Open Mike 11/05/2026

30 comments on “Open Mike 11/05/2026”

Comment numbers have changed to permanent references. Older quoted numbers may no longer identify the same comment.

    1. 1.1

      He has a marketing problem. Whichever ad agency they used oughta get ditched pronto. Bland usually works for Labour, but this here sociological analysis shows where it has failed: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2026/may/10/surge-support-greens-reform-across-england-five-key-takeaways

      As regards the viability of a charisma transplant, I suggest lateral-thinking. Delegate that. Not to Gordon Brown! Someone young & vibrant. Trump is using a classic blonde & she hasn't screwed up yet, so the model does work.

  1. 2

    Do we need to talk about TOP?

    Verity Johnson: Has the Opportunity party gone from Zombie to Lazarus?

    https://www.stuff.co.nz/politics/360976086/verity-johnson-has-opportunity-party-gone-zombie-lazarus

    "There was dim lighting, a hip warehouse space, a DJ in an ironic knitted tank top, fresh raspberries on a snack platter, and, ah, a whiteboard. And powerpoint. For policy ideas. Whilst dancing. It was weird but it worked. Like seeing a Fiat 500 with a towbar and trailer."

    1. 2.1

      Only if Lucy Lawless sees an opportunity. She may still have her battle-dress in the closet. Showing up in the tv headline news sitting next to Russell Norman was a power play that led to nothing – obviously got a whiff of leftist herding that seemed toxic.

      Clearly a woman of subtlety, not just talent, since she has kept quiet about it since. As regards any zeitgeist for TOP, depends on how much collective brain death is exhibited by the other parties as we all drift into proximal voting headspace.

    2. 2.2

      I love the way Verity has a clearly feminine voice to her writing with constant analogues between relationship management and political management.

      Always a fun columnist to read, always sufficiently impatient with the status quo.

    3. 2.3

      I'm thinking now that TOP are Peter Dunne for the hipster crowd 😆

      yes we do need talk about them

      That article is such a good read. In amongst the highly entertaining framing, there are things we should be pay attention to.

      But. Here’s the rub. Opportunity didn’t actively court these new suitors. It didn’t ply them with chocolates and cryptocurrency and pull them in. These new beaus showed up on their own accord, pissed off by what else was on offer. They’re standing there, waiting to be wooed.

      Maybe there aren't enough of them the worry Labour in chasing. But if they're enough to get TOP into parliament, that's a game changer.

  2. 3

    Orwellian language use in the NZ Herald:

    "Current average support for the three coalition parties is 50.2% compared to 44.9% for the opposition, a gap of 5.3 points, the research found."

    (my italics)

    Doing a poll of polls works OK if it's the UK or USA and there are plenty of polls even in one week, but it's nonsense in NZ, except perhaps in the last few days of an election campaign when they proliferate.

    Prime Minister Chris Luxon pans NZ First, Labour for ‘dishonest’ stance on raising age for NZ Super – NZ Herald

    1. 3.1

      There was a recent rogue Curia poll contained in those results.

      In any event a 5-point gap with 6 months to go is far from definitive.

    1. 4.3

      Like almost every other report on the topic, the RNZ story (in link) misses the point.

      If National want to scrap it, they should campaign on doing that. Make the case. That's what elections are for.

      So much political commentary is on that basis: "We know they never told the voters they'd do this, but hey, never mind, is it a good idea anyway?".

      They lied. That is the story. Where is it?

      Election 2023: National would keep fees-free policy, wouldn't means-test, despite reckons from candidate | Stuff

  3. 6

    Ok..more anecdata. And I am sure L Prent dealt with this with a comment, quite categorically…last time.

    [TheStandard: A moderator moved this comment to Open Mike as being off topic or irrelevant in the post it was made in. Be more careful in future.]

  4. 7

    As I replied to Karoline _IS…..L Prent quite categorically dealt with this by comment ..last time….

    [TheStandard: A moderator moved this comment to Open Mike as being off topic or irrelevant in the post it was made in. Be more careful in future.]

    1. 7.1

      That sounds like anecdata.

      Seriously though, the difference between Karolyn and my comments and yours is that we made political points. You appear to be acting like a partisan hack, or perhaps a troll. I don’t even really know what your point is. People use personal memory of events on TS all the time. If you have a problem with that, please state it clearly.

      You are under no obligation to believe me, or Karolyn, or anyone. But I note that you ignored my comment about how liberals act.

      1. 7.1.1

        I wonder who moved..my comment? And I certainly would link L Prents comment…but past comments cant be accessed….

        Ani O'Brien is a far right hate troll. Proven.

    2. 7.2

      Well, the nearest I can come to evidence is this 2019 blog post by Ani, on Medium, in which she outlines some of the verbal harassment she had been receiving on twitter, supported by a green MP.

      I never followed closely, on or offline, what Ani was doing, back then, but there were some things I saw on twitter. I'm certainly not a supporter of the hit jobs she's now into.

    1. 8.1

      Imagine the damage they would cause if they ever got in to power. Too busy fighting amongst themselves.

      1. 8.1.1

        Sounds like you are describing the Nat/ACT/NZF horror show, Jimmy!

        Imagine if they got into power!

        Damage x 1000!

    2. 8.2

      This is excellent news.

      Kapa-Kingi will disappear into irrelevance, taking sod-all votes with her.

  5. 9

    Calling many Maori voters dissafected and dumb is not very nice Ad and as for Jimmys comments pure scaremongering

    1. 9.1

      Harden up cupcake. TPM have been falling apart for a year in public, and are now officially at war in the election. You go waste your vote if you want to.

      1. 9.1.1

        You go waste your vote if you want to.

        Ta smiley Imho, a TOP vote is more likely to be wasted than a TPM vote – time will tell.

        Of course, there's little political risk to the left in invective flung at TPM;
        TPM MPs aren't going to align themselves with demonstrably anti-Māori CoC parties.

        Still, you have to wonder why ostensibly lefty commentors would waste invective on TPM, when there are much more deserving targets.

        Rewriting a violent settler-colonial history: why anti-Māori racism must be distinguished from other forms of racism in Aotearoa New Zealand
        [15 July 2025]
        In April 2024, the National Iwi Chairs Forum walked away from NAPAR [National Action Plan Against Racism]. Their departure occurred after the newly entered right-wing government Justice Minister, Paul Goldsmith “signaled to the tangata whenua caucus (Indigenous) … that he wanted to reduce the focus on colonial racism and institutional racism, this was merely the last straw in a very concerning time for race relations in Aotearoa”.

        Govt’s extreme anti-Māori agenda ramps up with another 27 roles proposed to go at Te Puni Kōkiri [10 April 2026]

        From taonga to target: the assault on te reo Māori
        [careful now RNZ, 20 August 2025]

  6. 10

    https://www.rnz.co.nz/national/programmes/mediawatch/audio/2018936865/critics-foam-over-frothy-poll-coverage

    Maiki Sherman's coverage of polling has angered the political right for two years now.

    If you want to hold moderator power to ban commenters here perhaps you might like to keep up with the political climate?

    [TheStandard: A moderator moved this comment to Open Mike as being off topic or irrelevant in the post it was made in. Be more careful in future.]

    [I’ve run out of patience with your incessant bullshit over moderation and I see absolutely no reason why we should put up with this disrespect. Last warning. Expect a long ban next time. 2 weeks this time. – weka]

Comments are closed.