Open Mike 21/10/2026

79 comments on “Open Mike 21/10/2026”

Comment numbers have changed to permanent references. Older quoted numbers may no longer identify the same comment.

  1. 1

    The One News/Verian poll results from last night.

    Lab 27.0 Gre 16.0 TPM 0.7 =43.7 (seats 56)

    Nat 32.0 ACT 11.0 NZF 8.0 =51.0 (seats 60)

    Opp 7.0 (seats 8)

    Not very good news for the Left. I may be clutching at straws but the Nats polling recently (see Wiki) has been 25.9 29 28.5 28 28 27.6. On the same day as Freshwater had National on 27.6 Verian had them at 32.This has rogue written all over it.

    In any event, when the TPM/TTT overhang is taken into account (see link) Opp is in the driving seat where it can choose a Left government 64-60 or a Right government 68-56. Both would be viable.

  2. 2

    Bolsonaro Jnr in Brazil's election has made a huge PR own-goal:

    'the far-right politician’s decision to attend a primetime television debate against his leftwing opponent, Lula da Silva, with the word “corrupto” [with a square around PT, the initials of Lula's party] handwritten on the palm of his hand has backfired… viewers sarcastically took Bolsonaro’s message as an admission of his own guilt.'

    And created a meme: 'Lula supporters… flooded social media with photographs of their own self-descriptions inked on their palms.'

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/oct/20/flavio-bolsonaro-corrupto-viral-meme-brazil-election-runoff

  3. 3

    riotgrrrl on reddit/nzpolitics this morning on OP's policy board, beginning with their policy-decision structure:

    ' 12.1 policy committee mandate
    The Policy Committee has sole responsibility for developing the Party’s policies. The board, other officers, and members of the Party are expressly prohibited from interfering with the development of policy by the Policy Committee.

    'No grassroots then' says riotgrrrl. And then their info on committee members:

    'Q has said publicly that in addition to her, Jessica Hammond [Opportunity's Wellington North candidate (and mikesh's crush)] is also a member of the policy committee. The other two members aren't named publicly due to their professional commitments'

    Choke. Is Wong's mum one, then? The trisky wording of their Palestine genocide position, for example, suggests a high-power legal wordsmith. “Senior National Party members can neither confirm nor deny they wrote OP’s 2026 policy”?

    1. 3.2

      They changed the policy boards power in the party's constitution, please keep up caucus will have ultimate power not the party board. I'm not voting for them but I will defend them because they are not the lefts enemy, at best they work with us, at worst they blunt the beneficiary bashing anti climate anti Maori viciousness of the incumbent govt

      It's life or death for many of us, a weak national with an empowered act and NZf will be far more brutal than this term

      Anything that helps rid us of this govt or handbrakes them is not my enemy, I will not vote for them

      I see a lot of middle class comfortable Lefty's quite happy to sabotage top even if it means causing immense harm to poor, disabled, sick, vulnerable special needs, Maori, immigrants, LGBT or unemployed people

      Some of us don't have the luxury of left wing tribalism. I'll attack labour for being weak but I'd rather them any day of the weak and if top helps is get there or helps block the extreme policies of nact/NZf/act, good.

      1. 3.2.2

        I posted information from today's Reddit, and if it's incorrect about current policy-setting, then thanks for the update. If you have been reading my comments, then you'll know OP-acity of decision-making is my key issue with OP as a new (electoral-power-wise) party.

        Have those two people on the policy committee been named since then? The only NZ political parties I've known to date with secret memberships in leadership positions are old-school communist.

        1. 3.2.2.1

          And not only opacity, but as with all parties believability in commitment to the people not the baubles and strutting and hairdos and… They all make promises. One should ask seeing how we are told business style is better than government – can we sue the business-government when things are not carried out as promised.

          I think we have lost our say over government, and govt has given away its power to business and money interested avatars. What have we now then Hollow Men and Women. I remember a sturdy determined accountant I think, bravely taking on the govt some years back. Should have become a national (small n) hero.

          I want rights as citizens to choose our own CEO, and pick out one governing body that has to follow rules for good governance. And annual depreciation of our exchange rate etc. Mad aren't I, but then so are all others who continue with out present farce.

      2. 3.2.3

        They changed the policy boards power in the party's constitution, please keep up caucus will have ultimate power not the party board.

        I think you are wrong and making things more confusing.

        12.1 policy committee mandate

        The Policy Committee has sole responsibility for developing the Party’s policies. The board, other officers, and members of the Party are expressly prohibited from interfering with the development of policy by the Policy Committee.

        To my knowledge this has not been changed. If you have evidence to the contrary, put it up w link(s).

        I think that you’re confusing this with another one of TOP’s issues.

        The Opportunity Party is scrapping its policy that would give its board veto power over caucus decisions, following queries from The Post.

        Its constitution gives its board the unusual ability to “overrule” caucus decisions by a 75% majority vote – something several legal experts have confirmed is unusual and out of step with other parties.

        It’s also not been clear the mechanism is even legally enforceable: democratically elected MPs are free to vote how they like, though it is often down party lines so as not to risk their political prospects.

        Following queries from The Post, the Opportunity Party’s general manager Iain Lees-Galloway said the party would scrap the board veto power.

        "In response to valid concerns raised about Rule 11.4 of the Opportunity party constitution, the party board has called a special general meeting for members to consider proposed amendments.

        https://www.thepost.co.nz/politics/361065503/opportunity-scrapping-boards-veto-power-over-caucus [paywall]

        As you can see, these are different sections of TOP’s Constitution relating to entirely different issues, one of which has been fixed now, apparently, and the other still is in place, AFAIK.

        1. 3.2.3.1

          So, if caucus enacts a policy which the the policy committee doesn't like, they can be reprimanded for breach of the constitution, but it can't stop them.

            1. 3.2.3.1.1.1

              Be interesting to see what the outcome would be. If you mutiny, are you fired from a list mp position and next one takes your place? Or, once sworn in, are you effectively an employee of Parliament and hustling you out is more complicated? Can't jump the waka. I haven't paid enough attention to NZ politics to think of an example.

              “Bring out the whip!”

    2. 3.3

      Jessica Hammond [Opportunity's Wellington North candidate (and mikesh's crush)]

      I recommended her to the Wellington North electorate, but I have never actually met the lady, though have heard her speak at public meetings. I think you owe me an apology for insinuating that there exists some sexual attraction.

      1. 3.3.1

        I don't know, mikesh, voting for her three times sounds like an emotional attachment to me. I looked up 'crush' to check, and its definition is 'romantic' attachment, not sexual necessily.

        I aplogise if my wording somehow implied that you lust after Jessica. I see romantic here with a Capital R, by the way, with windswept moors, and uplifting spiritual feelings.

        As I wrote yesterday, of all your posts, the one about your voting preferences was the one that intrigued me, and I went hunting for information about her political history. She seems a good sort, and I can fully understand your voting preference.

    3. 3.4

      "Senior National Party members can neither confirm nor deny they wrote OP’s 2026 policy"

      Where does your quote come from? I can't see it in the source you linked.

        1. 3.4.1.1

          Did Wong's mum help her with her homework? And doesn't want the ladies she lunches with to find out, in case they drop her from their dinner party circuit? Or is it big-name business people who would lose lucrative government contracts in the pipeline?

          Of course this is scurrilous speculation on my part, but perfectly justifiable, given Wong herself gave ‘reputation damage’ as the reason.

  4. 4

    Re: last night's leaders debate.

    Lyin' Luxon wins again – 24 lies to Hipkin's 2.5.

    According to Paul … the other one.

    1. 4.1

      NB: one thing that Luxon did say that was correct – when replying to Hipkins saying the Mongrel Mob drug programme was begun by Key:

      "I'm not John Key!"

      Now, ain't that the truth!

  5. 5

    "With the Greens offering at least a tacit endorsement to the Mongrel Mob at a recent absolutely-not-a-campaign-event event, Labour leader Chris Hipkins has been feeling increasingly threatened, and in a bid to defend his ever-shrinking territory, has turned to perhaps the Mongrel Mob’s oldest rival, Grey Power."

    Cheer up, everybody! This from The Civilian will make you laugh !

    https://thecivilian.co.nz/2026/10/20/tensions-flare-as-labour-seeks-to-win-back-green-votes-by-backing-rival-gang/

    1. 5.1

      Luxon's criticism of the Greens for talking to the Mongrel Mob was unwarranted. As far as I know its members are entitled to vote so there is no reason why a politician, during an election campaign, should not go and speak to them. Hipkins should have acknowleged that instead of launching an implied criticism himself . After all Labour and the Greens are purportedly on the same side.

      1. 5.1.1

        Labour are NOT on the Greens side. They're fighting a vote war on two fronts, OP for swinging centrist votes, while the Greens chew up their left flank, and it's making Hipkins cranky.

      2. 5.1.2

        You are not in your own there. Harry Tam is critical of Hipkins response and points to political expediency. That's what is needed when the principle cupboard is a little empty. Bearing mind he was a senior minister when the meth cessation funding was approved.

