Open Mike 20/09/2026

44 comments on “Open Mike 20/09/2026”

Comment numbers have changed to permanent references. Older quoted numbers may no longer identify the same comment.

  1. 1

    Its the Last day to Vote '26…

    Voting is now open!

    It's time to pick your party and back your bird.
    Let's give nature a clear majority in 2026!

    https://www.birdoftheyear.org.nz/

    in the Forest and Bird Bird of the year. A very cool site…you can read all about the Candidates (and hear their song : )

    Please support our Feathered Friend Candidates..and their Friends

    : )

  2. 2


    Sharon Murdoch, in The Post (Sunday Star-Times), 20 Sept 2026

    Comrade Luxon? I'll believe it when I see it. Paraphrasing R. G. Collingwood:

    The only clue to what the nACT1 CoC would do is what the nACTf CoC has done.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_acts_of_the_54th_New_Zealand_Parliament

    David Seymour says 5 National MPs complained to him about their own supermarket policy [Stuff, 18 Sept 2026]
    ACT leader David Seymour says some National Party MPs are confiding in him about how they despise their party’s own policy to break up Foodstuffs.

    [comment]
    Imagine believing that National are going to do something, anything, about supermarkets or price gouging. Watch them totally walk this back if they were to get re-elected, most likely blaming coalition negotiations as to why they couldn't get it done.

    1. 2.1

      Pure theatre. They’ve had 3 years, plenty of prior reports and analysis plus anecdotal evidence of price gouging. They get back in this will all go away IMO.

      OZ’s ACCC spent over a year on their duopoly and basically concluded they’re way too powerful. No shit Sherlock, they only have 65% there but at least Labour is following their lead with a grocery czar type role here as a start.

      Adding in the greens new no frills player to that and now we’re talking.

      The anti competitive behaviour from both leave little choice IMHO.

    2. 2.2

      Isn't Murdoch riffing on Muldoon's anti SuperFund cartoon, with dancing Cossacks representing Labour? Although does that make Chloe Sir Rob?

      1. 2.2.1

        Although does that make Chloe Sir Rob?

        Could do, although it seems to me that Chlöe is voicing her approval of comrade Luxon's theatrical [see tc @2.1] (super)market interventation policy.

        One interpretation would be that the Nats have been tacking frantically towards the political centre as the election looms – Nat campaign chair Simeon must be hoping that voters will forget all the regressive wrecking the nACTf CoC has done to date.

        2023
        Urgent legislation repealing the dual mandate (inflation and employment) of the RBNZ

        Repealed the Fair Pay Agreements Act

        Repealed the Clean Car Discount programme.

        Repealed the Natural and Built Environment Act 2023 and the Spatial Planning Act 2023.

        Reinstated 90-day work trials.

        2024
        Disestablished the New Zealand Productivity Commission.

        Repealed the previous Labour Govt's Three Waters reform programme.

        Disestablished the Māori Health Authority [just because]

        Smokefree Environments and Regulated Products Amendment Act

        Land Transport (Clean Vehicle Standard) Amendment Act

        Reinstating the poll requirement for Māori wards and constituencies

        Reinstating Charter schools in New Zealand

        Climate Change Response (Emissions Trading Scheme Agricultural Obligations) Amendment Act

        Repeal the Therapeutic Products Act 2023, which would have increased regulations over therapeutic and medical products.

        Reinstating the three strikes law in New Zealand.

        Smokefree Environments and Regulated Products Amendment Bill (No 2) [the 'poor' old tobacco companies are "on their knees"!]

        Fast-track Approvals Act 2024 – Establishes a new fast-track consenting regime for various resource extraction and building projects.

        2025
        Equal Pay Amendment Act. Urgent legislation raising the threshold for making pay equity claims. As a result, 33 claims representing thousands of workers have to be dropped and refiled.

        Raising the threshold for Māori foreshore and seabed claims.

        Regulatory Standards ACT
        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_Standards_Act_2025#Political_parties

        Removing the statutory requirement for school boards to implement the Treaty of Waitangi.

        Land Transport (Clean Vehicle Standard) Amendment Act. Urgent legislation lowering the emission standards for "clean cars."

        Climate Change Response (2050 Target and Other Matters) Amendment Act

        Delays the phasing out of farrowing crates by ten years.
        ["It's a case of slower to go faster." – Luxon]

        Electoral Amendment Act. Reduces the timeframe for voter registration to two weeks before election day, bans prisoners from voting, and allows larger anonymous political donations.

        2026
        Employment Relations Amendment Act. Tightens the criteria for personal grievances claims, creates a "gateway test" for differentiating between employees and contractors.

