOP also wants to improve things around lobbying and political donations.

    https://newsroom.co.nz/2026/10/05/lobbyists-oia-breaches-under-microscope-as-labour-seeks-to-improve-public-trust/

    Ah! I just found this re. TOP:

    Alongside that body, the party would upgrade the day-to-day integrity rules through Official Information Act reform, stronger pecuniary interest rules, better whistleblower protections, and an independent policy costing unit available to all registered parties.

    https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics_election-2026/1010243/opportunity-party-vows-to-clean-up-politics-with-lobbying-and-donations-reforms

  3. 6

    Let’s hope this isn’t an issue here.

    ”The Guardian’s findings about the extent of sexual abuse in schoolsrequire an urgent, calibrated response. Data revealing multiple rapes committed each year on school premises in England and Wales is hard to comprehend. Yet this is what freedom of information requests to police forces, covering the period from 2021 until last year, have revealed. As well as the severity of the offences, the youth of many of the victims is disturbing. More than 8,500 sexual offences at or near schools were committed against under-13s, most of them girls.l

    https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/oct/05/the-guardian-view-on-sexual-abuse-in-schools-teachers-cannot-deal-with-this-alone?

    Although it’s unlikely our new curriculum will go anywhere near it.

    1. 6.1

      No sex education, including contraception and STDs until Year 8 (~13 yo) now, under the new RSE curriculum. Despite children going through puberty as early as eight for girls. Family First is very happy with this because "the legal age of consent is 16". Yes, for old guys preying on young girls and boys. Sex between people who are both under 16 is perfectly legal.

      https://familyfirst.org.nz/2025/10/31/new-rse-guidelines-b/

      1. 6.1.2

        Good points tWig. It is time that we had some worthwhile sexual guidelines that allow for discussion, learning and fair treatment for the young. Teach them about the power of the procreative urge at Intermediate, learning to curb it till later on, and for the younger to avoid over-friendliness and handling. It could be that there is still not enough quiet discussion in a mixed gender, restrained, informative way, and a lot of curiosity, and the young can be prey to insinuating older guys and women.

  4. 7

    The Leaders’ Debate tonight will be moderated by Jack Tame. Luxon’s performance could be ghostly as well as ghastly similar to his Party’s performance and the Coalition’s under-delivery over the last 3 years (with the a few exceptions such as landlords, farmers, bankers, some newspaper owners, toy importers, TPU, etc.).

    https://thespinoff.co.nz/podcasts/at-large-with-toby-manhire/jack-tame-on-getting-ghosted-by-luxon-and-hosting-the-first-big-debate

    1. 7.1

      They've got half an hour before the TV audience switch to Taskmaster.

      Politics tragics like us might prefer the debate show, but most voters will be tuning out after the 17th "What I would say to you …".

  5. 8

    To deviate from politics for a moment. This big fire across the lake from Queenstown is likely to have big repercussions in pastoral management on high country stations. It's a disaster, more so if, as reported, a controlled burnoff gone rogue.

    1. 8.1

      Major vegetation fire threatens Walter Peak station near Queenstown

      Fire and Emergency NZ (Fenz) said it was tackling the blaze with two helicopters equipped with monsoon buckets, attempting to protect the historic homestead and gardens.

      More aircraft are reportedly on the way to the scene.

      “Firefighters from Frankton and Glenorchy are being airlifted on to the fireground while crews from Mossburn are travelling by road,” Fenz said.

      There is no road access to the area from Queenstown.

      Fenz said the fire was a result of a controlled burn last Wednesday reigniting.

      https://www.odt.co.nz/otago/queenstown/major-vegetation-fire-threatens-walter-peak-station-near-queenstown-e7cppnu4

      Nothing changes. I well recall when living/working Qtown, Wanaka and Cromwell fkn massive out of control farm burnoff blazes….i took photos of some because they looked like volcanoes !.

      Jerks dont care as there are fck all consequences. And land is…cleared. Job done.

      1. 8.1.1

        Here are just 2 …..Controlled? Just fuckwits : (

        Skippers Canyon fire could flare up in afternoon winds – FENZ

        He said the fire started from a burnoff that went out of control, and reminded those lighting burnoffs to be extremely careful.

        "Really put a lot of thought into the planning process of lighting up – what's the weather doing, how long will this fire burn for, how can I put it out – thoughts around that I think would go a long way to reduce the numbers of fires that are escaping."

        https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/regions_otago/399861/skippers-canyon-fire-could-flare-up-in-afternoon-winds-fenz

        Two blazes burn through 1800ha across Otago

        A fire at Ben Lomond, which is visible from Queenstown, is estimated to have burned up to 1000 hectares.

        Farmers undertake burn-offs to clear land, prepare it for replanting, property maintenance and to increase accessibility for stock movement.

        https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/122707714/two-blazes-burn-through-1800ha-across-otago

        There are sadly more : (

        1. 8.1.1.1

          "Farmers undertake burn-offs to clear land, prepare it for replanting.."

          Replanting with .. grass, that translates directly into monetary profit, that is, farmers burn in order to make money.
          Who are those low-landers/non-farmers and what are they whining about???

          1. 8.1.1.1.1

            Matey I have been involved with NZ Native Plants/Birds/Animals IE NZ Environment for a few decades…seeing the devastation in those photos is just…. despair.

            The one aj commented on, and I linked to at 8.1, apparently now 6 choppers? (that was on Crux…I cant link, Im sure you can find? But will prob be on News : (

            1. 8.1.1.1.1.1

              Thanks for adding the links PL.A.

              This is also a relevant read when discussing farming, politics, science, climate change

              Responding to recent discord between Aotearoa New Zealand's agricultural sector and the government over environmental policies, this paper examines farmers’ trust in climate change science and policy and how scientific knowledge is communicated and received.

              New Zealand Farmers’ Trust in Climate Change Expertise and Policy: A Case Study

              https://rsnz.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/kot2.70058

  6. 9

    Reply to aj 8.1.1.1.1.1 Thanks for that link aj will check it out. On that subject, Ive linked these before, but here again if of interest. Note glowering FedFarm creep…now ACT Minister)

    Federated Farmers launches petition against climate change teaching resource

    https://www.stuff.co.nz/southland-times/southland-top-stories/118855668/federated-farmers-launches-petition-against-climate-change-teaching-resource

    And yeah our New Govt wont be as much of a pushover : )

    Federated Farmers issues list of demands for next government

    https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics/491612/federated-farmers-issues-list-of-demands-for-next-government

    1. 9.1

      Ta, yes Fed Farmers and Hoggard are one and the same.

      The depth of denial is very strong, pointless arguing with those types. I've heard every one of the respondents comments in that paper. Bless the very few that recognise the real issues in front of us.

Comments are closed.