        Yes I know it's a Newstalk ZB link but it is quoting Tam's appearance on BHN.

        He uses the Foreshore and Seabed Bill and Closing the Gaps as examples of being hard to trust Labour

        https://www.newstalkzb.co.nz/news/politics/mongrel-mob-s-harry-tam-accuses-hipkins-of-throwing-jacinda-ardern-under-the-bus-over-gang-funding/

        1. 5.1.2.1

          Harry Tam might be voting for the Coalition – very clever ‘strategic voting’ but shite political strategy.

          And yes, I'm a left winger myself, but you know, I rather have the opposition in front of me. At least I know what I'm fighting. But friends like Hipkins I don't need.

          https://youtu.be/bZBPqRLnb6I?si=MfnQya6Ie91R1rri&t=936 [BHN on YT; starts @ 15:36]

          Hipkins wasn’t even in Parliament when the Foreshore & Seabed Bill was enacted nor during the implementation of the Closing the Gaps policy. Still, there are still people around who still don’t trust Labour because of Roger Douglas and 1984. In contrast, Luxon’s memory doesn’t go back further than 2020.

        2. 5.1.2.2

          A mobster saying others are hard to trust, Tam when you're an ex mobster then I'll take you seriously .

          I’d love to know how much government money he was paying himself and his allies

      3. 5.1.3

        Was more than implied. Hipkins went fully nuclear, such a dumb thing to do. He could've got away with criticising the promotion of the meeting, but he should've defended engagement with all members of society. It could've been a great platform to get some of these basic ideas across to the average voter. Instead he let his comments at best give the impression the left are all over the place, and at worst that Labour is just as nasty and uncaring as the nactoids. Harry Tam's spot on with his description of Hipkins' behaviour:

        https://www.stuff.co.nz/politics/361048817/nz-election-2026-live-updates-politics-campaign-news

        1. 5.1.3.1

          Read ad's comment, where they point out Tan's framing is a decade or two out of date. The gangs are bigger now, wirh imported 501 ideas, well-enmeshed in the international drug trade, and heavily invested in P, an addictive drug that does no community good.

          Hipkins needed to be more expansive in his takedown. "I was in government when police Operations Cobalt and Nickel took out took out top-tier drug importers. As Health Minister I know very well the social harm that results from P sales (which are up 300% in the past three years under 'tough on crime' Luxon). I acknowledge the damage to young Māori in borstals that led to them setting up gangs in the 70s. But the drug trade is very different from then, and the Greens need to understand that". Schooled. All round.

          I personally thought in 2023 that the drug-trade top tier were so pissed off over the ringleader busts, as well as covid shutdowns throttling their trade, that they coordinated ramraid campaigns at street level to make Labour look bad. They certainly weren’t done for profit.

  6. 6

    They can’t manage the economy and they can’t manage Health NZ, among too many other things that they can’t manage or choose to mis-manage for whatever reason that’s on their agenda.

    Indeed, this Government’s first health action wasn’t to recruit more nurses – it was to place a hiring freeze on Health NZ that unions say also impacted frontline staff. Somewhat ironically, Health NZ chief executive Margie Apa revealed to Newsroom in July 2024 that the agency had taken on too many international and graduate nurses in 2023/24, leading to its well-documented $1 billion budget blowout.

    https://newsroom.co.nz/2026/10/21/overkill-or-killer-blow-newsrooms-takeaways-from-the-last-leaders-debate/

    PS the correct answer is 54.

    1. 6.1

      The $1b blowout is a manufactured crises by levy and crew removing 20% capacity from the hospital system i.e pulling the rug out from under it.

      Hey presto they're all over budget suddenly with a convenient backstory to go with it.

      They did the same shit with ACC in 2008 making mischief over its forward funding that took a GFC hit.

      They get back in and health is goneburger baby as Simeons undermining of it will gather pace.

      1. 6.1.1

        Add tens of millions to private hospitals 'to bring down the backlog', which would have been more effective directly invested into the public health system.

      2. 6.1.2

        "The $1b blowout is a manufactured crises…"

        It would show the budget was the thing that was incorrect, that needed revisiting.

        A bit like whenever you read worker shortage what they mean is a wage shortage.

  7. 8

    It starts from the top…always. Greed. But just disgusting when people were hurting for somewhere to live : (

    Former Kāinga Ora official among four charged over $4m in alleged bribes

    The construction company owners allegedly bribed the former Kāinga Ora official with more than $2.6 million through 46 payments into five different bank accounts, and more than $507,000 in credits for the construction of a family home.