        Controversial legislation legalising online casinos.

        Environment (Disestablishment of Ministry for the Environment) Amendment Act

        Public Service Amendment Act. Removing the public service's representation, pay equity requirements and replacing the 34 government departmental "Long-term Insights Briefings" with one produced by the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet.

        Urgent legislation allowing the Ministry of Social Development to use artificial intelligence to make decisions regarding people's welfare benefits.

        Healthy Futures (Pae Ora) Amendment Act. A 'dog whistle' that also emphasises out-sourcing care to the private sector.

        Reversing 2015 workplace safety legislative changes that were passed following the 2010 Pike River Mine disaster.

        Climate Change Response (Tort Liability) Amendment Act – Do we take requests?” Prevents lawsuits against companies for climate changing-emissions under tort law.

        Bootcamps bill passes final reading under urgency [17 Sept]

        Move-On Orders bill passes final reading under urgency [18 Sept]

        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_acts_of_the_54th_New_Zealand_Parliament

        A Dark Day For Aotearoa New Zealand Where We Have Made Poverty A Crime [Scoop.18 Sept 2026]
        “At a time where other countries, such as the United Kingdom, are decriminalising homelessness, shifting from punishment to prevention, and investing in strategies to tackle homelessness for good, our country is going backwards.”

        The nACT1 CoC are wreckers – selling off (and out) NZ Aotearoa to the Sorted.

  3. 3

    The only clue to what the nACT1 CoC would do is what the nACTf CoC has done.
    – paraphrasing R. G. Collingwood

    Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Act (Royal assent 5 June 2026)
    Urgent legislation allowing the Ministry of Social Development to use artificial intelligence to make decisions regarding people's welfare benefits.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_acts_of_the_54th_New_Zealand_Parliament


    Guy Body, in the New Zealand Herald, 3 June 2026

    New law allowing automated benefit decisions to modernise welfare system, government says [Be careful now RNZ, 30 May 2026]
    The Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill passed its third reading in Parliament on Friday, rushed through the house under urgency.
    …
    Social Development Minister Louise Upston said it would reduce delays, errors and unnecessary debt, while freeing up staff to better support clients.
    …
    Labour's Helen White on Friday said the regulatory impact statement – which summarises the law's purpose, costs and benefits – redacted the section outlining the problem the bill sought to solve, "so it is very, very difficult to know what is going on here".

    'I accept responsibility' – Louise Upston fronts on MSD failures
    [Be careful now RNZ, 11 Sept 2026]
    It was August 18 when the initial winter energy payment mistake was first reported after an error in a bill was passed through all three stages under urgency.

    The winter energy payment should have been exempt from a law change that required main beneficiaries to confirm their circumstances annually to remain eligible.

    About 10 days later RNZ revealed a second error had occurred, this time affecting people's main benefits, after the same law change, rushed through under urgency, created a backlog of paperwork that ministry staff couldn't keep up with.

    1. 3.1

      I reckon I can see what’s going on here, outsourcing the punitive behaviour (blame the AI ) and reducing the process cost (less people) all at once is a win for this coalition.

      AI works on rewards so imagine what goals they will set it.

      Neutering the OIA process is all part of it with their love of ‘commercial sensitivity ’ to hide behind.

    2. 3.2

      We shall now sing 'The Daleks, the Daleks, the Daleks are Best, so up with the Daleks and down with the rest.' Paraphrasing Flanders & Swann -'The English are Best – 'Song of Patriotic Prejudice'. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dOoStY95YZc

      Spike Milligan was born in India and that creeps into his Irish? humour. He knows about Daleks too and combines them here. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C0n88tZQc4Q

      Anything for a laugh, I think we are getting too serious about this elective round of Theatre Sports. If it's a collaborative affair let's choose who we really want to collaborate with. Come on darlings, let's away….Make it so! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FaLyasJPyUU

  4. 4

    I know I claimed to post my last ai post in my last ai post, but this exposé from House of El covers the economic story. It recaps the main events, describes the actual limits of the tech and US political manoevering by the ai bros, and summarises their precarious financial position.

    Lots of ai company info in a nutshell. End message: these folks are after pension funds to sustain their $20 bi pa losses.

    https://youtu.be/kHW3Y0gObU8?si=fjyj-fycfgazUyD-

    House of El has a whole -ai section I missed, may be worth exploring if you’re interested.

    1. 4.1

      Checkout Ed Zitron on YT a few to choose from. He covers the finance and the tech behind the LLM’s.

      Makes me think what is all this really about, uber surveillance state perhaps as cancers still with us.

