Search Results » @author Belladonna
-
Comment on Open Mike 26/09/2026
Also, even in clear cases of sexual assault, women are frequently very reluctant to engage in or pursue a criminal case. The process all too often results in revictimizatuon through the court system. Without a victim who is prepared to make and follow …
-
Comment on Open Mike 25/09/2026
And the primary reason why AI models are horrifically risky when used for mental health support. They’re risky to rely on, uncritically, anywhere – but mental health has resulted in real tragedies.
-
Comment on Open Mike 25/09/2026
Good luck. It’s out of stock at the NZ suppliers. https://www.batemanbooks.co.nz/?s=dirty+work&search_id=7&post_type=product
-
Comment on Unmasking the TaxPayers Union as the Tobacco Protection Union
Interesting that you’ve now moved from this is a “truth book” to agreeing with me that this is political opinion. Please note that I haven’t dismissed anything. Political opinion is entirely valid, and a well-recognized tool for shifting debate. I’ve never …
-
Comment on Unmasking the TaxPayers Union as the Tobacco Protection Union
There is no need to include ‘necessarily’ in my statement “Sales and readership don’t equate to a change in opinion” The two things are not related. Opinions can change regardless of whether people buy a book, or even read it. Media coverage can be an …
-
Comment on Open Mike 25/09/2026
It seems astounding to me that Wigram is a two horse race at all. For generations it’s been a bastion of the Left. And the profile as outlined in the article is predominantly young and ethnically diverse – albeit with low voter enrollment. Not exactly …
-
Comment on Open Mike 25/09/2026
Given that his first line is a confession he hasn’t read it, it makes it difficult for anyone to take him seriously in reviewing it. If anything, he’s reviewing the press coverage…..
-
Comment on Open Mike 25/09/2026
And, the assumption that Luxon will be in charge. Even if National/ACT/NZF are able to form a coalition (with or without TOP) – I forsee a night of the long knives coming for Luxon after November.
-
Comment on Hager’s next book
So, to use my relevant example. Do you think that Gardiner-Hopkins is also an ACT supporter? I highly doubt it. Examples of misogynistic culture abound across the political spectrum. If you (as in Hager) want NZ to be debating the political actions and …
-
Comment on Hager’s next book
Just look at how much of the commentary here and in the media has been focused on the allegations. And therefore not debating the political influence of TPU. And imagine that being replicated across NZ. Was that the desired outcome that Hager was looking …
-
Comment on Hager’s next book
However the sexual conduct allegation isn’t why Hager is writing the book – it’s the political implications of the TPU. Would Hager have written a book about James Gardner-Hopkins? I doubt it (and, in fact he hasn’t). Would Hager have been just as outraged …
-
Comment on Unmasking the TaxPayers Union as the Tobacco Protection Union
I was asked about the specific claim that he’s mentioned he’s not rock solid on. He mentions two or three things in your quote above. The only evidence that we have that his witnesses are “really reliable people” is Hager’s assessment. And the accusation …
-
Comment on Unmasking the TaxPayers Union as the Tobacco Protection Union
Most legal cases in court are decided on the credibility of witnesses and their statements of what they thought that they are on documentation. I agree. However, I’m not the one claiming that this was a “truth book”. So far as I’m aware, none of the …
-
Comment on Unmasking the TaxPayers Union as the Tobacco Protection Union
It’s mentioned in the article. The book also claimed co-founder David Farrar used access to a National election database to send mailouts to homes occupied by “wealthy National and ACT voters”. Williams said this was “totally wrong”. “I’m going to dig out …
-
Comment on Unmasking the TaxPayers Union as the Tobacco Protection Union
In which case this is not, and cannot be a ‘truth’ book. There is (reportedly) an awful lot of opinion, i.e. interpretation of facts which themselves may or may not be entirely accurate – given that they are recollections, rather than documentary evidence. …
-
Comment on Unmasking the TaxPayers Union as the Tobacco Protection Union
The article appears to be hyperbole (since there were certainly copies available in Auckland, where the radio station, and presumably HDPA are based) And, it would be a breach of copyright to photocopy the whole book (and not one any journalist is going to …
-
Comment on Unmasking the TaxPayers Union as the Tobacco Protection Union
I was simply making the point that readership numbers and/or book purchases – don’t necessarily result in people changing their opinions. Your opinion is that this is a “truth book”; other people will have different opinions. Or are you seriously arguing …
-
Comment on Unmasking the TaxPayers Union as the Tobacco Protection Union
I think that ‘people don’t care’ is a little more nuanced – than they can’t be bothered to read it. Sales and readership don’t equate to a change in opinion. People like ‘shock’ books (isn’t everything awful, and look how horrible the world is) – hence the …
-
Comment on Hager’s next book
TPU are much more ACT than National.
-
Comment on Hager’s next book
I don’t agree that they are necessarily related. People can have appalling politics and dodgy business ethics, but have entirely respectable personal behaviour; and vice versa. Harger wouldn’t have written a book about Williams if the sexual assault …
-
Comment on Hager’s next book
I think that Hager has made a tactical error in including allegations against Williams and Farrer, personally. Its resulted in a whole lot of media coverage of the ‘he’s lying’, no ‘he is’ variety. Which takes away from the serious political issue of how …
-
Comment on Hager’s next book
If an allegation of sexual misconduct was made against you. What do you respond, apart from ‘no there wasn’t’? If you don’t know who, when or what – how do you provide the evidence?
-
Comment on Hager’s next book
You absolutely can list a book on bookseller websites with a default title, like “Untitled”. So long as it has a unique ISBN – it can be listed. It’s the ISBN (international standard book number), which is unique to each edition, which is actually used for …
-
Comment on Hager’s next book
Equally, though, if those allegations are as demonstrably false as his subjects are claiming, there is a fairly obvious way to rebut them: produce the evidence that demonstrates that. In effect, trying to prove a negative – notoriously a difficult …
-
Comment on Is the Opportunity Party left wing?
I think there is a difference in negotiating on policies that were actively campaigned on by other parties, where Labour is neutral, or has a complimentary policy. However, the GP and TOP position on tax is directly opposed to the Labour policy. I don’t …
-
Comment on Hager’s next book
Difficult to see what can be leaked using an author, a title an ISBN (the standard number used for book supply) and a publisher name. That’s all that’s needed for booksellers to pre-order their copies for delivery on the publication date. Everything except …
-
Comment on Daily review 22/09/2026
The strikers get to feel superior, while their lives and civilization continue to be supported by the essential workers doing their jobs.
-
Comment on Daily review 22/09/2026
Does that include doctors, nurses, sanitation and electrical workers?
-
Comment on Hager’s next book
It’s a bit weird. It’s not listed on the publisher’s website – so it won’t be included in any of the aggregator feeds that inform bookshops. Its not on the websites of either Whitcoulls or Unity (which is more than a bit surprising). I wonder if its been …
-
Comment on Is the Opportunity Party left wing?
However, it would leave Labour forever after on the back foot in election campaigns. Their weak spot – successfully attacked by National (fairly or otherwise) is taxes. Which is why Hipkins is so sensitive. Given that he’s campaigned on no new taxes (apart …