Gangs are bad. Crime is not?

It’s only a few days before enrollment for voting closes in Aotearoa New Zealand, and it appears corporate media and the right have found their “Ram Raid” moment.

When the media set upon Labour in mid 2023 for “out of control” raids, ram raids had already been coming down for well over a year, and reached their lowest point in September 2023, just a month before the 2023 election.

Ram raids peaked in August 2022 after a social media trend exacerbated the activity among youths. Remedial policies saw a clear downward trend from then.

Most Kiwis would have seen the news headlines about “out of control” ram raids, but they probably didn’t hear about their low point in September – and how it was already coming down well before that.

That’s because corporate media didn’t promote the latter, but certainly spent a lot of attention on the former.

The moment now looks to be “gang photos”.

Apparently, one campaign stop by Te Pati Maori was a bridge too far for New Zealand. In this country, gangs rose up from Abuse in State Care; i.e. after having suffered violent physical and sexual abuse, gangs formed from within. Luxon is well aware of this, because he launched the findings of the Royal Commission into Abuse at State Care, and was informed at length of the origination stories.

This isn’t to excuse gangs, or any of their crimes and conduct, but to reflect on their part in a society frequently betrodden by poverty and grievance.

Reaching out to find pockets of rehabilitation and connection shouldn’t be a crime.

But it is the inconsistency among Kiwis that is the question mark here.

Remember when Luxon’s Chief Policy Advisor and ex-Atlas Network partner, NZ Initiative staffer , Matt Burgess, asked Fonterra and Z Energy to use private emails to avoid public awareness?

And then copied and pasted Z and Fonterra’s law requests into law as National Party policy?

That’s criminal, but apparently it doesn’t matter if you’re not brown or poor or not in the halls of power. I say the former sentence partly facetiously, but also out of bewilderment at what we choose to be shocked at.

Let’s also take a moment to remember how David Seymour shielded a pedophile in his midst, tried to redirect victims away from police and to his party lawyer, and gave Tim Jago the power to determine whether there had been sexual assaults committed within his own Party. And ACT affiliated parties then allowed Jago to conceal his identity for years.

Then there was Seymou leaning on Auckland police to go easy on his constituent Philip Polkinghorne, despite Polkinghorne being the sole suspect in his wife’s death, and it being a live, ongoing investigation.

When is association and crime bad?

And when is it not?

7 comments on “Gangs are bad. Crime is not?”

Comment numbers have changed to permanent references. Older quoted numbers may no longer identify the same comment.

  1. 2

    It only became a thing because Chris Hipkins was foolish enough to take the bait and paint himself into corner with his subsequent comments, which no doubt contributed Oriini Kaipara outing Kerrin Leoni during that debate.

    If Chris Hipkins had been more careful in his initial comments none of this shit would have happened and it would have died a pretty quick death in the media.

    1. 2.2

      If Hipkins hadn't said what he said, it would have dogged Labour for the rest of the campaign, including today.

      Leoni handled it badly, should have told Hipkins about the campaigning when the original issue broke a few weeks ago.

      Hipkins did well in the media today.

      Hipkins said Leoni had not given the party the "full information" about the gathering and had not managed the conflict appropriately.

      But he said he bore her no "ill will" for the mistake and became emotional while expressing his frustration at the "unfortunate" circumstance.

      "All of us navigate family situations in politics, and it's bloody hard," he said.

      "In her case, she should be really proud of what she has been able to achieve. She has grown up in an environment where she's been surrounded by gang members. She is not a gang member herself. She has made a good life for herself.

      "She has made a mistake here, and she has paid a high price."

      Hipkins said he also believed there was an element of "racism" to the reaction and chided National for "crowing" and "salivating" over the candidate's mistake.

      "Our Māori MPs get held to a very different standard to others."

      https://www.odt.co.nz/news/national/labour-candidate-filmed-talking-with-gang-members-says-it-was-a-whanau-function-rqtvbu5b

  2. 3

    Reaching out to find pockets of rehabilitation and connection shouldn’t be a crime.

    Are you disagreeing with Chris Hipkins that campaigning with gang members is an extremely serious issue?

  3. 5

    Also the National MP Same Uffindel that beat up a fellow teen in his younger years, but all was forgiven. Hipkins is right, Māori are held to a different standard.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *