1. Comment on Open Mike 23/09/2026

    Yes – and naturally the NZ Initiative frames any of the suggested structural changes to the supermarket industry as a property rights infringement. Wagging their finger disapprovingly at us, and trying to make sure that supermarkets are not going to be …

  2. Comment on Unmasking the TaxPayers Union as the Tobacco Protection Union

    Agreed – but it can’t only be the tobacco industry. That wouldn’t explain why the TPU were so determined to kill 3Waters. It seems to me that there are three possible reasons why the TPU so cynically and easily leveraged provincial anti-Maori sentiment to …

  3. Comment on Hager’s next book

    will never be considered anything more than counter-culture. Probably so – which is sort of weird. Because for some of us, the book is just providing the detail of what we always assumed was the case. Because this is how capital behaves at all times and …

  4. Comment on Open Mike 22/09/2026

    I’d agree that in the long run it would be a good idea to end private residential landlordlism. It is a socially unnecessary extractive layer within the housing market that drives inequality both in the present and inter-generationally. It also diverts …

  5. Comment on Is the Opportunity Party left wing?

    OPP has policies. At present, more of them would fit with a Left(ish) coalition than they would with a Right coalition. (See Ad at no.5 above). Some of them have oversights, holes, inconsistencies and perversities (see Weka at 4.1.1.1) which reflect the …

  6. Comment on Comrade Christopher and the breakup of Foodstuffs

    Yes – it’s not a problem with the structure of the market, it’s an ownership problem. To imagine that it can be solved by more competition via a third privately-owned player, is to assume that a market actually behaves like it claims to on the packet. You …

  7. Comment on Open Mike 17/09/2026

    Fundamentally the flywheel of economic prosperity is simple. If we save more, we invest more. If we invest more, we make more money. That sounds boosterishly wonderful. But I have a few random doubts that may or may not make sense: If we save more, we …

  8. Comment on Open Mike 16/09/2026

    They’ve announced the announcement of the conclusions of an investigation. It doesn’t get more action-oriented than that – surely? This is what I would expect from Luxon, a man whose behaviour is most charactised by what I would call “performative high …

  9. Comment on Open Mike 15/09/2026

    We all know that a phone call from National Party leadership is all that it takes for a neophyte National candidate to reinterpret the evidence and come to a different conclusion. Lloyd Budd is the anti-Galileo – someone forced by a higher authority to …

  10. Comment on War Without Shooting When They Used To Be Allies

    Anybody who ever thought that The Monroe Doctrine would always look only to the south, wasn’t paying attention. A nation that thinks such a thing as The Monroe Doctrine was in any way a legitimate expression of their national interest, is dangerously …

  11. Comment on The robots are coming to get us

    As AI agents become capable of taking actions rather than simply producing text, the systems around them need to enforce what they’re allowed to do. You can’t assume the AI will understand and respect a boundary simply because that’s where you intended …

  12. Comment on Why does National despise the poor?

    Why does National despise the poor? Because it is both ideologically and psychologically necessary for them to do so. If their own life success and relative affluence is to be protected from even moderate levels of taxation by the State, it must be viewed …

  13. Comment on Why does National despise the poor?

    This suggests that we have a rather cruel way of distributing resources. It is called a market, goods and services are rationed by the ability to pay.

  14. Comment on Why does National despise the poor?

    “But we live in an absolute food basket. We produce enough food to feed eight times our population”. There is no ‘we’. This is not a country, it’s a private investor-led economic zone.

  15. Comment on Taxpayers Union hides its funding

    Unless we have the courage to say that democracy actually means the equal influence of every citizen over electoral outcomes, we may as well go and die in a hole of our own making. Implement that principle in whatever damn way it works best.

  16. Comment on Taxpayers Union hides its funding

    Limiting their ability to release political polls is an improvement. You rightly raise the wider question of the TPU (or any big donor) poisoning the well of public discourse in some other way. None of what I suggested is done with an assumption that all …

  17. Comment on Taxpayers Union hides its funding

    Yes it will – but that has to be accepted to get any legislative control over the whole donation and campaign financing sh*tshow. The principle here is the core democratic one of “equal influence over outcomes”.

  18. Comment on Taxpayers Union hides its funding

    Political donations and campaign financing are in urgent need of reform. Possible foundational points in such a reform – first thoughts anyway: all donations must come from named individuals who are enrolled on the NZ electoral roll. cap these donations …

  19. Comment on Open Mike 08/09/2026

    There’s an interesting contradiction happening. People on the left are demanding Labour release more policy, while at the same time forgetting half the policy Labour have already announced. And when a policy is announced (as with the Greens supermarket …

  20. Comment on Open Mike 06/09/2026

    Good work Ad. I hear that the Bayeux tapestry can de damaged at illumination above 50 lux. By the time I get to the local shops I am feeling quite unwell by exposure to only about 20 Lux on so many billboards. They obviously have truckloads of money. So, …

  21. Comment on Government makes Move On Orders Bill less shit

    It’s an improvement, but the problem remains. The move on policy has some public appeal because people don’t like the centres of their towns and cities feelng and looking like crap. Homeless people, boarded up shops, shabbily-dressed people hunting for …

  22. Comment on Open Mike 03/09/2026

    Once you start looking for ‘ideological positions’ in any corpus of compulsory professional education, you’re likely to find them all over the place, if you’re clever enough. So that in practice, any professional education will contain enough assumptions …

  23. Comment on Open Mike 02/09/2026

    The same story as automated checkout terminals in supermarkets. The jobs will go but the food prices will neither go down nor go up more slowly. These places are gigantic money-siphons.

  24. Comment on Labour will guarantee a job for graduate nurses

    Dear Sanctuary Anyone between the ages of 27 and 41, with a partner of the same age plus or minus 5 years (of whom both must be in full time work, or one in full time work and the other working more than 15 hours.week), a minimum of three children of whom …

  25. Comment on Open Mike 02/09/2026

    Andrew Dickson on the role David Seymour’s attendance targets may have played in the current flu epidemic. (https://andrewdicksonnz.substack.com/p/crouching-bureaucrat-hidden-ideologue) Perhaps Mr Seymour was frustrated and angered by the non-death of so …

  26. Comment on Open Mike 01/09/2026

    that a government increasing taxes will make inflation worse That’s an interesting take, and I see why you make it. If taxation takes the form of regressive levies that everyone has to pay, yes – it does increase inflation because some things cost more …

  27. Comment on The Government suddenly wants to limit the damage it has caused to our climate response

    As far as I know, the payments go to offshore providers of carbon credits who do things like plant trees to sequester carbon emissions. How credible these providers are and whether they really achieve what they claim to, who knows? It would be far better …

  28. Comment on The Government suddenly wants to limit the damage it has caused to our climate response

    “And they cannot avoid having to pay for excess emissions.” I would have thought the logical place that their inaction leads to is reneging on our Paris Agreement commitments precisely to avoid making those payments and effectively withdrawing from the …

  29. Comment on Open Mike 29/08/2026

    I think that’s right and I’d assume that the trade-off calculation for this policy goes something like this: 1.) Sickness beneficiaries will be better off than they were by getting 3 free visits, but not as well off as they need to be in terms of access to …

  30. Comment on Open Mike 27/08/2026

    Oh – (Sir) Ian Taylor frothing with excitement at suddenly realising something that anyone with half a brain saw instantly years ago. Specifically, that when Seymour states that the basis of Maori rights under the Treaty is ‘race’ rather than indigeneity, …