    An additional $1 million in bribes was allegedly allocated to the former TRC official; however, the former Kāinga Ora official allegedly retained more than $900,000 in payments, with the TRC official allegedly receiving $171,250 in payments and gifts.

    "This case involves contracts worth millions of dollars to provide new homes in Auckland neighbourhoods, for the benefit of our communities. The people overseeing these projects are expected to act with integrity," SFO Director Karen Chang said.

    https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/regions_auckland/2049804/former-kainga-ora-official-among-four-charged-over-4m-in-alleged-bribes

  8. 9

    Re Stuff's leaders' debate last night, according to the final numbers on-screen approximately 20,000 online viewers voted. Chris Hipkins scored 57% of the vote and Christopher Luxon 43%. Yet from AI:

    "While the snap online viewer poll favored the Labour leader, professional political commentators and media panels considered the overall debate to be much tighter, with several highlighting strong, combative moments from both candidates".

    Why do these commentators claim the debate was much closer? Surely the viewers'/voters' opinions are the most relevant?

      1. 9.1.1

        Ir wasn't a battle of ideas, it was just about which of the Chris's could tell the truth.

        Chris Hipkins won hands-down.

        Christopher Luxon floundered like a flatfish.

    1. 9.2

      Simple. 'Professional' commentators are paid by someone or some party supporter to write their guff. The UK media is infested with these parasites, and they directly influence public opinion by drowning out alternative views.

      1. 9.2.1

        No different here. Look at the opinionators on offer….penk, grant, hosking etc.

        Plus numerous pieces where a coalition minister faces no scrutiny, press releases are re-published rather than analysed and questioned.

        Winston claimed theres gas to be discovered where decades of exploration yielded none. Zero questions asked as one example……pity as he's quick to an unhinged rant when put on the spot and that was a biggie imo.

        1. 9.2.1.1

          I must admit, it's baffling why Hipkins strength in debates and dominance in preference as a leader, is not showing through in polls. Baffling. Could anyone unbaffle me.

          1. 9.2.1.1.1

            IMO, it's the drag effect from his association with the Covid restrictions.

            He was a senior member of the government, which implemented the lockdowns, and vaccine mandates. And had direct responsibility for many of the policies and their implementation. He is inextricably associated with Covid in many people's minds.

            Before the yelping chorus comes at me.

            Yes. I know why they were done. Yes, I understand that *if you are already on board with these decisions*, this is not an issue.

            But the political reality is that many people disagreed with the lockdowns. Many people disagreed with the vaccine mandates. Many people were badly (very badly) affected by both. And they are not ready to forgive and forget.

            By keeping Hipkins on, from the Ardern years – Labour have opened themselves up to the risk of his unpopularity.

            I have literally heard people say that every time Hipkins appears or speaks, they think of X impact from lockdown or Covid.

            Is it 'fair'? Well, when has politics ever been fair…..

            Is it too late to do anything about it. Yes, of course.

              1. 9.2.1.1.1.1.1

                So do you have an explanation for why Hipkins and Labour aren't further ahead in the polls?

                Or is your theory that there's nothing to see here– She'll be right, mate.

                Rating better as a leader than Luxon is hardly a high bar to clear. And both are around 20% as preferred PM.

                The minor parties are neither here nor there. (Or we'd be discussing why Hipkins polls higher than Swarbrick who runs rings around him as a leader).

                1. 9.2.1.1.1.1.1.1

                  Labour and Hipkins have been subject to a prolonged and unrelenting smear campaign since the last election, with National, ACT and NZFirst combining with their media puppets, to erode public trust by foul means and foul. That's the reason why Labour and Hipkins aren't shining as brightly as they ought to. That's the strategy adopted by the Right and its mechanics and it has clearly worked, as they were promised.

            1. 9.2.1.1.1.2

              Labour got a massive vote in 2020, so I don't think that's it. Yes, there are plenty of people around still fucked off about the lockdowns and mandates. Businesses negatively affected too. But at the 2023 election the issues were more co-governance and three waters. My guess is that it's a combination of all of that, plus Hipkins being rather ordinary.

              I don't mind ordinary and suspect in years to come we will appreciate it more.

              1. 9.2.1.1.1.2.1

                The election 2020 was before the extended lockdowns (especially in Auckland) and the vaccine mandates.

                I disagree that Covid didn't matter by 2023.

                I agree that Hipkins is ordinary – and he's never really mastered popular appeal. Which would be a lot more problematic if he were up against anyone other than Luxon.

                    1. 9.2.1.1.1.2.1.1.1.2

                      Paul the other one – check the link above – logged 24 lies uttered by Luxon, compared to 2 and a half one by Chippy.

