I think my main concern about this scenario is methodological. Your model appears to assume that National's electorate candidates will systematically outperform the party vote, including in marginal seats won during the 2023 national swing. Split voting certainly happens, but electorate outcomes are ...
Agreed. The lack of electorate-level polling makes it tricky, but what we do know seems to support the theory that an overhang is highly contingent , rather than something parties can reliably manufacture. There are also quite a few marginal electorates National will struggle to hang onto. Some ...
Winston Peters went after Labour pretty hard in 2020, despite being, ostensibly, Deputy Prime Minister. He publicly questioned Labour's competence and experience, claimed credit for blocking its capital gains tax and Auckland light rail proposals, and campaigned on NZ First being a necessary ...
Nah, there's nothing particularly extraordinary about coalition partners trying to distance themselves from an unpopular government. ACT is clearly trying to make Luxon the scapegoat for the unpopularity of a policy programme they've spent the last three years championing, much as they've spent ...
Or we could just accept that the system is good enough. No electoral system is perfectly immune to gaming, and MMP already makes it pretty difficult. A deliberate overhang might be a viable strategy once every 50 years, and even then there's no guarantee it would work. Electoral systems should be ...
Which would be fine, if people could reliably distinguish Zionism from Judaism, agree on what it actually means, and avoid treating any support for Israel as Zionism. Without those distinctions, criticism of a political ideology can all too easily become a blanket judgement of people whose actual ...
I think there's a fundamental problem with this forecast. It assumes that increasing daily fixed charges automatically means consumers will pay more overall, but that's not necessarily the case. I work for an electricity distribution business, and one of the interesting things we found when ...
shrug That's one of the drawbacks of parliamentary sovereignty. Parliament can't ultimately bind its successors, and even the electoral entrenchment provisions aren't themselves entrenched. There's no general exceptional circumstances exemption to the 75% requirement, either. And I'd be very wary of ...
Which is entirely contingent on the left winning the election in the first place, rather than spending the final week wringing our hands about how imperfect Labour and Hipkins are.
I think you've gone well past sensible analysis and into wishcasting about how you'd prefer economic policy to work, rather than engaging with the political constraints under which it actually operates. Yes, austerity sucks, both in human and economic terms. There's a substantial mainstream economic ...
My concern with all this handwringing is that it conflates what is politically desirable with what is electorally achievable. I'd also like to see Labour be more ambitious in its policy agenda. But I recognise that a substantial proportion of the voters Labour needs to win over don't necessarily ...
Insofar as losing an election and their jobs, while undermining the case for privatisation for a generation, is merely a temporary setback, sure. 'Tis but a flesh wound!
Profit, of course. But there's a difference between transferring public money into private hands and securing public consent for privatisation. The latter requires delegitimising the public system. And while the public can see that the system is struggling, they can also see who's holding the ...
Sure, Deus ex Brownia is possible. But Occam's Razor suggests a rather more mundane explanation. The simplest story is that this government is populated by a) ideological zealots and b) incompetents. And the Venn diagram between those two groups is basically a circle. Because if there really is some ...
tWig, I think you're arguing against a position I haven't actually taken. Of course personality matters. I've never suggested otherwise. But personality doesn't operate in a vacuum, and it certainly doesn't explain electoral behaviour all by itself. Its significance depends on the political context. ...
In which case, yes, Labour could potentially invoke the waka-jumping law. However, I don't see why they would. Leoni would presumably continue to support any hypothetical Labour-led government, so what would Labour actually gain? Why start a new government by forcing out an MP over something they ...
Not much they can do, really. Parliament is sovereign. The courts can declare legislation inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act, but they can't strike it down or prevent it from taking effect.
The party-hopping law only applies to MPs elected as representatives of a political party, whether through the party list or an electorate. If Leoni wins as an independent, she'll be an independent electorate MP, so Labour won't be able to use the law to challenge her seat. There's nothing to stop ...
So your answer to the problem of personality politics is to just, what, give up? Accept that substance matters less than image, and start searching for the next political celebrity? The irony here is extraordinary. You're lamenting the arrival of American-style personality politics while ...
Of course teachers are required to teach the prescribed curriculum and comply with Ministry of Education requirements. Nobody is disputing that. But teachers are also trained professionals, with expertise and professional judgement that extend well beyond simply following political directives. ...
A politician doing politics while leading a political party and following a political strategy? Quelle horreur! Such a phenomenon has never before occurred in New Zealand's political history.
There could, potentially, be a party leader outside Parliament – though I can't see it working well. Didn't that happen with ACT at one stage? It did: Mr Incest himself, Jamie Whyte. Also with NZ First (Winston), and the Greens. Although the Greens are the more interesting example, because they ...
As an interesting comparative study: National: The leader is elected by caucus. Hence their love of leadership coups. ACT: The arrangements are a little more interesting. The leader is appointed by the board, but once the party has at least five MPs, a caucus majority can direct a leadership change ...
I really don't see much difference between a leader being appointed by a board and one being elected by caucus. Both can be replaced, and we don't go into every election worrying that Labour, National or the Greens will suddenly change leaders afterwards, even though they all have mechanisms for ...
I agree with a lot of what MT says here, particularly about the wider political and media environment, and I think the concerns about coalition uncertainty are legitimate. But I think there's an important question missing from the analysis: Why TOP and not Labour? There's a lot of discussion about ...
Nothing else matters apart from changing the government. To you, perhaps. But TOP's voters have made a different, equally legitimate decision about their own political priorities.
Why are we still having this argument about whether TOP is valid? It obviously is. Our fellow citizens have decided so. And rather than accepting that fact, and the voting intentions of a not-insignificant chunk of the electorate, we keep coming up with increasingly elaborate theories about why ...
To be fair, every political movement is opportunistic to some degree. But I think there's a more interesting question here. The electorate isn't static, and neither are the political spaces parties attempt to occupy. There's a push-and-pull relationship between voter demand and political supply. ...
Finally, an actual cogent fucking argument about TOP that isn't finger-wagging about its desire to exist independently of Labour, or hand-wringing over its many and nefarious crimes: being attractive to centrist voters, releasing policy early in the election cycle, having a political strategy, ...