Luxon's first answer in the debate was about supporting Ukraine. Ironic. Now, I doubt that he really means to axe that support, but Hipkins/Tame didn't challenge him on it. They should have. Of course, this is not a serious policy proposal, it's only a cynical headline-grabber, which is why there ...
It doesn't make sense anyway. Scenario: Bloc A: 59 Bloc B: 51 TOP: 10. (For simple maths, we'll ignore overhang). But within Bloc B Lab/Nat have a few more votes than Nat/Lab in the other Bloc. Good luck sticking with the "largest party" line. It wouldn't wash.
People believe the Greens on that (as they believe ACT ruling out Labour). Those positions are clear and honest, based on fundamental differences. It's the fake "rule out" that irritates, although the media are as much to blame as the politicians. Key ruled out NZF in 2008 for tactical reasons, ...
Well, I stuck with it to the end. The media love a "game-changer" but this wasn't. The voters at TVNZ gave it to Hipkins, not sure that means much. So superficial though. Example: At the end they got onto the Middle East and Tame didn't want anything except yes/no. Not exploring beyond that. Same ...
TBH I'm as much annoyed by the format as the politicians. Having these percentages from voters during the debate is just silly (even though it has favoured Hipkins, it's not what a debate should be).
It will probably get lost in the noise but in the debate Luxon just said "Trump's crazy war in Iran". Wow. That is one heck of a shift from Luxon's take when that war began. (Hipkins and Tame let it slide, pity).
Obviously. But not my point. "The opposition need Opportunity" is not true. So it's not necessary to try to get them over 5% for tactical reasons only. Which is not the same as voting for their policies. We can guess at who Opportunity would go with (influenced by our own preferences, probably). ...
They've got half an hour before the TV audience switch to Taskmaster. Politics tragics like us might prefer the debate show, but most voters will be tuning out after the 17th "What I would say to you ...".
The other story is that left-leaning voters should stop fretting about Opportunity, because if they do get 4.9% the combined opposition are ahead of the coalition, after wasted votes. (Of course that is very changeable, but the claim that TOP have to be there to change the government isn't true. ...
Headlines like "up 3, down 2" are meaningless without context. Usually a poll is published months after the last one (by the same outfit), so it's the movement over a long period. But the last TVNZ poll was just last week, so major shifts are unlikely. I confidently expect to be shouting at the TV ...
Luxon's personal numbers are dismal (Hipkins' numbers are mediocre). The fun now is in the bickering on the Right. It will get very nasty, as they argue about tactics and tetchy thin-skinned Luxon doubles and triples down (his only response setting).
Frankly that's a ridiculous quote from a typically poor column by Jo Moir. The "both sides" cop-out won't wash. It's literally her job to report facts and call out lies. Which she rarely does. When Luxon/Willis/Brown lie, Hipkins should say so. And Moir's comment about "hindsight" is laughable. ...
But it's a lot more than that. Useful info about how other people vote and why, which is pretty much what an election campaign is. See the responses (so far) on the environment, mining, etc. The government is way out of step even with those who support other rightwing policies.
The compass includes a weighting option, which helps to clarify our vote. There may be people who think the NZF position on gender, for a bill that wasn't important enough to the government to become law inside 3 years, is far more important than NZF voting for the scrapping of pay equity, a move ...
The TVNZ Vote Compass is up and running. See which party is closest to you. You've probably done these before, they are used worldwide and it's fair to say they vary in depth and precision (I was Nelson Mandela in one, Gordon Brown in another. Hmm). This one delivered an accurate result for me, and ...
Concentrating resources on winning the Māori electorates and encouraging supporters to give their party votes elsewhere is a comprehensible strategy. Whether voters actually behave that way, and what parliamentary arithmetic consequently emerges, is another question entirely. They already do behave ...
If anyone wants to guess which electorates National will hold/lose/gain, this is useful. (It's not the full results which provide more detail, but a simple at-a-glance check of the seats): E9 Statistics - Electorate Status Go down the list and try and find 12 seats for National to lose. Shows how ...
This is another of the "Vote Nat to dump a Nat" seats. I'm not suggesting that most voters will or should play that game, but it is an option. If National gain the seat that is one more electorate and one fewer Cabinet Minister off the list. A very possible outcome.
As always, the problem is not only Luxon being wrong, but the extraordinary ham-fisted, tetchy, sarcastic response when he is asked about it: Election 2026 live: Luxon questioned over '9 new taxes', MPs remember former Adrian Rurawhe | RNZ (scroll down the link to the story) "Asked for evidence on ...
Luxon did a policy announcement today, with Carlos Cheung (Mt Roskill ultra-marginal) standing alongside him. (The clip is in various media). "Mr Luxon, you need him to lose, don't you?" was the question begging to be asked. Maybe some reporter did, but if so it was overlooked. The press pack are as ...
I'm sure I'm not alone in being tempted (if this were my electorate) to vote Melissa Lee to oust Willis and co. But I'm also sure that in the end I'd resist that temptation and pick the MP I genuinely want. The armchair calculations by Bomber overlook the psychological or emotional factor. When we ...
He delivered a few shots in foot (for the coalition, not him personally). Luxon is not in the same league as Clark, Bolger, Ardern (not named but implied). The disdain extends to Hipkins as well but that bridge is burnt so it doesn't matter. Admitting that your current boss is a 3rd rate PM, that ...
All that really matters for this campaign is that there is now open warfare between people on the Right. This stops National rising in the polls. Mowbray and various self-appointed strategists, versus Luxon, Key, DPF etc. Two opposite approaches. Let's hope they keep at it.
No doubt your first two sentences are correct. But it's hard to see many of those voters saying "I was thinking of voting Labour, and can accept former Covid minister Hipkins becoming PM again, but can't accept seeing somebody who isn't even in Parliament and won't be."
The media are slowly coming to grips with the new reality of this election. A good overview here from Stuff: Nicola Willis, Chris Bishop among top ministers who could lose their seats as election overhang possible | Stuff Tim Hurdle (Nat) says: “So some of the seats like Mt Roskill and Banks ...
A classic case of political partisans mistakenly assuming that the voters think the same way. Nobody says "I will or won't vote for Party X because of Mallard". People commenting on political blogs might, but we're fringe fruit loops. Irrelevant.
There won't be a clean government formation unless the current lot get a clear majority. We don't want that, obviously. Time taken to form a government doesn't matter. There won't be a result until Nov 27. Negotiations will continue after that. NZF are only going one way, so they are irrelevant. The ...
I agree with Weka's OP and disagree with Ad and Sanc. (Though I won't be voting for Opp). Much better to have a party that can work with the 3 left (ish) parties while staying out of government, or - worst case scenario - can limit a government of the Right from doing even further damage to our ...
For the (broad) left Mt Albert is win-win-win. If it stays Labour, fine. If it goes Green (unlikely), great. If it goes Opportunity that's a major shock, but still one that hurts the Right. If Melissa Lee wins it then she replaces Willis or Bishop, Goldsmith, etc. National's nightmare.