  5. 6

    I went on the March for Nature yesterday in Auckland. A good turnout, although hard to fix an estimate of the numbers present – maybe 6,000.

    I expected a few politicians to turn up for the speeches at the start, but none were there (Russel Norman, ex-MP, was present). Presumably the pollies figured that only people committed to the Greens would be there so no point in attending.

    Any National MP would have got a hot reception as the main point of the gathering was the proposed changes to the Conservation Act, which will try to make conservation subordinate to commercial activities.

    If you want Maccas and coffee shops, paved roads and gondolas right throughout the back country, vote ACT or National.

  6. 7

    Under the policy, Foodstuffs and Woolworths would still be able to own both wholesale and retail, but Labour said it would use existing laws to guarantee access for smaller retailers to wholesale suppliers.

    Williams said requiring the companies to sell off their wholesale operations and become different companies would take a long time, lead to extensive litigation, and add costs. Labour’s proposed approach would not lead to short-term price rises, she said.

    https://www.stuff.co.nz/nz-news/361035764/labour-proposes-splitting-woolworths-and-foodstuffs-retail-and-wholesale-operations

    No mention of what shoppers can expect to save, though they say the policy would have immediate effect.

    In comparison, Nationals proposal to break up Foodstuffs is expected to save households between $3.85 and $25.38 a week by 2035

    https://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/companies/retail/nationals-foodstuffs-break-up-plan-how-much-it-would-save-shoppers-and-the-cost-to-supermarket-owners/premium/DWG4MXWDZFDS7KBZZMP24T7SHY/

    1. 7.1

      Can't see Labour's policy offering voters much help.

      Evidently, nor will Nationals and that's even if they go through with it.

      So we can expect the pain at the checkout to continue on.

      Oh well, perhaps the 2029 election will lead to better offerings?

    2. 7.3

      National would have a battle royal to get that done, legal costs that would be passed onto consumers as it rolls along.

      All to save $25 a week in 9 years time maybe assuming so many things line up.

      Levelling out the wholesale side is smart play from labour given foodstuffs have done what they were told not to do in that space. Allows the smaller operators a level playing field.

      No need to get into the numbers people know they're being reamed, immediate action is the key.

      1. 7.3.1

        Labour could get really unpopular (with the duopoly) and force the supermarkets to stop selling wine and beer over say 3% and say that it has become almost a monopoly, encourages alcoholism by buying that instead of sustaining food, and prevents real choice. Which is how big business operates as some of us realise. Protests can be held with banners Be Kind to Liquorland and not a word against supermarkets. Deflection of aim would rule the day.

      2. 7.3.2

        What shoppers are going to save and how soon will savings take effect is key

        Labour are largely relying on increased competition from small grocers to aggressively take on the big players, forcing them (the big players) to lower their prices.

        A very big ask that is unlikely to succeed.

        Explains why there are no expected savings given

        1. 7.3.2.1

          It’s about a level playing field at the wholesale level for the duopoly and smaller players, not extra competition.

          Priced the same for all. Imagine all those superette owners not needing to fill trolleys at P&S with milk etc could get it from wholesalers at the price foodstuffs pay.

          1. 7.3.2.1.1

            A level playing field at the wholesale to foster wider competition is the aim as far as I'm aware.

            But there seems to be nothing stopping small grocers from merely pocketing savings rather than passing them on, let alone aggressively compete.

          2. 7.3.2.1.2

            “Priced the same for all. Imagine all those superette owners not needing to fill trolleys at P&S with milk etc could get it from wholesalers at the price foodstuffs pay”

            Just want to address the above comment you made. You seem to be forgetting the current prices at P&S and such are already far too high for a growing number of people. Hence, the problem.

            Therefore, small grocers selling items at the same price isn't really going to make much difference.

            I find (from the people I've spoken with) it's the high price of meat that is one of the biggest concerns when it comes to driving up the price at the checkout

    3. 7.4

      existing laws to guarantee access for smaller retailers to wholesale suppliers

      Remember what happened to the price of broadband after Telecom wholesale was split from the retail business.

      This is a very good idea.

      In comparison, Nationals proposal to break up Foodstuffs is expected to save households between $3.85 and $25.38 a week by 2035

      And in 2023 households were going to get a $250 a fortnight tax cut, too.

      /

      1. 7.4.1

        Apples & oranges, joe.

        The Commerce Commission was used to set pricing.

        Which, after years of regulatory battles delivered a decisive win for Chorus.

        https://billbennett.co.nz/commerce-commission-copper-line-price-hike/

        Labour have made no mention of getting the Commerce Commission in to set wholesale food pricing.