                      So Luxon lied 10 times more than Hipkins. I know which one I'd rather trust!

                  1. 9.2.1.1.1.2.1.1.2

                    Also. I've yet to be convinced that TV debates matter at all.

                    Apart from political tragics – who watches? And, if they do, is their opinion changed?

                    1. 9.2.1.1.1.2.1.1.3.1

                      She's a real handful and for the moment, he has to appear seperate from her and The Greens. This will change when they both work together to form the new Government.

              2. 9.2.1.1.1.2.2

                I agree although I think the whole preferred PM is a red herring, so FWIW, Hipkins rated reasonably well when he became PM in 2023 with a slight downward trend towards GE-2023.

                https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polling_for_the_2023_New_Zealand_general_election#Preferred_prime_minister

                As Leader of the Opposition, the ‘worst job in politics’, he held quite steady, with possibly even a slight trend upwards.

                https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polling_for_the_2026_New_Zealand_general_election#Preferred_prime_minister

                The effect of a Covid hangover would be higher early on and peter out over time, one would think.

    2. 9.3

      I wouldn't red anything in to the stuff vote , I did it cause I was bored while watching grown men squabble.

      Ever category was just about exactly 57%ish to 43% , which I bet corolates exactly the the lean of the viewers that could be bothered voting, about 2000 per question

      1. 9.3.1

        Hipkins only "squabbled" when Luxon's bullshitting finally irritated him beyond what his patience could handle. Until then, Hipkins turned Luxon's lies neatly against him, making several significant corrections and even squeezing some humour out of the situation. Luxon though, banged on and on and on. That sort of blunt, bald dishonesty wears an opponent down and creates the squabble effect you describe. I blame Luxon entirely.

  9. 11

    This will be a task for next term with people finally coming to terms what commercial billing for water from water entities looks like:

    Thousands call for review of Selwyn's water pricing

    So, who other than the Commerce Commission regulates the price of water, from a regional monopoly?

    What if any residual power does the public council owners have to hold the entity to account for this pricing?

    Even if a protest burnt the entire Council down, what if any effect would that have on a bill?

    This is what power bills began with under Max Bradford's power reofrms.

  10. 13

    On being an unusual politician in Australia. I thought this person's progress might give us some hints. https://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/HL2610/S00052/attempted-assassinations-the-attack-on-helen-haines.htm Wednesday, 21 October 2026, 2:09 pm
    Opinion: Binoy Kampmark

    It is not a good time to be a politician. Prices are rising with extortionate speed. Foolish wars continue being waged. The banksters are in clover. Corporate oligarchies are humming along. The thieves in artificial intelligence are gloating about an end of civilisation they are happy to exploit for commercial reasons. But even in these situations there are certain figures who have distinguished themselves with quiet tenacity. They should be bottled and perfumed for posterity.

    Helen Haines, the federal Member for the rural Victorian seat of Indi, baffled psephologists with her electoral victory in 2019, becoming the first independent to succeed another in the country’s history. The previous member, Cathy McGowan, had pioneered a form of grassroots political engagement that stressed the importance of representation and service over the hulking monster of party politics and vulgar self-interest….

    1. 13.1

      Given what has just happened to her, I'm not sure exactly what you mean by "I thought this person's progress might give us some hints."

    2. 13.2

      This was not a political hit by a random. Her attacker was the son of family friends, and and he was taken into mental health care on his arrest. It's dishonest of Australian politicians and media to frame it as political violence.

  11. 14

    Don't know if anyone has put this up from Martyn at TDB. But well worth a read. Mikesh and Corey may have enough points in their analysis that echo Martyn's and need consideration. It is this election that is especially important so think NOW and deal with other things later. There will be great problems from now on so why get stuck on just one for the future, deal with now. Is that the way to go?

    https://thedailyblog.co.nz/new-poll-why-doesnt-nz-left-understand-they-can-only-win-if-top-gets-over-5/

    As I have been pointing out since fucking January – the only way you get to 51% is with 4 parties.

    Let me spell this out to my dear fellow Comrades of the Left.

    IF. TOP. DON’T. GET. OVER. 5%. THERE. IS. NO. PATH. TO. VICTORY. FOR. LABOUR + GREENS + TPM.

    Look. I’m about the MMP Math.

    And the MMP Math be saying 4 parties to get to 51%. If the Judea Front Splitters have their way, they will sink TOP and we lose to a far worse right wing Government.

    REMEMBER Luxon couldn’t control Winston and Seymour when they were 6% and 8%, how will he deal with them in double digits with half his Cabinet amputated because of the Overhang?…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *