
Daily review is also your post.
This provides Standardistas the opportunity to review events of the day.
The usual rules of good behaviour apply (see the Policy).
Don’t forget to be kind to each other …

Daily review is also your post.
This provides Standardistas the opportunity to review events of the day.
The usual rules of good behaviour apply (see the Policy).
Don’t forget to be kind to each other …
Comments are closed.
It will probably get lost in the noise but in the debate Luxon just said "Trump's crazy war in Iran".
Wow. That is one heck of a shift from Luxon's take when that war began.
(Hipkins and Tame let it slide, pity).
CEO Luxon’s flip-flop-mettle’ on full display – Foreign Affairs minister Winston First will be ropeable
So, a turn around in Luxon's thinking, but he could not think of any personal changes of opinion in 'matters of policy' during the Leader's debate.
I thought when he remarked on the 'crazy war' that was one time when I agreed with Luxon. But he hedged behind the ICC and ICJ when asked about genocide in Palestine. Why could he not say he was against what was happening there?
A good point was raised by Harman in the post debate discussion about the long term effect of "no new taxes' which National are pushing. What will happen when people see the falseness of the claim and/or get tired of National's negativity and want to see something of what they would do?
Also, why no chance for an uninterrupted final speech at the end from each leader?
He was also somewhat economical with the truth when he mentioned Opportunity's land tax proposal; failing to mention their proposed unconditional income proposal, which in most cases would probably swamp the land tax. The two go together.
He has probably found something to change his mind about. A pity he didn't remember it during the debate.
He's a real man of the people his defense of his business boost was the government subsidizing coronet peak to put in snow machines!!!
lol.
The skiing class are big donators no doubt.
Yep – while the business in some dirt poor town that was making decent school lunches for local schools, got replaced by Compass. No desire for more money to be circulating in that poor community, but Luxon is 'proud' about more money going into Queenstown. His threshold for being 'proud' is extremely low – maybe he's 'proud' of putting his underwear on the right way round in the morning?
The emperor has got no clothes on.
It's known in the trade as a 'snow job'- a flurry of words, "an intense, insincere effort to deceive or persuade someone using overwhelming flattery, exaggeration, or a flood of misleading information."
There was a word analysis of the debate. https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics/1775167/luxon-vs-hipkins-leaders-debate-what-once-was-a-crisis-is-now-a-challenge
Worthwhile looking at, by Farah Hancock on RNZ. This topic was most revealing.
"Dodging the hard questions
A common tactic to avoid answering a question is to use what's referred to as a 'block and bridge'. The politician acknowledges the question using a 'block' and then uses a 'bridge' phrase to move the topic to something they are more comfortable with. Common bridging terms are "I would say", "what I can tell you", "the reality is". The bridge allows them to transition the conversation to their own talking points." Luxon used the tactic very often- 15 times to Hipkins once.
Another topic. Luxon won this but proved that saying more is saying less… Luxon used the word 'actually' 68 times.
"Who talked the most
When it came to getting more words in, Luxon won out. He said 6031 discernable words during the debate compared to Hipkins' 4270 words, which trailed even Tame."
That was an analysis of the actual language used. I'd like to see an analysis of the body language as well.
The funny thing is the few time luxon was being genuine and positive he actually came cross as not a angry dick head, hope he doesn't do that to often before the election
Nice spot OBS.
TBH I'm as much annoyed by the format as the politicians. Having these percentages from voters during the debate is just silly (even though it has favoured Hipkins, it's not what a debate should be).
Yes but what is how it should be with these inadequate representatives of the 'People' in power; they were mistaken, thought it would be pow-err. ..oof!
Agreed!
To my way of thinking, Hipkins lost the initiative when he declined to say it was morally acceptable to have the number of billionaires increase 2024 -2025 from 18 to 26!
Never, never acceptable when people are going hungry and sleeping on the streets!
Agreed TV…..but Hipkins was trying to avoid headlines in the morning like " Hipkins hates wealth creation" or "Hipkins hates entrepreneurs".
We are incredibly lucky to have MMP….the Greens' hate billionaires and they are polling 16…..I repeat 16. So FU Luxon.
Yes, I can accept that, but surely there should be a place in our politics for a little honesty? I'm sure the electorate would reward him for that (if he thought that billionaires should pay more in taxes, that is).
Some billionaires are accidently from creating something good, so hating on them is stupid.
Taxing them isn't though
Well, I stuck with it to the end. The media love a "game-changer" but this wasn't. The voters at TVNZ gave it to Hipkins, not sure that means much.
So superficial though. Example: At the end they got onto the Middle East and Tame didn't want anything except yes/no. Not exploring beyond that. Same for most of the topics covered. Poor.
My take after listening to the end:
Luxon did his usual… spewed numbers and statistics and a good few were blatant lies, or at best misrepresentation of a circumstance eg. actions taken during the pandemic. When Hipkins tried to correct them he was shut down and it was portrayed by the so-called experts afterwards as two larrikins having a schoolboy verbal fight (my words). There was no recognition that one leader was lying and the other trying to establish the facts.
Btw, who was the woman commentator among the experts. I had the impression she was supposed to be the token Maori. If so, she was about as pro Maori as David Seymour.
I switched off once we got to the woeful panel, I don't need a killer punch or pazzaz, chippie went well, luxon just looks ugly when he's grumpy or doing the prepared attacks,
I thought Tame was very good and the event was telling. No theatrics, but Luxon's intransigence was clear and Hipkin's calling-out of so many of the Government's wrong-doings was all that was needed.
Personally I thought Tame was awful. He talked over them both and insisted on trying to get a ‘gotcha’ moment.
Missing John Campbell IMHO.
I would be interested to hear Ginny Andersen's response to Erica Stanford's phone call accusation. It sounds as though Stanford didn't make much of an effort to contact her. If I didn't get an answer the first time I would keep on phoning, or made contact in some other way.
I thought it was a call to Willow Jean Prime….
But yes you are correct. In order to reflect a bipartisan approach you (as a minimum) send details of education proposals to the shadow education minister and to the leaders of all political parties then mutually arrange a discussion process.
"She didn't answer the phone so I assumed Labour and all the other parties weren't interested" is complete bollocks.