        Nor have they stated there would be any regulation to prevent small grocers from merely pocketing savings rather than passing them on, let alone to go out and aggressively compete.

  7. 8

    Yup, more vitamin C will do it.

    /

    New Zealand First has released its plan to "Make NZ Healthy", promising to put prevention at the centre of healthcare if re-elected.

    […]

    Fund New Zealand scientists to assess nutritional interventions for preventing and treating mental illness

    Remove Medsafe and Pharmac barriers to "recognised safe nutrients"

    Invest in hospital trials to assess the effectiveness of intravenous vitamin C pre- and post-surgery for preventing and treating infections

    Fund a review of vitamin D and determine optimal levels for maintaining health

    https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics_election-2026/1479982/new-zealand-first-reveals-plan-for-bold-shift-in-healthcare

      1. 8.1.1

        Doubt that's the Greens, supplements are not the same as organic veges. That's rather Kennedy Jnr's MAHA schtick in the US Heath Department. Supplements, and as many of them as the grifters can supply, is the public health tool of choice there. While arguing against childhood vaccination and cutting food-safety monitoring.

        Looking next for NZF to drop a defence policy requiring mandatory testosterone testing for over-30 defence force personnel, as just rolled out for US troops by Hegseth, the Defence Secretary.

        '…screeners will check with male troops for symptoms including reduced sexual desire, erectile dysfunction or loss of spontaneous morning erections, as well as unexplained loss of muscle mass, depressed mood or low motivation, and diminished physical performance not tied to injuries.'

        Sounds like, if your Defense T is too low, you'll be forced to 'take the jab'. “What could possibly go wrong?”

        https://taskandpurpose.com/field-guide/pentagon-testosterone-male-troops-screening/

        All the stupidest trends in online nuttiness transformed into government policy.

        1. 8.1.1.1

          "screeners will check with male troops for symptoms including reduced sexual desire, erectile dysfunction or loss of spontaneous morning erections, "

          As a scool leaver in the Army, word going round Waiouru was that bromide was put in to the salt to stop these sort of occurences.

        2. 8.1.1.2

          The Greens support a holistic approach to health.

          https://www.greens.org.nz/health_policy

          I'm sure the Greens support soil health sustainability and would support researching practical alternatives to potentially harmful agricultural sprays

          I don't think the Greens would say no to providing more support for organic food producers. Do you?

          I'm sure they'd also support nurses getting fair compensation and better working conditions. Don't you think?

          Don't think they would say no to embeding good nutrition in the New Zealand curriculum. Do you?

          Vitamin use is very common in NZ. I'm sure Green supporters would makeup a number of them.

          https://www.consumer.org.nz/health/nutrition-and-supplements/why-are-natural-health-products-so-popular

          So, all in all, seems to be a lot there the Greens would support

        1. 8.2.1.1

          lol

          /

          New Zealand First appears to have copied most of its health policy from a natural health advocacy group – even going so far as to copy a typo from the group’s website into their official policy documents.

          […]

          What is Make New Zealand Healthy?

          Make New Zealand Healthy (the organisation) was founded by John Appleton and Patrick Fahy.

          Fahy is a naturopath and nutritional biochemist who develops and sells “nutritional supplements, homeopathic, natural skin care, and functional food preparations,” according to his company’s website.

          He is also the chairman of the Natural Health Alliance, a lobby group that campaigned to repeal the Therapeutic Products Act and has supported Peters and NZ First in the past.

          […]

          Meanwhile, Appleton describes himself as having “[studied] nutritional medicine attempting to find answers to difficult questions” for 23 years, and distributes nutritional supplements via an online store.

          Neither appear to be doctors, although two Auckland-based health specialists- a GP and a chiropractor – are listed as co-trustees and advisers.

          https://www.stuff.co.nz/politics/361036430/nz-firsts-health-policy-copy-pasted-advocacy-groups-website

          https://makenewzealandhealthy.co.nz/about-us/

          1. 8.2.1.1.1

            Covering the base….

            Three of the four doctors have previously appeared in the news: Dr Damian Wojcik for posting anti-vaccination beliefs online, Dr Tim Ewer for prescribing minerals, herbs and supplements to a boy battling cancer, and Dr Glen Davies for leaving his Taupō medical centre after a disagreement over the Government’s vaccine mandates the year after he won General Practitioner of the Year.

            Also on the board is Guy Hatchard, a prominent voice in New Zealand’s anti-vaccination movement.

            https://www.stuff.co.nz/politics/361036430/nz-firsts-health-policy-copy-pasted-advocacy-groups-website

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *